By on June 11, 2013

When Spyker sued GM for mucking with Saab’s failed deal with Youngman, and wanted $3 billion for its trouble, TTAC’s resident garage lawyers did not give Spyker big odds.

Yesterday, the suit was thrown out.

A U.S. federal judge said the GM had the right to block the sale of a company using its technology, Reuters reports. Said U.S. District Court Judge Gershwin Drain said in a hearing in Detroit:

“General Motors had a contractual right to approve or disapprove the proposed transaction. The court is going to grant the motion to dismiss the matter.”

Spyker Chief Victor Muller was in the court room. He did not want to say whether he would appeal. “We will be awaiting the written order and then we will assess,” Muller told Reuters.

The allegedly aggrieved entity was Saab and not Spyker. Saab went bankrupt, and its assets were bought by a murky Chinese entity. Spyker acquired the rights to sue GM. As usual, Muller did not use his own money. Back then, a Spyker press release said:

“Spyker has secured the financial backing required to see the lawsuit through to the end from a third party investor.”

More money down the drain.

Get the latest TTAC e-Newsletter!

10 Comments on “U.S. Court Shoots Down Saab Suit Against GM...”

  • avatar

    This is what happens when tort lawyers are given a pen and paper, they write down the biggest number they can think of and call it fair damages.

    • 0 avatar×250/19429631.jpg

    • 0 avatar

      GS650G’s statement on damages has no real basis in the law — you must be able to present a method to calculate damages. Punitive damages also generally have a limit in most jurisdictions, and you must be able to show your case for that too.

      The peanut gallery on TTAC likes to mention plaintiff’s lawyers or tort suits with derision, but they’re really speaking ideologically, rather than based on facts. The Bureau of Justice Statistics has a report from 2005 that says the following:

      ::*In the nation’s 75 most populous counties, the number of tort trials declined by about a third between 1996 and 2005.::

      Note that only 4% of cases actually went to trial — most are dismissed, and many more settle. Most of them have extremely low payouts — half of plaintiffs win, and the median payout is about $24K.


      In the real world, 60% of these trials are for auto accidents and the 2/3 of those trials for auto accidents involve individuals suing individuals.

      Even for med mal cases, there’s no evidence that actual payouts have been increasing. In fact, if you adjust for inflation, they’re probably down and are not what’s driving healthcare costs up. Yet the ideologues still mention it as a factor for some reason…

  • avatar
    Pastor Glenn

    More money down the drain sums up my (and many people’s) experiences with owning Saabs. Which may go a long way towards explaining why they are no longer around.

    While technically interesting, the Saab 99 I bought used over 20 years ago became the first car I’d ever had with destroyed its own engine. While I had young children. On the wrong side of the country from home. On vacation.

    I considered the company a manufacturer of “amateur-mobiles” after that and nothing ever changed my mind.

    Then my sister, who loved Volvos, got to that certain age in life where she wanted a red turbo Volvo. Most-problematic-car-she-ever-had.
    She bought a Subaru after that and is perfectly satisfied.

    It’s interesting to note that Volvo’s sales are way down – seemingly in a death-spiral in this country, isn’t it? Probably not a coincidence, if my sister’s FWD Volvo was anything like typical.

    • 0 avatar

      While I’m sure your experience was abysmal, I’ve met a lot more people who turned their back on GM, than I ever heard turn against SAAB. Subaru is a good alternate though.

  • avatar

    Where’s VoltsonFire? I want to know if I can use his avatar for an album cover for my new punk rock band.

    I don’t have the disposed/source of sales data directly on hand at the moment, but I think it is obvious that a lot of Saab and Volvo customers moved into Subarus. Actually, without them, Subaru might have died in the US, too.

Back to TopLeave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Subscribe without commenting

Recent Comments

  • Re: Buick Envision Photos Leaked

    brn - Agreed. If Buick is going to try and compete as near luxury, they need sensible lux-type names. Shoulda named it %#$@#.
  • Re: Buick Envision Photos Leaked

    Clarence - If anything is going to steal sales from Audi in China, it’s a faux-marble dashboard. Mental.
  • Re: Ford Announces 2015 F-150 Pricing

    DeadWeight - Thank you, koschei. 1) Rear wheel drive (or light AWD system, sending no more than 18% of power to front wheels) 2) Diesel (turbocharging a diesel, unlike a...
  • Re: Lexus GX Sales Double, Profits Pile Up

    VenomV12 - My neighborhood and area are inexplicably littered with these ugly things as well as the less ugly, but still ugly LX. After years of seeing them, I can...
  • Re: Buick Envision Photos Leaked

    340-4 - Last night I checked out the new Lincoln MKC. Looked nice, seemed well built, SMALL, particularly the cargo area. And. $44,000 and $48,000 for the two on the lot....
  • Re: Reader Review: 2010 Volkswagen Jetta Sportwagen

    tedward - carlson fan Diesel doesn’t produce as much heat as quickly as a gasoline motor which explains the slow heat issue. Contributes to engine...
  • Re: Ford Announces 2015 F-150 Pricing

    DeadWeight - Not everyone who is critical and/or skeptical of the claims surrounding the Ecoboost (3.5 and upcoming 2.7) in terms of long term reliability & alleged...
  • Re: Mitsubishi Vans Are A Delica-te Matter In Canada

    danio3834 - Good post. If only all auto enthusiasts were that dedicated.
  • Re: Buick Envision Photos Leaked

    thegamper - Looks good. I saw a new MKC today and I’d have to say I would take this over the Lincoln based on looks. But I’d like to see how they stack up in other...
  • Re: Reader Review: 2010 Volkswagen Jetta Sportwagen

    tedward - Kyree I own the exact model reviewed in the article (13 model year so different feature set), but have made a lot of changes to mine. The...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote


  • Authors

  • Brendan McAleer, Canada
  • Marcelo De Vasconcellos, Brazil
  • Matthias Gasnier, Australia
  • Tycho de Feyter, China
  • W. Christian 'Mental' Ward, Abu Dhabi
  • Mark Stevenson, Canada
  • Faisal Ali Khan, India