This Is The Analysis Of The Video That Jalopnik Also Just Showed You

Jack Baruth
by Jack Baruth

The nice people at BEST Motoring have produced another one of their entertaining pseudo-races. This one features the GT86/BRZ twins vs. the current Miata. It can be watched and enjoyed solely on its own merits. If that isn’t enough, and you want to hear some thoughts regarding the setup of the race, the performance of the respective vehicles, and the showmanship involved, click the jump.

The finishing order and best laps:

Toyota GT-86 – 1:46.0
Subaru BR-Z – 1:47.1
MX-5 Fabric Top – 1:48.6

Now for the observations:

  • This test was rigged to favor the Miata. Not in the obvious sense of putting the Miata P1 on the grid, although that was done, but in the sense of having the Miata driver turning the fastest, most careful laps. The guys driving the twins (one of which is noted drifter Keiichi Tsuchiya) are goofing around and throwing time away — most obviously in Lap 3 where Tsuchiya is screwing around to make the finish closer. The Miata driver is putting his head down and hitting his marks. It’s safe to assume that the true gap between the twins and the MX-5 is more than the 2.6 seconds per lap shown in the video. The Jalopnik commenters who are frantically typing “OMFG TEH MIATA IS LIKE SO CLOSE DESPITE HAVING NO POWER LOL ITZ TEH BEST” are failing to understand this.
  • Obviously the twins are identical. Tsuchiya had the inside line and never gives up the advantage from there. Don’t freak out. The lap time differences are entirely due to showboating and the fact that the BR-Z had to make the pass on the Miata in a tougher spot.
  • The twins won’t drift. Yes, they will slide a bit, but when the Drift King himself can’t get the GT-86 more than a bit sideways despite having an open track and a free hand to do so, that doesn’t augur well for suburban hoons. Luckily, it doesn’t really matter.
  • Nor are they particularly quick. Those digital speedometers are in kph, which means that these cars can barely break 100mph around the track. Raw speed isn’t the focus, obviously. Still, it’s worth remembering that these cars will be easy meat for V-6 ponycars… even on a racetrack. Understand?
  • I want to go race in Japan. Obviously these guys are goofing around, but… they drive around with their hands on the shifter like they are in a reboot of the American Graffiti franchise, they steer approximately, they wander back and forth on the track, they coast 100 feet on neutral throttle on every entry… I remind you that Ralf Schumacher won a lot of Formula events in Japan.

Watching this video doesn’t do a single thing to dull my desire to own a Scion FR-S. If anything, the sheer fun everyone is having is quite infectious. My application to be one of the “First 86” was denied, but maybe I should go have it out with the local Toyota dealer anyway. It’s what Gan-San, who is sadly missing from this video and who would have given all these pups a solid thrashing, would do.


Jack Baruth
Jack Baruth

More by Jack Baruth

Comments
Join the conversation
4 of 76 comments
  • Phillymiata Phillymiata on May 01, 2012

    The car is not bad - but the overhype has created two distinct sports car camps. Those who think it is a water walking miracle worker and those that think it is a terrible waste of money. I am curious how many they will actually sell. I am sure there will be a flurry of sale the first 6 months that peters out consideraably once people realize what Jack said: 1) It isn't that fast 2) It wont drift As a car marketed to young guy you most definitely want it to go at least a little bit fast or at least feel fast. And low torque = slow feeling. Being dusted in a miata is no big deal - its a girly convertible! Dusted in your RWD sports coupe by a minivan? Not as cool. This is the ultimate "enthusiast" car, now we get to see how many of the most vocal car fans actually will buy it.

    • See 1 previous
    • AKADriver AKADriver on May 01, 2012

      @wmba The current crop of V6 vans all do the 0-60 sprint between 7 and 8 seconds, which is a bit slower than the BRZ/86 (assuming it isn't forced to do a 2-3 shift at 59mph). Even if it were true, it's a meaningless argument in light of Jack's other article from today. The BRZ/86 is as fast as some exotic sports cars within my lifetime. The fact that I can buy something faster is almost meaningless.

  • Lzaffuto Lzaffuto on May 01, 2012

    Think about what you are saying. The Miata is the best selling sportscar in the world, and not because of the performance numbers it produces. Not because it is fast, not because it is the best handling. Everything you said about the FR-S applies to it as well, but doesn't hurt it in the least. This is *NOT* a numbers car. Like the Miata, it can be made into one, but that isn't the point. The point is *FEEL*.

  • D When I bought our truck there were so many complaints about the 12 inch screen delaminating that I refused to buy any of the trucks that the dealer had on the lot. I ordered a trim with a smaller screen, no friggin GPS and lots of old fashioned buttons. Within 3 months of delivery there was a recall on all the trucks on this guy's lot. He was faced with a stop-selling order for all of them because the screen malfunction ment no access to critical functions. I kept on driving mine.
  • EBFlexing on ur mom I was hoping Jeep would announce the HEMI is returning to the Grand Cherokee. Needs to happen ASAP.
  • Ryan Knickerbocker Chris Bangle
  • Grandmaster T • Matt, when you become an automotive executive, I predict that the executive meetings at that company will be very long meetings. (You use a lot of words, is what I'm saying.) [Like Mazda adding mass to a vehicle, they don't know when to stop. 😅]• Ajla said, "I think it's reasonably likely that the people regularly posting on general purpose car websites like this one are above average drivers from a safety and skill perspective." That probably maybe applies to some regular posters. It is highly likely that some regular posters are complete self-absorbed jerks behind the wheel.• I think anyone commenting on this article should list their automotive insurance claims history, and maybe their history of moving violations. (Here are mine: [ ]).• Matt, have you done any 0-60 runs in the family Mazda recently?• Learn to drive, people.My solar panel was delivered yesterday. How far can I drive an EV on 300 watts of sunshine per day? (You know what else uses solar power? The European spacecraft carrying Americans into sort-of-deep space right now.)
  • Jkross22 Auto insurance institute claims tech = safety. I believe that auto emergency braking has prevented 2-5 mph fender benders that would cost thousands to repair. But how many are calibrated correctly to prevent false positives? Not many.LKA is intrusive and dangerous. Having the wheel vibrate and pulled in a direction different than what I am doing is terrible.Convoluted menu systems, using screens instead of hard buttons causing distractions and drivers losing focus because of that..... they'll never cop to this. But don't touch your phone because it's distracting. Screens themselves shoulder a chunk of the blame.
Next