Germany: Judge Blasts Speed Cameras as Cash Grab

The Newspaper
by The Newspaper
germany judge blasts speed cameras as cash grab

A veteran district court judge in Herford, Germany earlier this month dismissed 42 speed camera citations on the grounds that they were not issued for any legitimate safety purpose. Judge Helmut Knoner blasted the use of cameras that has turned into a multi-billion-dollar worldwide industry.

“Speed cameras are often a big rip-off,” Knoner said. “There is no law that regulates when, where and how measurements are made. For me, the reasonable suspicion is that cities, counties and police authorities only want to make money.”

Knoner vowed not to convict anyone based on speed camera evidence until the law changes to provide clear protections for motorists. Existing prosecutions take advantage of statutes designed to fight terrorism and organized crime, not traffic violations. Knoner argued that the state was misapplying the law. As long as a driver remains silent, a photograph is insufficient, absent other evidence, to identify the offender. He added that there was an inherent conflict of interest in having local officials decide where to place cameras considering the amount of money they are able to generate. He said that if the state wants to raise revenue, it should raise taxes, not issue tickets.

“How can I judge whether a speed camera to make money or was set up because of an accident black spot?” Knoner wrote in his ruling. “We need rules on how and where should be photographed and that speed cameras are set up there where it has meaning and purpose.”

Knoner has served on the bench for thirty years. Prosecutors are now looking at the possibility of appealing the cases. In an online chat with Stern TV last week, the judge expanded on his reasoning.

“In recent years, the density of monitoring by automated systems and new methods (e.g. laser) has increased significantly,” Knoner said. “Now, digital technology watches 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. The situation on the streets alternates between dense traffic and very low-traffic. Monitoring systems do not adapt. If there is any breach it suspects a ‘speedster.’ Because of the new technology, I think it is possible that the high-volume monitoring will continue to increase, possibly only for financial reasons. This must be stopped.”

Knoner emphasized that the procedural rules are put in place to prevent an abuse of power by the state. He explained that it is essential not to allow the government to violate its own rules. He hoped other judges would join in his effort.

“If many judges participate, it will put considerable pressure on the federal government,” Knoner said. “The government then will have no choice but to establish clear rules.”


Join the conversation
2 of 12 comments
  • Herb Herb on Nov 15, 2010

    Right he is. Let's praise the independence of judges. Income-wise, German communities DO rely on speeding tickets. Usually, speed-traps are set up at four-lane inner city roads, with ample bushes to hide, not on accident-prone spots. Same with Autobahns. Driving with about 180 km/h on a totally empty Autobahn does not impose any dangers to anyone, but offers a nice source of income from machine-ticketing to our overlords. Nobody cares about REAL dangerous driving, because there is no way of automating the prosecution of such offenses. I've got two "speeding" tickets over the last 5 years for exceeding the speed limit by 4 km/h and 6 km/h somewhere in the woods, by a "Kommunaler Interessenverband" (a society set up by broken municipalities in order to cash money from "speeders"). After this "Interessenverband" was dissolved by court order due to corruption and criminal offenses and there was no real speed ticketing for more than a year, nothing changed with regard to safety on the road. Just a decrease in income for the communities involved setting up this scheme. Now let's wait for the chorus of the do-gooders singing: "Just obey the speed limits" and "If only one accident is prevented".

  • Vento97 Vento97 on Nov 16, 2010

    YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! His Honor doesn't beat around the bush or sugarcoat the issue. Something you won't hear from spineless politicians or bureaucrats whose coffers depend on $$$$ from said industry...

  • Ravenuer The Long Island Expressway.
  • Kwik_Shift A nice stretch of fairly remote road that would be great for test driving a car's potential, rally style, is Flinton Road off of Highway 41 in Ontario. Twists/turns/dips/rises. Just hope a deer doesn't jump out at you. Also Highway 60 through Algonquin Provincial Park in Ontario. Great scenery with lots of hills.
  • Saeed Hello, I need a series of other accessories from Lincoln. Do you have front window, front and rear lights, etc. from the 1972 and 1976 models
  • Probert Wow - so many digital renders - Ford, Stellantis. - whose next!!! They're really bringing it on....
  • Zerocred So many great drives:Dalton Hwy from Fairbanks to the Arctic Circle.Alaska Marine Highway from Bellingham WA to Skagway AK. it was a multi-day ferry ride so I didn’t actually drive it, but I did take my truck.Icefields Parkway from Jasper AB to Lake Louise AB, CA.I-70 and Hwy 50 from Denver to Sacramento.Hwy 395 on the east side of the Sierras.