Used Car Review: The 2010 BMW Z4, an Extinct Metal Roof Convertible Experience

Corey Lewis
by Corey Lewis
used car review the 2010 bmw z4 an extinct metal roof convertible experience

Back in February, I purchased an old Z4, one of the prior decade’s smattering of folding hardtop convertibles. Nearly extinct today, such a roof arrangement is reserved for high-end European exotica, the C8 Corvette, and the Mazda Miata RF. Over these last months, the past-tense nature of the car I’d bought came to mind more than once. And that’s unfortunate because the Z4 is pretty, pretty good.

I got a good impression of how the BMW fared for comfort on the drive from Nashville to Cincinnati. During the trip north I got familiar with the (optional) bevy of seat adjustments the Z4 offered: Side bolsters can squeeze, the lower seat cushion has a sliding extension, and the power lumbar fills in wherever needed. The seats have a good amount of height adjustment, though taller drivers will find they run out of headroom if the seat isn’t fairly low. 

At 6 feet and with longer legs, I don’t have an issue finding a comfortable driving position. The seat slides back far enough, but I’m against the rear wall. Anybody over 6’2” or so will be uncomfortable with regard to head or leg room, or both. Getting in and out is easier than you might expect. Though the apertures look low, the seat is far enough down that hitting one’s head is not a worry. Exiting requires a bit of flexibility, and there are no grab bars to be found.

Once inside, the decade-plus-old cabin presents itself well. Materials are of good quality, with (optional) real wood and faux stitching across the dash. The Z’s simple interior design helps it age well, as do the circular climate controls that are unique to the model. Buttons give good feedback when pressed, though there’s a lack of consistent feel between the higher-quality climate controls and wheel buttons and lower-quality ones on the stereo.

Ringed in chrome, climate controls are easy to understand. There’s a temperature setting for passenger and driver, fan speed, and bi-level adjustment. Climate control was an optional extra, and grants an Auto mode I don’t use. Air conditioning cools the small cabin easily on hot days, though the fan gets a bit blustery sounding on level four or five.

Most all equipment is powered (and optional), and the heated seats warm up very quickly on cold days. Absent is any seat ventilation, which should be included. For better or worse there’s a general feeling of The Old School in here, as there’s no screen (optional), no parking sensors, and no camera. Drivers become quickly reacquainted with looking over the shoulder while reversing.

The stereo sounds nice and maintains decent fidelity when the top is down. There’s slightly too much bass, an issue that persists even with a -3 setting on the tuner. Credit the large subwoofers behind the seats, part of the optional Professional stereo package. Stereo knobs for tuning and volume are too small, though the controls are replicated on the steering wheel. There’s Bluetooth for phones which is easy to pair, but nothing for streaming music.

Gauges are clear and easy to read, though may be small for those used to a screen presentation or a more traditional gauge size. While levers and switches fall easily to hand, the turn signal and high-beam stalk are right above the cruise control lever, which is identical in look and feel, and operated using the exact same methodology. They’re so close together that more than once when attempting to activate the cruise control, I’ve flashed my brights at the driver in front. Setting the cruise control presents a cool green LED square that slides smoothly from 0 on the speedo to wherever you’ve set it. 

Part of the turn signal lever is the trip computer, which contains several different menus that allow more car customization than one might expect. The hieroglyphics require the use of the owner’s manual, but reward with Twilight Sentinel features, optional beeps and flashes for locking and unlocking, and even a triple lane change blink from activating the turn signal lightly. Exterior greetings via white LED light (under door handles and puddle lamps) and orange ambient interior lighting look nice at night, but are part of an optional lighting package.

Within the menus is the information on servicing, temperature, tire pressure, and oil level, which lead to my first fault: The oil level sensor is nonoperational and has been since I took delivery. This a common problem, but an important one as BMW removed dipsticks long ago. I’ll have that addressed at my first service. 

Once the adjusting and fiddling are finished, the 3.0-liter inline-six is fired up via the start button (optional). 255 silky smooth horsepowers and 220 torques shift through a six-speed automatic that’s rarely caught off-guard. One of the better automatics I’ve experienced in recent memory, there are only occasional hesitations when a quick downshift is requested and the car is in Normal mode. More on that in a moment. 

Though it’s low to the ground, visibility is generally good to the front, side, and blind spot areas. The side glass extends well toward the rear, and the lack of a B-pillar means blind spot detection (not available) isn’t missed. The view out the rear is compromised by a high deck and small rear window which means reversing into regular parking spaces with tall curbs is a bad idea. Parallel parking isn’t fun either, as it’s difficult to see where the back of the car is. 

The front view takes some getting used to as well, as the long hood is plenty visible to the driver but its corners are not. That’s especially true when maneuvering around taller obstacles since it’s impossible to see over the high fender. Such situations call for a head out the window.

Visibility concerns fade in most driving situations, especially when the Z is pointed at a curvy road. The engine is willing and responsive, and the steering is accurate if a bit dead. Compensating for this is excellent grip from Bridgestone Potenza run-flat tires. Throw it at a corner and the Z hangs on tight and doesn’t ask for a slower pace. 

Everything feels balanced as the car pivots on command and shrinks around you. On occasion, a flat throttle reminds us this is the 255-horse 30i and not the twin-turbo 300-horse 35i, but it’s not a concern in most instances. The ride is firm, but in keeping with the roadster genre. It’s a big adjustment coming from the GS, which now seems like a very padded noise-deprivation chamber that rides high in the air. 

The optional M-Sport package adds adjustable transmission programming via Normal, Sport, and Sport+ modes. Both Sport settings make the dampers firmer, and the shift logic much more aggressive. Notably, activating Sport+ turns off the traction control. 

