By on December 18, 2015

Miller Motorsports Park Circa May 2008

A Utah judge has blocked the sale of Miller Motorsports Park to a Chinese investment firm because county commissioners may have illegally lowered the price to below fair-market value, KSL reported Thursday.

In a filing, Judge Robert Atkins said Tooele county officials tasked with selling the shuttered racetrack ignored higher bids to sell the racetrack for $20 million to Geely-backed Mitime Investment and Development Group. According to the report, county tax officials estimated the value of the track at $28.1 million.

A competing bidder, Center Point Management, said it offered $22.5 million for the park. The Wyoming-based company filed a lawsuit to stop the sale because they said county officials ignored their bid based on unverified promises by the Chinese group.

According to KSL, the county commissioned an appraisal after the lawsuit was filed by Center Point, which valued the track at $9 million. The judge noted that the appraisal wasn’t believable considering the timing and pending lawsuit.

Tooele County Commissioners said they were disappointed, but stopped short of saying they would appeal the decision.

“We are disappointed by the judge’s findings,” county Commissioner Shawn Milne said in a statement. “Tooele County is committed to bringing about the successful sale of the Miller Motorsports Park property. It is important to the citizens of the county that it remain a viable racetrack, and that the jobs and businesses associated with the facility, as well the revenue realized by the county and area businesses, remain intact. In light of the court’s decision, the county is considering several options to resolve this situation in both the short and long-term.”

The judge wrote that the sale was “an inappropriate attempt to circumvent the law and avoid the prospect of having to address a higher purchase offer from another willing purchaser.”

The order by the judge is the latest measure in an increasingly ugly fight between the Chinese investment group, competing bidders and county officials.

After Larry Miller, who owned one of the largest automobile dealership groups in the U.S. and the Utah Jazz, died in 2009, the future of the track bearing his name became increasingly uncertain. Miller built and maintained the world-class track, often at great personal expense. The track struggled to turn a profit, and in recent years, has struggled to attract big-name events to keep it afloat.

In May, when the Miller family walked away from the track — exercising an escape in its 99-year lease with the county — commissioners were left to sell the track. In August, the group announced the sale to Mitime, which is a subsidiary of Chinese automaker Geely, who also owns Volvo.

[h/t to John for the tip!]

Get the latest TTAC e-Newsletter!

Recommended

18 Comments on “Judge Overturns Sale of Miller Motorsports Park...”


  • avatar
    zip89105

    Someone made a nice contribution to someone’s re-election.

  • avatar
    30-mile fetch

    “Mitime has promised to make additional investments in Miller Motorsports Park while keeping in open for racing. It is not known what Center Point Management planned to do with the property”

    http://www.sltrib.com/sports/2934339-155/company-files-suit-challenging-miller-motorsports

    That worries me a bit. Legal is legal but I would rather not see the track be replaced by residential development. That area is quickly becoming an exurb of the Salt Lake metro area and I wonder if subdivisions are a more profitable use of land for a developer.

    If it does go to a developer who shuts it down, I will have picked a sh*tty time to become interested in getting a bit of track experience.

    • 0 avatar
      ckb

      No idea what the real motives are but it would be very strange for an automaker (subsidiary) to buy a racetrack and turn it into houses. If it were a good residential investment you’d think real estate developers would be making more bids.

      • 0 avatar
        30-mile fetch

        Center Point Management is the company suing for losing the bid. A short internet search didn’t turn them up, but I don’t think they are an automaker subsidiary like MiTime

  • avatar
    carguy67

    Wonder what happened to the fantastic car collection; including several Cobras and at least one GT40.

  • avatar
    RHD

    Unsubstantiated speculation and unfounded rumors indicate that several county officials will have to immediately return their brand new Volvos.

  • avatar

    I haven’t seen recent Volvo market share numbers but if bad memory serves, the last US numbers I remember were around 600,000/yr. About 500,000 of which were sold in Utah.

    Good Volvo market. Volvo should have no trouble reselling them there.

  • avatar
    DenverMike

    It’s just a tax dodge. Corruption on both sides, and tax payers the victims.

  • avatar
    Signal11

    There’s a pattern to certain bylines of late of there being missing or just plain wrong information.

