GM's Pickup Truck CNG Conversion Costs $11,000

Derek Kreindler
by Derek Kreindler

Compressed natural gas may cost the equivalent of $1.89 per gallon of gasoline, but retrofitting your GMC Sierra or Chevrolet Silverado will cost you $11,000 – and GM still think it will save you money.

According to GM, “…Customers could save $5,000 to $10,000 over a three-year period, depending on their driving habits.” How GM came to this number is a bit of a mystery, and we’re doing some digging to try and figure it out – because it’s a conversion, there is no EPA rating on it and data is difficult to find.

What we did notice was this little tidbit

Businesses are looking for ways to control their costs while reducing vehicle emissions and becoming less dependent on fluctuating gas prices. The low cost of ownership makes these vehicles a realistic solution,

$11,000 is a lot of cash for a business to tie up in one truck. In the absence of any data on how many miles it would take to break even (as well as the gas price number used to come up with it), it appears that GM is hoping to sway buyers with the prospect of unstable or rising fuel prices in the future. Emissions are almost certainly a secondary concern. It’s a wonder that GM didn’t promote the fact that CNG can legitimately claim to be a domestically sourced form of clean energy, seeing as they (barely) did back in March.

We contacted GM to try and get more information on the CNG conversion, and more specifically, how they came to their savings figures. Please leave all accusations of anti-GM bias, skulduggery and wrongdoing in the comments section.

EDIT: General Motors says that they calculated the savings based on a truck driving 24,000 miles a year, with gas prices at $4 per gallon and a CNG gallon equivalent of $2. GM’s Mike Jones, Product Manager for Fleet and Commercial Operations, thinks that there will continue to be “…a pretty significant price separation…” between gasoline and CNG.

Derek Kreindler
Derek Kreindler

More by Derek Kreindler

Comments
Join the conversation
3 of 31 comments
  • Redmondjp Redmondjp on Apr 19, 2012

    Does anybody here know if there are periodic testing/recertification requirements for the CNG tanks, much as there is for SCUBA tanks and compressed gas cylinders? That may affect the payback period slightly as well. I'm just thinking down the road about these CNG vehicles becoming more widely available on the used market, and if they are going to link vehicle registration to having a current tank cert.

    • Nikita Nikita on Apr 19, 2012

      Tanks have a 15 or 20 year rated lifespan. My understanding is that it is based on heavy fleet usage of tree fill cycles a day five days a week.

  • Pinetreepark Pinetreepark on Apr 23, 2012

    The $11,000 price is steep but for people who drive 30,000 miles a year it would be a good option. If these big trucks average 15 mpg then that would be 2000 gal per year at $2 savings is $4000 a year. The return on investment is less than 3 years. The CNG option makes the resale value higher also. Look at the prices for a 2003 cng Silverado (the last full year GM made cng. The big thing is the fluctuation in fuel prices and the expectation for the future. There is a good site that explains this www.cngoco.com The problem isn't the price of the truck, it is the availability of places to but cng!

  • Ajla So a $10K+ transmission repair?
  • Kwik_Shift_Pro4X I've mentioned before about being very underwhelmed by the Hornet for a $50000+ all in price tag. Just wasn't for me. I'd prefer a Mazda CX-5 or even a Rogue.
  • MaintenanceCosts Other sources seem to think that the "electric Highlander" will be built on TNGA and that the other 3-row will be on an all-new EV-specific platform. In that case, why bother building the first one at all?
  • THX1136 Two thoughts as I read through the article. 1) I really like the fins on this compared to the others. For me this is a jet while the others were propeller driven craft in appearance.2) The mention of the wider whitewalls brought to mind a vague memory. After the wider version fell out of favor I seem to remember that one could buy add-on wide whitewalls only that fit on top of the tire so the older look could be maintained. I remember they would look relatively okay until the add-on would start to ripple and bow out indicating their exact nature. Thanks for the write up, Corey. Looking forward to what's next.
  • Analoggrotto It's bad enough we have to read your endless Hyundai Kia Genesis shilling, we don't want to hear actually it too. We spend good money on speakers, headphones and amplifiers!
Next