California: Two More Cities Dump Red Light Cameras

The Newspaper
by The Newspaper
california two more cities dump red light cameras

Red light cameras are becoming less popular among municipal leaders in California. On Monday, the Yucaipa city council voted unanimously to cancel its photo enforcement contract with Redflex Traffic Systems of Australia. The previous week, Costa Mesa officially pulled the plug on its automated ticketing machines.

The controversial cameras caused an increase in accidents in Costa Mesa, according to city data. In 2005, the California Supreme Court allowed an appellate division ruling to stand against Costa Mesa’s cameras. The appellate judge had found that Costa Mesa violated the state code by failing to provide 30-days notice for each intersection where the devices were used, as required by the law. It also found the city improperly allowed another agency to control and set signal timing ( view ruling).

Yucaipa’s problems were less dramatic. The city council silently swallowed a $198,000 bill from Redflex in order to get out from under the program that failed to meet revenue expectations since it signed a three-year contract with the Australian company in December 2007. The first citations were issued in April 2009.

“The program was not very productive in terms of paying for itself,” Public Works Director Bill Hemsley explained. “The anticipated revenue was a loss.”

The city blamed the San Bernardino County courts for having compassion on local residents whose per capita income is $18,949. Instead of attempting to collect the stiff, near $500 fine for mostly minor, technical violations all at once, the court offered installment plans that delayed full payment to the city. In other cases, the court slashed the payment due.

“Many citations were either forgiven or the fines were drastically reduced,” Hemsley said. “Fortunately there was a provision in the contract to revisit within a year the program. Staff did that… There was not a good solution found.”

By the time all installments are received, the city expects $155,000 in revenue. After paying Redflex $198,000, that represents a net loss of $43,000. The Australian company initially insisted on payment of $236,620.24 to cancel the contract but after negotiation agreed to offer a 22 percent discount to the city.

A number of other cities have dropped automated ticketing machines. In April, Loma Linda and San Carlos ended their red light camera programs. Moreno Valley gave Redflex its walking papers in January. Yucaipa’s cameras were unplugged on June 30. Costa Mesa’s were turned off July 22.

A copy of Hemsley’s memo to the Yucaipa city council is available in a 200k PDF file at the source link below.

Termination of Contract — Redflex Traffic Systems Inc (City of Yucaipa, California, 7/26/2010)


Join the conversation
2 of 4 comments
  • Russycle Russycle on Aug 02, 2010

    I like the idea of red light cameras, I see way too many people blatantly running reds. But when corporations and municipalities treat them as cash cows instead of safety enhancements, they're a disaster. Time to pull the plug.

  • Pete Anthan Pete Anthan on Aug 02, 2010

    I don't like the idea of people running red lights and I'm not sure who does. Some idiot comes barreling through the intersection on his way to whatever idiot place he's going. That could be you and your family getting broadsided, or me and mine. I agree, though, that revenue-generating red light cameras are a complete money-grubbing disaster. So, what's the better solution? Running a red light is, after all, illegal not to mention insane. (You'll INVARIABLY get stuck at the next red light, meaning you gain nothing.) Now what?

  • Zang You just proved me right lol. dont worry, outside ttac people dont value your opinion either.
  • Fred Mean while, 2 people dies last night because of DUI Just saying EDIT: Just saw that id a woman whose Tesla crashed into a pole, but she was driving.
  • MaintenanceCosts If you are going to buy anything Hellcat or 392 equipped, you better have a garage with steel doors, high-security locks, and some reinforcement for the walls. These things are catnip for thieves, including some with markedly higher levels of skill than Kia Boyz.
  • Fie on Fiasler "Pedestrian" is often a euphemism for "homeless," especially in blue cities.
  • Oberkanone Too slow! Need a Trackhawk.