Bailout Watch 142: ALL NEW! World's Most Extreme Detroit Apologists

by Robert Farago

Published: November 3rd, 2008

bailout watch 142 all new world s most extreme detroit apologists

Tonight. On World’s Most Extreme Detroit Apologists… Move over Jerry Flint! Forbes’ ancient and once venerable scribe thinks GM CEO Rick Wagoner hasn’t raped stockholders by pocketing more than $100m in executive compensation. But The Detroit Free Press‘ Justin Hyde and Brent Snavely are willing to go even further. While their most recent mega-apologia predicts the end of Wagoner’s misguided management, the writers are happy to give the floor to analysts who suggest that Wagoner’s done- and is still doing— a great job. “Erich Merkle, an analyst from Crowe Horwath LLP, said Wagoner inherited years of bad decisions from previous managers that have limited his options. ‘You almost need to put Roger Smith on the hot seat, and I know he’s dead,’ Merkle said of the CEO who led GM from 1981 to 1990. ‘They were setting the company up for disaster later down the road. The business model that was created and the way that the contracts were structured were such that they were just not economically viable.'” Mea culpa be damned. And you can be damned sure that Merkle isn’t the only one blind to Wagoner’s cataclysmic effect on GM’s business…

Hyde and Snavely point out that an anyone who bought $10k worth of GM stock in June 2000 — when Red Ink Rick was named president and CEO — would see their stake diminish to just $860. And yet, “GM’s decline has done little damage to Wagoner’s stature among industry executives because its Detroit rivals have done no better. ‘Rick is very highly respected, and he is a very good leader,’ said Neil DeKoker, president of the Original Equipment Supplies Association. ‘They are just facing challenges that are bigger than any one individual or group of individuals can handle.'”

So it is just a question of great landing too short runway. Aaron Bragman, automotive analyst for IHS Global Insight, say yes. “Ehe biggest criticism he hears of Wagoner is that while change has occurred, it hasn’t happened fast enough. ‘And actually, I have been fairly impressed with his turnaround plan,’ Bragman said. ‘They have gone from being largely a group of fiefdoms around the world to what seems to be a very well coordinated company.'”

R-E-S-P-E-C-T. Tell me what Rick means to thee. “‘I think he’s as respected as anybody in the industry. I think he’s earned that. He’s been managing in a very difficult period,’ said David Cole, chairman of the Center for Automotive Research in Ann Arbor. ‘You’ll see that he has led a very important transformation.'”

And that’s what happens when you got and look for… Detroit’s Most Extreme Apologists.

Robert Farago

More by Robert Farago

Comments

Join the conversation

2 of 8 comments

Psarhjinian on Nov 03, 2008
There’s a reason he’s still there. A business-based reason. Don't assume that businesspeople are infallible.** Two of the most terrible sicknesses to infect a corporation are as follows: * Management, especially upper management, being unable to admit mistakes for fear that an admission of fallibility calls everything else they have or may do into question. * Front-line and lower-management's unwillingness to either a) call upper-management on it's failures or b) present real evidence that failure is happening at all. Many, many businesses fall victim to this, especially when management abstracts itself from the business. It doesn't matter if you're managed by engineers, accountants, lawyers or plumbers: lose track of the fundamentals, let the process become more important than the product and/or start worrying about fallibility instead of results and you're in a world of hurt shortly. Ironically, "smart" people are just as, if not more, susceptible to this. It's easy for, say, Joe Plumber to admit fallibility; it's much harder for, say, Rick Wagoner or George Fisher to do so. They should know better, heck, they do know better. They're the smartest guys in the room, the best and brightest, they can't be wrong. ** Two examples from GM's own board: George Fisher presided over Kodak's implosion at the start of the digital camera age by failing to track the way the industry was going; he's also notable for starting Motorola's fall from grace. Eckhard Pfeiffer effectively killed the successful, independent Compaq, weakening it through non-core acquisitions and making it a target for more focused companies like Dell. Any of this sound familiar?

Like Reply
Gus on Nov 07, 2008

David Cole, head of the Center for Automotive Research is a complete buffoon, far removed from reality and a total tool of the US auto industry. I'll laugh when, unlike GM, Ford and Chrysler "employees" who are paid to not work, he's on the unemployment line. It's apologists like him, on the industry's dole, who help keep us from a real solution for the industry, which is on death's door.

Like Reply

Recent Comments

Peter Buying an EV from Toyota is like buying a Bible from Donald Trump. Don’t be surprised if some very important parts are left out.
Sheila I have a 2016 Kia Sorento that just threw a rod out of the engine case. Filed a claim for new engine and was denied…..due to a loop hole that was included in the Class Action Engine Settlement so Hyundai and Kia would be able to deny a large percentage of cars with prematurely failed engines. It’s called the KSDS Improvement Campaign. Ever hear of such a thing? It’s not even a Recall, although they know these engines are very dangerous. As unknowing consumers load themselves and kids in them everyday. Are their any new Class Action Lawsuits that anyone knows of?
Alan Well, it will take 30 years to fix Nissan up after the Renault Alliance reduced Nissan to a paltry mess.I think Nissan will eventually improve.
Alan This will be overpriced for what it offers.I think the "Western" auto manufacturers rip off the consumer with the Thai and Chinese made vehicles.A Chinese made Model 3 in Australia is over $70k AUD(for 1995 $45k USD) which is far more expensive than a similar Chinesium EV of equal or better quality and loaded with goodies.Chinese pickups are $20k to $30k cheaper than Thai built pickups from Ford and the Japanese brands. Who's ripping who off?
Alan Years ago Jack Baruth held a "competition" for a piece from the B&B on the oddest pickup story (or something like that). I think 5 people were awarded the prizes.I never received mine, something about being in Australia. If TTAC is global how do you offer prizes to those overseas or are we omitted on the sly from competing?In the end I lost significant respect for Baruth.