    Reading the TTAC article without reading the referenced article, one could easily believe (as more than one poster seems to have) that there is some sort of Chinese involved malfeasance at work here.

    OTOH, reading the actual article written by a real journalist reveals that the vague “unverified promises” that were quoted in the TTAC article were about investing in the property as a racetrack, expanding and upgrading facilities as well as bringing in more jobs.

    Who is the Andrew Cartwright referenced in the article? Other than stirring up xenophobic sentiments from the locals such as, “Personally, it’s disgusting to me that you’re selling out. Not only to a foreign country, but to a communist country.” Who is this guy?

    A property developer. One who is making no assurances or promises that the facility will remain a racetrack after his group purchases it. It literally took less than five minutes of googling to dig a little under the surface to see what the county official’s statements meant.

    • 0 avatar
      wmba

      I agree with you. I read this article, and could not make any rational sense of it. I read Cole’s earlier article back from the summer and it was okay, no more. I clicked on the external link above to the latest newspaper article of Dec 17,and read it. Now it all makes sense. Point is, why was the rewrite published here such a mess?

      This is about the fifteenth time I’ve commented on Coles’ articles. Basically, they’re rubbish. No other way to put it, no way to sugar-coat the reality. Also, he obviously cares not one whit about criticism – constructive or otherwise, thinks he’s funny or something.

      Used to spend a lot of time on the site, but now I generally just skim it. If I didn’t already read about something three or four days before just in surfing the web, then I’ll have a read of the article, which often amounts to nothing more than gibberish if it has a Coles byline, and go off on the web to read about the subject by someone who can actually write logically, to understand what’s really going on – if I care enough about the topic.

      The comments also rarely match the topic, with the same commenters repeating on every single blessed article, basically having a neighborhood chat on whatever strikes their fancy. Zero interest to me to read about student loans on the new Nissan car post, for example. Who cares? Why are there so few new commenters these days?

      The Baruths are usually ranting on about what they regard as others’ bad habits, or lack of someone or something being as wonderful as they are. I once found this interesting, perhaps for the first few dozen times. Now it’s just more of the same, a repeat of a tired-out formula.

      Trucks. Couldn’t care less about these beam-axle monstrosities which are state of the art in precisely nothing. The site’s title says cars, not trucks. So what if trucks sell 40% of the market? Make a site for those who truly care about them to argue incessantly about payloads and towing specs and arcana.

      The real technical content of the site is next to zero, and I read better comments on C/D Backfires.

      I’m sure traffic numbers drive a website’s viability. I hope all is well in this regard, because originally this site was a trailblazer and exciting, so I retain a certain loyalty to it. I know things change, been around seven decades to observe that, but this place is really getting super stale.

      I know I pay nothing to read TTAC, so any complaint can objectively be discarded as unimportant. That’s fine, as they used to say: if you don’t like the program then change the channel.

      For the most part I already have.

      The only reason I hang about at all is nostalgia I guess. But good lord, surely something needs to change to make it a bit more interesting, to attract new commenters and to make things a bit more lively so discussion doesn’t drag down to idiotic politics, pronouncements from on high from people without the slightest clue usually living in the minimum wage paradise down under, and people who still hold a grudge about the GM and Chrysler bankruptcies and who cannot even get their facts straight, so blinded are they by some perceived outrage they’ve manufactured in their own heads. And so on.

      A reset. That’s what’s needed.

  • avatar

    Mitime is a Chinese investment group in the same manner that Ford Motor Land Development Corporation is a Dearborn based real estate company.

Read all comments

Back to TopLeave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Recent Comments

  • dantes_inferno: You need to order the Exxon option with this vehicle. A dedicated Exxon tanker truck escort to keep...
  • MoparRocker74: THIS. Also, what they would more likely care about is whether you have side mirrors relocated when...
  • MoparRocker74: Never driven an old CJ Jeep, I see. I’ve owned 3, and all had the “full view” soft doors at some...
  • tomLU86: Since the Audi 5000 (aka my teens), the car magazines and Consumer Reports have liked Audi. Back in the Audi...
  • tomLU86: Massive extravagance, yes! I saw an Escalade in Greece a few months ago. At a gas station! And this was a...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Matthew Guy
  • Timothy Cain
  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Chris Tonn
  • Corey Lewis
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber