Question of the Day: Are You Ready To Buy Small?

Jonny Lieberman
by Jonny Lieberman

Just paid $4.37 per gallon this morning for premium. Oy. While patiently waiting for (another) $60 to leave my wallet a lady pulled up in a Smart Roadster. I haven't driven a Smart yet, but from I'm told, it blows. However, it really doesn't weigh very much. A few days ago, a dear friend called me and asked if she and her one-year-old should buy a used Audi. Let me rephrase that: she wanted to buy a used A4. I tried explaining that when new, the A4 sold for three times what a Mazda Protege went for. Today the Mazda is worth more. She wasn't hearing it. I then touched on the fact that she could well be paying $400 a month in bizzaro repair bills, like CV joints and a new electrical system. And the (relatively) poor mileage. "But Jonny, it's so cute! My friend has one– I love it" I finally talked her out of it by mentioning that the auto-dimming rearview mirror will eventually leak mercury all over her infant. That worked. Long story short, she's got about $15k to spend. I told her to get a Honda Fit. "Oh no! My friend says they're death traps." Based on what? Her friend– a TV actor– test drove one and thought it was a death trap. From the test drive. Long story short, even though she wants a clean, high mileage car, she ain't going small. Because of her baby. You?

Jonny Lieberman
Jonny Lieberman

Cleanup driver for Team Black Metal V8olvo.

More by Jonny Lieberman

Comments
Join the conversation
4 of 86 comments
  • David C. Holzman David C. Holzman on May 30, 2008

    If I had to get a new car today, I'd look hard at a Civic. If the Fit got about 10-15 mpg more than the current Civic, without being a hybrid, I'd look at that. I currently drive an Accord.

  • Ricky Spanish Ricky Spanish on Jun 03, 2008

    We're having a baby in August We got a new Civic SI. It has all those fancy ass curtain airbags, reinforced steel doors etc - the nanny government has essentially regulated extra weight and safety into the car for us. we get 26 mpg city, 32 highway. It swallows everything I own without complaint (no problem eating 4 wheels with tires to take to autocross). small can be safe and efficient.

  • Ricky Spanish Ricky Spanish on Jun 03, 2008

    I just want to add that "I'm having a baby so I need an SUV" is one of the most retarded things I've ever heard, yet so many people believe it. Car seats fit in the back of a regular car. Unless you have a brood, you don't need an SUV. My family of 4 did fine in a BMW 5-Series and Mercury Sable.

  • Beelzebubba Beelzebubba on Jun 10, 2008

    I am both amused and enraged, simultaneously, when idiots (for instance, TV actors who test drive $15k cars) state their ill-informed opinions as authoritative fact. The inevitable result is that folks like us, who actually spend time researching and educated ourselves on a topic before advising others, get to first 'un-do' their damage before actually offering useful information. Even more ridiculous, some still won't heed the good advice even with hard facts (crash test data, CR reviews, etc). I guess they deserve what they get! One of my favorite quotes seems appropriate here- "Better to remain silent and be thought a fool than speak out and remove all doubt."- Abe Lincoln TV actors- take note!

Next