EU Launches Emissions Collusion Investigation Against German Automakers

Matt Posky
by Matt Posky
eu launches emissions collusion investigation against german automakers

Roughly one year ago, German automakers were confronted with a crisis. Following Volkswagen’s diesel emissions fiasco, European antitrust regulators became suspicious that BMW, Daimler, and VW Group were involved in a longstanding automotive cartel that cooperated on decisions regarding technical issues, development, supplier management, and illegal price fixing. Investigators were also concerned manufacturers worked together to standardize diesel treatment fluid (AdBlue) reservoirs to reduce exhaust emissions, then encouraged each other to cheat on emissions tests when they were deemed insufficient.

This resulted in a series of raids and then almost a full year of silence on the matter. However, if Volkswagen’s dieselgate has taught us anything, it’s that German authorities prefer a snail’s pace when pursuing a criminal probe.

Apparently unsatisfied with the initial findings, the European Commission opened an in-depth and official investigation on Tuesday against the “circle of five,” a group that includes Audi, VW, Porsche, Daimler, and BMW. The quintet is accused of holding meetings where they colluded to limit the development and application of certain emissions control systems for cars sold in Europe. There’s also an accusation of price fixing.

“These technologies aim at making passenger cars less damaging to the environment. If proven, this collusion may have denied consumers the opportunity to buy less polluting cars, despite the technology being available to the manufacturers,” European Competition Commissioner Margrethe Vestager said, according to Reuters.

The good news, at least for the automakers, is that the previous probe yielded no signs that the companies illegally coordinated with each other in the use of defeat devices to cheat regulatory testing. Investigators also said that, while the companies are believed to have discussed common requirements for car parts and testing procedures, there was nothing to prove it was flagrantly anti-competitive.

That makes this whole thing a little confusing. Daimler and Volkswagen have already claimed whistleblower status to avoid any potential fines and all German automakers have said they’ll cooperate with the EU’s investigation. However, with no new evidence other than proof that meetings took place, the anti-trust probe looks a little bit like a witch hunt. That doesn’t mean the manufacturers should be exempt from suspicion; some are “whistleblowing,” after all. But we should still remind ourselves that the EU really has it out for diesel right now.

“The automotive industry was once a jewel in Europe’s industrial crown, but its global reputation is now deeply tarnished and cannot be trusted anymore,” said Greg Archer, director of the green Transport & Environment campaign. “It has become its own worst enemy and needs regulators to act with strength and decisiveness to clean it up and establish rules that put it on a path to zero emissions.”

Depending on how much you support the cause, such a path could mandate bullying automakers to adopt alternative energy vehicles and give up on the frustrations associated with diesel. Then again, carmakers have been known to circumvent the rules.

The companies could face fines of up to 10 percent of their global turnover if convicted of actively engaging in a corporate conspiracy. But that seems like a long way off at this point. Expect more raids in the coming months, followed by another bout of silence before regulators decide whether or not to prosecute.

Join the conversation
 1 comment
  • Carrera The diesels built during the last 10-15 years, if kept stock, don't really stink at all.
  • MaintenanceCosts I keep finding myself drawn to the Fox PLCs, both the Thunderbird and the Mark VII. They really got the design right by 1980s standards. The cars were reasonably sized but didn't look dinky like the 1986 Eldorado, they were comfortable and drove pretty well, and they were available with a 302 (that even got non-asthmatic in the late years).When I bought my first car - a 1987 Taurus - I also thought about Aerobirds, but I decided (probably correctly, given the number of carpools I was part of) that I wanted four doors.
  • SaraJumra Everyone can make money now a days very easily. I am a full time college student and just w0rking for 3 to 4 hrs a day. Everybody must try this home online job now by just useThis Following Website.-------->>
  • SaraJumra hwllo hy
  • MaintenanceCosts Where's a gas inline six, for that torque and nice sound without all the diesel stink? Oh, that's right; GM being GM, they prematurely canceled it.