Capsule Review: 2010 Lexus ES350

David C. Holzman
by David C. Holzman

It’s hard to fault the 2010 Lexus ES 350. There is no hint of rattle. The suspension feels as though it would take the worst New England washboard roads with aplomb. The steering is responsive and precise, and the handling crisp at modestly extra-legal speeds on Clifton VA’s marvelously twisty, hilly byways, despite 3,600 lbs of mass–almost parsimonious in this age of bloat–although you get the feeling you might begin to push the limits of crisp if you go much faster around here.

When you punch the gas the six-speed slushbox practically says “yes sir!” and salutes as it downshifts, and the melodiously burbling 272 hp, 3.5 L V6 blasts off. The ES has as much power as the South Seas had breadfruit back in Captain Bligh’s day. I mean, I can’t help thinking it would have blown The Rip Chords’ “Hey Little Cobra” right off of the track, along with the Stingray that the Cobra shut down back during the LBJ administration.

Oh, it would be nice to have RWD, as when you whomp the fun-pedal you feel the nagging symptoms of pull-power, a little bit of steering this way and that from cracks in the road, although I didn’t spin the tires once, a problem that plagued me with a VW Eos and other FWD fun cars. It’s actually amazing what this thing can do despite the absence of an optimal power train configuration. And if Heaven bestows it upon you, you are not going to sell it for the cash and hang onto your old WRX or whatever performance sedan from at least five years ago currently gives you your jollies.

Or maybe you might. Inside the Lexus there is space and comfort front and back, despite my elongated torso, which pushes my scalp to the roof in just about anything with a sunroof, and in this thing, too, though barely. But the damn greenhouse has such narrow slits that I feel like I’m in a space capsule, which would be fine if that were the moon down there. But it’s not the moon, it’s just Northern Virginia. Still, it’s beautiful out here in horse country. But even on the blasted Beltway, driving by Tyson’s Corner, I prefer to see my surroundings, and not just navigate through them.

Thanks to Will Meyer, of sureshotinc.com, Arlington, VA, for letting some maniac drive his car for TTAC

David C. Holzman
David C. Holzman

I'm a freelance journalist covering science, medicine, and automobiles.

More by David C. Holzman

Comments
Join the conversation
2 of 39 comments
  • Mtymsi Mtymsi on Jun 04, 2010

    The buyers of ES 350's are not in any way the same buyers of 3 series. The former want a more traditional luxury car (read road isolation) and the later want a performance orientated car (read road feel). To me it's ridiculous trying to compare the two cars as they attract completely different buyer segments.

  • Gottleib Gottleib on Jun 04, 2010

    mtysmsi you are absolutely correct. Lexus competes more for the Mercedes/Jaguar buyer while BMW is more competitive with Audi or Acura. i too hate the small window (gunsight look) that seems to be so prevalent. Currently I am holding on to my 2000 Avalon because the newer ones have about half the visibility of the earlier model. The more glass the better, can't stand the feeling of being in a capsule when I am driving.

  • Varezhka $35k, 184hp, and 25mpg EPA combined. With modern VW reliability and old school Hyundai level interior. I think I will take a CX-50, thank you very much.
  • Canam23 A good friend and his wife had one of these, and it ate them out of house and home. One major repair after another with no end in sight. I helped them unload it and put her in a Hyundai Vera Cruz, they put 200K miles on that with no problems.
  • Mister Unless you are a factory-trained Volkswagen technician, there is so much *nope* in this car that I don't even know where to begin.
  • Tassos VERY CLOSE FRIENDS OF MINE can tell you what a TRULY UTTER PIECE OF JUNK VWs, and IN PARTICULAR THE PITIFUL TIGUAN, are. Within the same couple, they have HEAVEN (a Lexus RX) and HELL (the ACCURSED TIGUAN, which spends more time in the shop than on the road. Its unlucky owner is my dear friend Anna P., who is a successful ORTHODONTIST, (grad studies at Tufts U) and could afford a MAYBACH if she wanted to.
  • Theflyersfan Having had some as loaners and rentals, and my sister and brother-in-law recently purchasing one, there was one thing left out. VW has to work on the quality of their plastics. Some of the materials feel as bad as 2002-era Nissan (an Altima 3.5SE on a test drive, with 7 miles on it, was already rattling and squeaking) especially on the doors and lower touch points. Some of the ongoing problems i had with my VW dealt with plastic quality - i had the overhead console buttons fall into the housing several times - and there were already squeaks at under 10,000 miles. They are so close with their cars and CUVs. They have designs people like. Just stop with the cheap plastics in so many obvious places. And if you touch the materials that make up the inside of the rear doors, you might be shocked how poor the quality is. Expect cargo to scratch the daylights out of the plastics.
Next