Piston Slap: Metering a Prince's Air Flow?

Sajeev Mehta
by Sajeev Mehta

TTAC Commentator haroldhill writes:

Dear Sajeev,

My wife is driving (and loving) her 2009 MINI Cooper which has been a delight and remarkably trouble-free for 10 years. However, it recently developed a problem which has befuddled us and our highly reputable independent mechanic as well.

Under certain conditions the engine stumbles, feeling somewhat like an erratic misfire on one cylinder or fuel starvation; however, the stumbling vanishes when accelerator load is increased. The required conditions are: fully warmed up (10-15 minutes of driving), engine speed between 2700 and 3300 rpm, and light throttle appropriate to steady cruising. The stumbling will eventually bring on the “check engine” light and a P115C error code (Mass Air Flow).

If the engine is turned off for a few minutes (e.g. for a highway rest stop) the stumbling will disappear and won’t reappear until the car has been driven for another ten minutes, suggesting the fault is something remote enough from the engine that it can cool substantially in five minutes. After a few uneventful driving cycles, of course, the “check engine” light turns itself off. Thanks for nothing. On the other hand, this would be how I got it through emissions inspection…

Thus far the Mass Air Flow Meter has been replaced twice and the Throttle Body once. The latter seemed to help for awhile but I can’t be sure because it’s only recently that I’ve pinned down the exact conditions that will reliably bring this problem on. My wife, who does most of the driving, is a bit of a leadfoot and generally has much less trouble with this stumbling.

Our wonderful mechanic would appreciate any ideas or suggestions.

Sajeev answers:

It’s time for this Lincoln-Mercury fanboi to put aside his fears of newer BMW products and hope his Google-fu is strong.

My go to automobile specification website says your MINI Cooper has a naturally-aspirated (i.e it’s not a Cooper S) has a Prince Engine with BMW’s VANOS system for variable valve timing. The P115c code is far from a quick and easy diagnosis, so I don’t blame your mechanic for changing these parts, especially if he’s not a specialized BMW technician. Then again, replacing the MAF twice does kinda, sorta bother me. It kinda feels like he was throwing parts at the problem.

But I hate being an armchair quarterback, especially since I don’t wrench on cars for a living, so let’s get off that throne.

Since this isn’t a turbocharged model, there’s not in the way of intake plumbing to spring a leak. So VANOS system might be the problem, especially since issues happen “between 2700 and 3300 rpm” and never else. I bet the VANOS solenoids need a good clean, and perhaps a test/replacement afterwards. Accessing your average MINI Cooper VANOS solenoid doesn’t look too hard, in theory:

So my advice? Remove and clean the VANOS solenoids and see what happens.

[Image: BMW Group]

Send your queries to sajeev@thetruthaboutcars.com. Spare no details and ask for a speedy resolution if you’re in a hurry…but be realistic, and use your make/model specific forums instead of TTAC for more timely advice.

Sajeev Mehta
Sajeev Mehta

More by Sajeev Mehta

Join the conversation
2 of 18 comments
  • Speedlaw Speedlaw on Aug 25, 2019

    Check any intake hoses. While not the same car, I had the same symptoms in my 330i, M54. Turns out the accordion hose on the intake had aged and cracked. Engine movement would cause occasional leaks, make things inconsistent and tossed codes. The hose was definitely leaking at cracks in the accordion.

  • Oreguy Oreguy on Aug 26, 2019

    We had a 2007 Mini Cooper S (turbo). I know yours is not an S, but ours suffered from similar symptoms. Rough idle, sluggishness and the like. Ultimately the PCV system was the cause. Apparently it was clogged, or failed in some manner, which necessitated replacement. On all previous cars I ever owned, a replacement PCV valve cost less than $10. However, the Franco-Germanic engineers involved with designing the engine in our R56 Turbo decided to integrate it into the valve-cover - a $750 part (installation not included). Good luck. Thankfully there are no more Minis in my garage.

  • Daniel J Until we get a significant charging infrastructure and change times get under 10 minutes, yes
  • Mike I own 2 gm 6.2 vehicles. They are great. I do buy alot of gas. However, I would not want the same vehicles if they were v6's. Jusy my opinion. I believe that manufacturers need to offer engine options for the customer. The market will speak on what the consumer wants.For example, I dont see the issue with offering a silverado with 4cyl , 6 cyl, 5.3 v8, 6.2 v8, diesel options. The manufacturer will charge accordingly.
  • Mike What percentage of people who buy plug in hybrids stop charging them daily after a few months? Also, what portion of the phev sales are due to the fact that the incentives made them a cheaper lease than the gas only model? (Im thinking of the wrangler 4xe). I wish there was a way to dig into the numbers deeper.
  • CEastwood If it wasn't for the senior property tax freeze in NJ I might complain about this raising my property taxes since most of that tax goes to the schools . I'm not totally against EVs , but since I don't drive huge miles and like to maintain my own vehicles they are not practical especially since I keep a new vehicle long term and nobody has of yet run into the cost of replacing the battery on an EV .
  • Aquaticko Problem with PHEV is that, like EVs, they still require a behavioral change over ICE/HEV cars to be worth their expense and abate emissions (whichever is your goal). Studies in the past have shown that a lot of PHEV drivers don't regularly plug-in, meaning they're just less-efficient HEVs.I'm left to wonder how big a battery a regular HEV could have without needing to be a PHEV.