Manual paddles can be activated on the fly temporarily, or permanently by switching the shifter into manual mode. Their operation is unusual in that both paddles can change gears up (push away) and down (pull toward). The paddles have a very expensive feel and are made of solid polished metal. 

The firm dampers are notable in the Sport modes, and things end up a bit too jiggly: The car feels nervous over rough pavement. Sport is a better compromise than Sport+ unless the pavement is very smooth. In all situations, the grip of the tires (225/40R18 front, 255/35R18 rear) brings with it road noise. It’s not noticeable until speeds are over 45 miles per hour or so, but at freeway speeds, there’s a constant hum. Tramlining occurs as well. 

The tire noise is perhaps more notable because wind noise is less than expected. A solid roof, lots of rubber sealing, and tight joins at the roof panels mean the most wind noise you’ll hear is from the side mirrors. Despite the road noise, it’s easy to go way too fast in everyday drives. Without a careful eye on the speedo, the Z4 will settle into its own pace in the upper two or low three-digit range. 

All driving is accompanied by a throttle pedal with a good amount of resistance that’s immediately easy to modulate. The brakes are easy to learn as well, though the pedal is a bit softer than may be expected. Disclaimer here that it’s 13 years old, so other examples may vary.

Once the weather warmed to an almost acceptable level in the low 50s, it was convertible time. One button and 16 seconds is all it takes, as the three total segments sandwich themselves into the trunk. Top-down operation around town has limited buffeting in the cabin if the winds are calm, and driving on the freeway sans roof is acceptable if the side windows are up. 

Practicality is not the aim of this sort of car, but it’s not as bad as one might assume. Storage space inside is very limited: There’s a small parcel shelf behind the seats with a net, and a ski pass-through to the trunk (optional). The trunk itself is large and has a nice, flat cargo area with the trunk partition stowed away. 

To open the roof the partition must be in place, at which point cargo access is reduced to a slot for a soft bag. It takes planning if cargo is involved and the top will be down, in an order of operations way. There’s a cargo access mode activated via the remote, which will lift the roof panels so the partition can be moved temporarily, and items loaded or unloaded. 

Roof operation from the remote is a nice showy touch, though it can only be used if within 10 feet of the car. And only if the partition is down. And only if it’s parked on flat enough ground that the gyroscopic sensor says it’s okay. Processes and procedures are very German.

Overall the Z4 has impressed me with its enthusiastic personality and excellent handling. Miles per gallon have varied from 25 to 30 per tank, dependent upon the mix of highway usage and country joyriding. Beyond the facts and figures and calculations, at the push of a button and a moment’s wait, a routine drive becomes something fun. That’s just what I wanted.

[Images © 2023 Corey Lewis/The Truth About Cars]

Become a TTAC insider. Get the latest news, features, TTAC takes, and everything else that gets to the truth about cars first by subscribing to our newsletter.

Join the conversation
6 of 56 comments
  • 28-Cars-Later 28-Cars-Later on Jun 01, 2023

    Corey - I think I am going to issue a fatwa demanding a cool kids car meetup in July somewhere in the Ohio region.

    • See 2 previous
    • 28-Cars-Later 28-Cars-Later on Jun 02, 2023

      I spent a week in Columbus years ago and really liked it... I've also been to Athens though it was even longer ago.

  • Slyons Slyons on Jun 12, 2023

    Very nice, that has my favorite BMW interior color scheme. Light tan leather and black, with the classic orange illumination on the dash features and no giant screen. I had a 128i that was similar.

    However, regarding the headline, does the MX-5 RF not count as a hard top convertible? Not quite extinct yet.

    • Corey Lewis Corey Lewis on Jun 19, 2023

      You must only read to the second sentence to get an explanation. "Nearly extinct today, such a roof arrangement is reserved for high-end European exotica, the C8 Corvette, and the Mazda Miata RF."

  • Dusterdude @El scotto , I'm aware of the history, I have been in the "working world" for close to 40 years with many of them being in automotive. We have to look at situation in the "big picture". Did UAW make concessions in past ? - yes. Do they deserve an increase now ? -yes . Is their pay increase reasonable given their current compensation package ? Not at all ! By the way - are the automotive CEO's overpaid - definitely! (That is the case in many industries, and a separate topic). As the auto industry slowly but surely moves to EV's , the "big 3" will need to be producing top quality competitive vehicles or they will not survive.
  • Art_Vandelay “We skipped it because we didn’t think anyone would want to steal these things”-Hyundai
  • El scotto Huge lumbering SUV? Check. Unknown name soon to be made popular by Tiktok ilk? Check. Scads of these showing up in school drop-off lines? Check. The only real over/under is if these will have as much cachet as Land Rovers themselves? A bespoken item had to be new at one time. Bonus "accepted by the right kind of people" points if EBFlex or Tassos disapproves.
  • El scotto No, "brothers and sisters" are the core strength of the union. So you'll take less money and less benefits because "my company really needs helped out"? The UAW already did that with two-tier employees and concessions on their last contract.The Big 3 have never, ever locked out the UAW. The Big 3 have agreed to every collective bargaining agreement since WWII. Neither side will change.
  • El scotto Never mind that that F-1 is a bigger circus than EBFlex and Tassos shopping together for their new BDSM outfits and personal lubricants. Also, the F1 rumor mill churns more than EBFlex's mind choosing a new Sharpie to make his next "Free Candy" sign for his white Ram work van. GM will spend a year or two learning how things work in F1. By the third or fourth year GM will have a competitive "F-1 LS" engine. After they win a race or two Ferrari will protest to highest F-1 authorities. Something not mentioned: Will GM get tens of millions of dollars from F-1? Ferrari gets 30 million a year as a participation trophy.