Musk Pushed Back Against Tesla Employees' Autopilot Concerns: Report

Steph Willems
by Steph Willems

Tesla CEO Elon Musk’s drive to develop and market new driving technology is well known, but former employees say he brushed aside their concerns about the safety of the company’s Autopilot system.

Several employees, including a former Autopilot engineer, told CNN Money that their concerns fell on deaf ears, as Musk always reverted back to a “bigger picture” position on safety.

The automaker’s semi-autonomous driving system came under scrutiny in the wake of a fatal May crash. Musk claims that although the Autopilot didn’t recognize a transport truck in that case, the system makes roads safer. He’s pledged to do more to educate owners on how to properly use Autopilot, but has no plans to stop offering the system.

Musk told the Wall Street Journal “we knew we had a system that on balance would save lives.”

Speaking to CNNMoney, ex-Autopilot engineer Eric Meadows claims he was pulled over by police in 2015 while testing Autopilot on a Los Angeles highway, a few months before the system’s release. The Tesla had difficulty handling turns, and the police suspected him of being intoxicated.

Meadows was later fired for performance reasons, but he claims his worries about Autopilot’s safety — especially the possibility that owners would “push the limits” of the technology — grew over time.

“The last two months I was scared someone was going to die,” he said.

The report mentions a former Tesla executive who worked closely with Musk, and claims the CEO was frequently at loggerheads with “overly cautious” employees. Tesla’s self-parking feature went ahead as planned, another source claims, despite worries that sensors wouldn’t function properly if the vehicle was near the edge of a steep slope. Again, the greater good of preventing driveway deaths overruled these concerns.

The employee mix at Tesla falls into two categories — younger, data-driven employees and seasoned automotive industry types. The report cites multiple sources who claim that data is the guiding factor in Tesla’s decisions, meaning slight risk is allowed if it means a greater potential for overall safety.

While this bothers some engineers and consumer safety groups, even the agency investigating the May crash sides with Musk’s views on safety. Recently, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration administrator Mark Rosekind said the industry “cannot wait for perfect” when it comes to marketing potentially life-saving autonomous technology.

[Image: Tesla Motors]

Steph Willems
Steph Willems

More by Steph Willems

Comments
Join the conversation
10 of 145 comments
  • DAC17 DAC17 on Jul 31, 2016

    Sounds to me an awful lot like the VW scandal. Various employees say something can't be done, but overbearing boss doesn't want to hear about it. Of course, Musk seems to get a bye for almost everything, because of the company's "green cred", so maybe he'll skate through this one.

  • VoGo VoGo on Jul 31, 2016

    If anyone read a credible news source* on the issue, they would see that the Tesla autopilot feature had nothing to do with the deadly crash. Autopilot doesn't control the brakes, only the steering. Which means that 90% of the comments on this and all the other related articles are completely wrong. *which could include NYT, CNBC, UPI,...

    • See 7 previous
    • Drzhivago138 Drzhivago138 on Aug 01, 2016

      @accord1999 Not that I have any dog in this fight, but couldn't speed-matching also be achieved by dialing back the motors?

  • Brian Uchida Laguna Seca, corkscrew, (drying track off in rental car prior to Superbike test session), at speed - turn 9 big Willow Springs racing a motorcycle,- at greater speed (but riding shotgun) - The Carrousel at Sears Point in a 1981 PA9 Osella 2 litre FIA racer with Eddie Lawson at the wheel! (apologies for not being brief!)
  • Mister It wasn't helped any by the horrible fuel economy for what it was... something like 22mpg city, iirc.
  • Lorenzo I shop for all-season tires that have good wet and dry pavement grip and use them year-round. Nothing works on black ice, and I stopped driving in snow long ago - I'll wait until the streets and highways are plowed, when all-seasons are good enough. After all, I don't live in Canada or deep in the snow zone.
  • FormerFF I’m in Atlanta. The summers go on in April and come off in October. I have a Cayman that stays on summer tires year round and gets driven on winter days when the temperature gets above 45 F and it’s dry, which is usually at least once a week.
  • Kwik_Shift_Pro4X I've never driven anything that would justify having summer tires.
Next