The Auto Enthusiast's Realistic Christmas Wish List for the North American Auto Industry in 2020
French hot hatches. Affordable full-size wagons. Manual-shift rear-wheel-drive sports sedans under $30,000. Production versions of the Chevrolet Code 130R, Dodge Hornet, and Ford Start. The reincarnation of Isuzu’s VehiCROSS and Trooper. Standard-of-the-world Cadillac sedans and ordinary BMWs that drive as well as modern Cadillacs. A hiatus on coupe funerals.
My unrealistic auto writer’s Christmas wish list could go on forever. Much of it is based on nostalgia. Some of it simply isn’t cognizant of current market trends. A healthy portion of it simply denies the lack of performance-oriented interest among 2020’s car buyers. The remainder shows a lack of gratitude for the spectacular automotive era in which we live.
But what about realistic hopes of what could be gifted to the auto enthusiast community in the new decade?
This is my realistic Christmas wish list for 2020, not for me personally but rather for the North American auto industry as a whole.
You’re familiar with vehicles such as the Honda Civic Si, Subaru Impreza WRX STI, and Volkswagen Golf GTI. The time has come. Let’s have a CR-V Si, a RAV4 TRD, a Tiguan GLI, and a Rogue SE-R. Power is easy, but don’t forget the brakes, suspension, wheels, tires, front fascia, and seat bolsters.
Unfortunately, Suburbans are terrifyingly costly. Since 2000, a four-wheel-drive Suburban’s base price has risen 29 percent when adjusted for inflation. De-content it, de-chrome it, run the prior generation as a “Classic” model – I don’t care. Just offer an entry-level Suburban for under $45,000, rather than over $55,000.
No, it’s not just the grilles. The X2 is ill-proportioned everywhere. The 7-Series doesn’t appear athletic. The Z4’s headlights search in vain for a connection to the grille. And yeah, okay, the grilles are an affront to good taste.
That means a Spark-like $13,400 and not a Fit-like $16,190. Doesn’t sound like a big gap? It’s a 21-percent difference that drives subcompact-intending Fit, Fiesta, and Sonic buyers into Civics, EcoSports, and, well, Sparks.
That leaves the general population under the mistaken impression that these mildly elevated cars, with their roof rails and wheel-arch cladding, went to the same school. Urban Utility Vehicle? That’s probably too much of a mouthful.
Mind you, Detroit’s truck innovation has not been slowed by a dearth of outside competition. But in a hugely consequential segment that produces over 200,000 monthly U.S. sales during a pandemic, it seems odd that there is so little viable competition. If the Tundra’s ever going to become a factor, it can’t merely be competitive. It needs to be better.
True, Toyota sold fewer than 15,000 FJ Cruisers per year in its final six years on the market, but more than 55,000 were sold in each of its first two years on the market. And while Nissan Xterra sales dropped below 20,000 units in each of its last five years, Nissan averaged 75,000 annual Xterra sales between 2000 and 2006. With a new Frontier, can we have a new Xterra?
Mazda’s CX-7, reborn with true performance credentials and improved cabin space, would suit Mazda’s range well as a challenger for the Edge, Murano, Passport, and Blazer. Might a rugged, small, affordable, body-on-frame GM SUV fare well in a battle with the Ford Bronco Sport? It’s time for a new Chevrolet Tracker. The first Dodge Nitro was fairly awful, but if FCA restyled the Cherokee or Compass just so, it would certainly fill a void.
With off-the-charts margins and insatiable demand, shouldn’t one premium brand or another be able to figure out a way around the enduring conundrum that pits rugged appeal against the paranoia of poseur pickups? If not Lincoln or Cadillac, what about Land Rover or Lexus?
[Images courtesy of the manufacturers]
Timothy Cain is a contributing analyst at The Truth About Cars and Driving.ca and the founder and former editor of GoodCarBadCar.net. Follow on Twitter @timcaincars and Instagram.
More by Timothy Cain
Latest Car Reviews
Read moreLatest Product Reviews
Read moreRecent Comments
- Mebgardner I owned 4 different Z cars beginning with a 1970 model. I could already row'em before buying the first one. They were light, fast, well powered, RWD, good suspenders, and I loved working on them myself when needed. Affordable and great styling, too. On the flip side, parts were expensive and mostly only available in a dealers parts dept. I could live with those same attributes today, but those days are gone long gone. Safety Regulations and Import Regulations, while good things, will not allow for these car attributes at the price point I bought them at.I think I will go shop a GT-R.
- Lou_BC Honda plans on investing 15 billion CAD. It appears that the Ontario government and Federal government will provide tax breaks and infrastructure upgrades to the tune of 5 billion CAD. This will cover all manufacturing including a battery plant. Honda feels they'll save 20% on production costs having it all localized and in house.As @ Analoggrotto pointed out, another brilliant TTAC press release.
- 28-Cars-Later "Its cautious approach, which, along with Toyota’s, was criticized for being too slow, is now proving prescient"A little off topic, but where are these critics today and why aren't they being shamed? Why are their lunkheaded comments being memory holed? 'Who controls the past controls the future. Who controls the present controls the past.' -Orwell, 1984
- Tane94 A CVT is not the kiss of death but Nissan erred in putting CVTs in vehicles that should have had conventional automatics. Glad to see the Murano is FINALLY being redesigned. Nostalgia is great but please drop the Z car -- its ultra-low sales volume does not merit continued production. Redirect the $$$ into small and midsize CUVs/SUVs.
- Analoggrotto Another brilliant press release.
Comments
Join the conversation
Mine are all pretty simple and cheap. Except for the last one. 1. De "angry bug" car/SUV styling. 1A. Enough with the giant damn grills! 2. Any car that has Stop/Start must have a simple way to set the default on it to "Off". I've driven a couple of cars with it, and it's just annoying. 3. Make it when using remote start that the heat comes on full blast if desired to thaw out the door mechanisms, and start the ice melting. Last week my car took several tries to open over two remote start cycles. 4.Kill the ugly ugly Camaro, and bring it back so it looks like a 2nd Gen one, with a little more greenhouse, and a usable trunk. I have the money if you do it right, but after seeing the present "stuff", I wonder if it can be done?
A new STI that sets / resets the standard, just like the original..