Piston Slap: "Spare" Me From Dry Rot!

Sajeev Mehta
by Sajeev Mehta

TTAC Commentator sastexan writes:

With the extreme cold throughout the US and seeing a few shredded tires on the highway this week (in fact, I had a flat myself – not sure what caused it but possibly doing donuts in the FR-S on a parking lot last week with lots of broken up ice on the edges), I got to thinking about spare tires.

Many of the Best and Brightest have “keeper” cars – myself included with our old Camry. Tires have limited lifespans due to dry rot, and I’m guessing spare tires are included in that category. The spare in the Camry is the original 14 year old tire (full size spare at least). How often do people change their spares, if ever? Has anyone with an aged spare had it blow out due to dry rot? Can you just order a new space saver spare off of tire rack?

Take care,


Sajeev answers:

Very interesting question, one that raises even more questions! Keep these in mind before we proceed:

  • Tires dry rot slower when living in an enclosed space with no exposure to sunlight (UV rays).
  • You may not see visible cracks like other rotted tires, but rest assured at some point the rubber has petrified like a rock.
  • The odds of getting stranded by a rotted temporary spare is less likely than an ordinary tire, as nobody wants to roll around on that tiny donut for an extended period.
  • Low air pressure can be the reason for a spare blow out, as they tend to leak profusely after a few years of hibernating in a trunk.
  • The items listed above will not necessarily apply to externally mounted spares in trucks/SUVs/CUVs. Treat those more like your other four wheels.

Externally mounted full size spare owners: change the tire every 5-10 years…more or less, depending on your risk tolerance and driving needs. Or re-use one of your “old” tires as a spare when upgrading to new ones for your regular wheels. And if you are luckily to have a matching 5th wheel as a spare (or unlucky enough to have 5 steel wheels on your ride) just rotate it into the mix.

Externally mounted temporary spare owners? Good question, as this is a future quandary of my little Ranger pick-em-up truck. Then again, it might be similar to our next case…

Internally mounted spare owners? Who knows the safe lifespan, but I’d wager that 10+ years is fine, since I’ve used the original spare in my Mark VIII for short distances in urban conditions. I’d change my tune if I was traveling hundreds of miles daily on rural roads…grabbing spare tires from crusher-bound Taurii and Fusions in the process.

Whenever you “internally mounted spare” folks are ready for new rubber, well yes, Tire Rack sells spares…but I’ll assume China’s finest off-brand donuts trade for less money from another vendor, as that happened when my 1983 Ford Sierra needed new tires in it’s unobtanium space saver-esque size for a measly $34 a pop. Which is more than adequate for the job.

In the case of your Camry? I say replace it (full size spare in the trunk) with one of the external tires when its time for new shoes. Or get a used tire from any local shop for $20-ish. Or just make sure it’s inflated to spec and you drive SLOW (i.e. 50mph or less) for a short period of time. There’s no wrong answer here, unless you’re stranded in the middle of no where and must rely on a fresh tire to take you hundreds of miles away in a harsh climate.

As with everything in life, this Piston Slap boils down to: It depends.

So eyeball the rubber and keep it inflated to spec. That’s a good start. Off to you, Best and Brightest.

Send your queries to sajeev@thetruthaboutcars.com. Spare no details and ask for a speedy resolution if you’re in a hurry…but be realistic, and use your make/model specific forums instead of TTAC for more timely advice.

[Image: Shutterstock user Wachira W.]

Sajeev Mehta
Sajeev Mehta

More by Sajeev Mehta

Join the conversation
2 of 41 comments
  • Claytori Claytori on Mar 11, 2014

    A number of years ago I spent a couple of months in Indonesia on business. I came to realize that the standard for replacing tires there was when the tread had worn completely through to the cords. Tires are amazing structures that require substantial abuse to make them fail, in most cases. Track use is not comparable to every day driving for the stresses placed on tires. Most people are unwilling or unable to use the full acceleration, cornering or braking capability of their cars, even in emergency situations. So they can get away with poor tires and not notice anything. Inflation pressure is a controversial subject. The carmakers pressure recommendations should be viewed as minimum. On my Saab, that is stated so on the sticker, with higher pressures set for increased load and speeds. The tires sidewall pressure states the maximum. Yes, it produces a rougher ride at higher pressures. But load capability and handling are improved and rolling resistance is reduced. Hydroplaning speed is increased with higher pressure. I had the original tires on my 1972 Centurion bicycle until last year. The "gumwall" sidewalls had long crumbled to nothing. But the tread remained OK until the very end. That was 40 years. So I think perhaps the answer to the age discussion may lie in the fact that synthetic rubber does age, oxidize, and harden through UV exposure, but the rate depends on the quality of the rubber and the exposure history. If the rubber is hard and resistant to indentation, then don't use the tire.

  • TR4 TR4 on Mar 12, 2014

    One thing I've not seen mentioned in this thread is steel belt deterioration. I've had it happen with two sets of tires. The belt breaks, the tread gets distorted and it feels like a terrible case of imbalance. A frequent recommendation is not to use steel belted tires (most of them nowadays) beyond six years from date of manufacture i.e. not date of installation. Big problem with "collectible" cars, not so much daily drivers.

  • ToolGuy Personally I have no idea what anyone in this video is talking about, perhaps someone can explain it to me.
  • ToolGuy Friendly reminder of two indisputable facts: A) Winners buy new vehicles (only losers buy used), and B) New vehicle buyers are geniuses (their vehicle choices prove it):
  • Groza George Stellantis live off the back of cheap V8 cars with old technology and suffers from lack of new product development. Now that regulations killed this market, they have to ditch the outdated overhead.They are not ready to face the tsunami of cheap Chinese EVs or ready to even go hybrid and will be left in the dust. I expect most of their US offerings to be made in Mexico in the future for good tariff protection and lower costs of labor instead of overpriced and inflexible union labor.
  • MaintenanceCosts This is delaying an oil change for my Highlander by a couple of weeks, as it prevented me from getting an appointment before a business trip out of town. Oh well, much worse things have happened.I also just got a dealership oil change for my BMW (thanks, loss-leader prepaid plans!) and this didn't seem to affect them at all.
  • Kwik_Shift_Pro4X Gonna need more EV fuel.