By on October 2, 2012

Are you a short seller who is on the hunt for companies that are worse off than European carmakers?  Look for parts makers that are also in the contract manufacturing business. OEMs may lose sales, but contract manufacturers lose whole contracts when manufacture is brought in-house by OEMs. Magna is likely to lose the contract with BMW to build the next generation of Mini cars, says Reuters.

Austrian Magna Steyr produces the Mini Countryman and will begin producing the Paceman later in the year, but possibly not for long.

“We let Magna Steyr produce the Countryman and the Paceman, but in the mid-term we are looking at concentrating Mini production in two locations, namely Oxford and NedCar,” a BMW spokesman told Reuters.

Get the latest TTAC e-Newsletter!


6 Comments on “Magna Soon Without Mini...”

  • avatar

    But why?

  • avatar
    D in the D

    With all the European overcapacity, this probably is real bad news for Magna, but I disagree with this one as a short candidate. Magna has one of those family share classes, where the family holds all the important shares, and the public really has only a small stake in the company, ever. Selling it short, or expecting much gain out of this one isn’t going to happen unless you’re on the inside.

    • 0 avatar

      Just look to the history of where crazy Frank sold his stock, and tried to manipulate the deal but the counter parties realized he was screwing them… Scuttled the deal… Iirc deal finally went thru but with a more reasonable payout to mr megalomaniac…

    • 0 avatar

      A few years ago I was considering purchasing Magna shares but was put off not only by who was on the Board of Directors (mainly retired politicians who would never say no to Frank) and the share structure but also by the shifting of assets from the auto business to Frank’s race horse hobby. Eventually after shareholder protests it was turned into a separate company, Magna Entertainment, that went bankrupt in 2009. I was thinking the term used by a poster here of “Mr. Megalomaniac” a bit rich but now I see that in his just-announced run for the Austrian Presidency his newly-formed party is named “Team Stronach for Austria.” At least Magna is still bolting together those Aston-Martin Rapides and VW-Bentley sedans in Austria.

  • avatar

    BMW kept the wrong factory – Plant Oxford (Cowley) is running at capacity and is all hemmed in with no real room for expansion, while most of the still-sprawling Longbridge complex lies vacant. They should have taken the bigger plant when they had the chance, but, then 12 years ago, who would have really predicted MINI would be as big a success as it is?

    • 0 avatar

      Gabriel Rees, the Uk equivalent of David cole, also with a university center for auto research, and just as inaccurate with his forecasts, predicted that mini would sell so few cars that BMW would not recover its investment before, at earliest, the second generation… Mini sold twice the number Rees predicted and was profitable in a couple of years…

Back to TopLeave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Recent Comments

  • golden2husky: You don’t like KYB struts? For a reasonably low price they are quite nice. Not KONI level to be...
  • APaGttH: Your Kia Soul came from the Scion xB, which came from this.
  • Spartan: Wish List! 1. 6MT Q50/Q60, please? 2. Extended wheelbase QX80L to compete with the Escalade ESV 3. Midsize...
  • APaGttH: So wait, AMC basically invented the CUV and the minivan? Looking through the lens of the times (1977) I...
  • golden2husky: Change all will be glad you did!

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote


  • Contributors

  • Matthew Guy, Canada
  • Ronnie Schreiber, United States
  • Bozi Tatarevic, United States
  • Chris Tonn, United States
  • Corey Lewis, United States
  • Mark Baruth, United States
  • Moderators

  • Adam Tonge, United States
  • Corey Lewis, United States