Mercedes Falls Behind BMW In India

by Cammy Corrigan

January 4th, 2010 5:22 PM

If you hear a loud screeching noise coming from the Stuttgart area, that’ll probably be Dieter Zetsche berating his Asian management team. The Economic Times of India reported that the Mercedes-Benz marque has lost its leadership of the luxury car segment in India to BMW after nearly ten years on top. Daimler also posted a 10.43% decline in sales in India, as volume fell to 3,247 units (if that doesn’t seem like much, consider that Mercedes also trails BMW in China by about 60k units to about 90k). And just like that, out come the excuses: “We are behind BMW in 2009 because of limited availability of our E-Class car … I don’t want to focus on leadership. We want to have a profitable growth,” Mercedes Benz India Managing Director and CEO Wilfried Aulbur told reporters. “We see a very strong growth in 2009 and it will be a blockbuster year for us. We are very bullish and we expect, it will be a high double-digit growth.”

However, Daimler have not hit the (semi) nuclear option of offering discounts to move vehicles. Wilfried Aulbur said “The focus is on profitable growth, overall discount is detrimental and it is not our focus. Just to generate volume is not a good strategy.” Herr Aulbur also believes that lack of uniform taxes on cars are also to blame. Aulbur said, “We need fair treatment across the line that will lead to volume and it will lead to investment. I want uniform tax for all car.” . According to the Economic Times of India, small cars are subject to an 8% excise duty while bigger cars are levied at 20%, with an additional 15,000 Indian Rupees for cars having engines between 1500cc and 2000cc, while cars with engines bigger than 2000cc have to pay 20000 Indian Rupees. Is Herr Aulbur seriously suggesting that a Hyundai i10 should have the same tax as a Mercedes-Benz E class? With logic like that, no wonder they’re losing market share in India.

#BMW #Daimler #India #Luxury #Mercedes #Sales

Comments

Join the conversation

2 of 7 comments

BuzzDog on Jan 04, 2010

I wish that Herr Zetsche would focus less on production volume, and more on the quality of build and materials. The Mercedes-Benzes I coveted as I was growing up had two key characteristics: Rock-solid quality and relative scarcity. Those things well justified their premium price.

Like Reply
Psarhjinian on Jan 04, 2010

Mercedes' problem is that they're not really able to understand that they make mistakes. All of the German marques do this, but Daimler is the worst: in their minds, everything they do is brilliant. On top of that, there's whole rafts of people who've built their careers enforcing this echo chamber. You can't fight this once it's taken hold, because any sign of reticence or admission of fault is seen as a critical weakness. You can never be wrong, because if you're wrong about one thing, you might be wrong about everything. So you make damn sure you're never seen as being wrong, and you build the house of cards ever higher until it collapses spectacularly. If this sounds a lot like the D3 in general, and the General in particular, it should.

Like Reply

Recent Comments

Sgeffe How does this compare to something like the Polaris Slingshot?
Lou_BC I just don't like the C - pillar lines. The rear window doesn't flow with the roofline.
Lou_BC You'd think that since England is 40 times smaller than the USA, EV's would be a shoe in. Thanks BREXIT.
Lou_BC "To be sure, many suppliers have received much-needed relief from automakers or their Tier 1 customers. And despite the significant pressure suppliers have found themselves under after unprecedented challenges in recent years, a wave of supplier bankruptcies that some have feared has not come to pass."You can say that again..........oh.....wait..... you did.
Lou_BC Lately I've had the crap scared out of me a few times. The most freaky was the other day. I was heading out to a lake with my dogs. I was at a "highway" traffic light. A small SUV was next to me in the outside lane. The light changes and we both accelerate. I'm a bit faster. I look in my centre mirror and a GM Sierra pulling an ATV on a utility trailer in right on my butt. He' so close I can just see the top of his grill. I accelerate up to 105 KPH (Speed limit 100 kph). He's still right there. I'm not one to brake check but I chose to "cover" my brakes to activate the tail lights as a warning. He swerves into the other lane almost taking out the little SUV. Both his pickup and trailer are wildly swaying all over the place. He zooms off and gets stuck behind a few transport trucks.