Turn Down for Watt: EVs May Lower Power Rates – Report

Matthew Guy
by Matthew Guy
turn down for watt evs may lower power rates report

In what is – for this addled author, at least – a mind-bending concept, a recent study by an outfit called Synapse Energy Economics suggests the adoption of electric vehicles may actually lower the cost of electricity.

That sound you hear is the B&B tripping over seized engine blocks and rusty Panther chassis cross members as they race to the comment section.

As with all studies, it’s worth noting a few caveats. In this case, a few huge caveats. The study was paid for by an environmental group called the Natural Resources Defense Council and focused on data collected in certain parts of California. In that state – and some others, apparently – a law can force utility companies to enact rate cuts to pass some of their profit to customers if the utilities suddenly start making more money. This has historically been the case in some jurisdictions to help prevent nefarious businesses from jacking up power rates, making everyone’s lives unaffordable, and making off to Tahiti with the cash.

Another key part of the study? Off-peak rates. Also called the time-of-use (TOU) structure, it differs significantly from so-called tiered rates which bump users into different price brackets as their electricity use increases. The study estimates EV owners in Cali will increase their consumption by about 260 kWh per month, which does seem on the low side but we’ll roll with it for the purposes of this analysis. Since it has been found that the vast majority of EV owners charge at home overnight, the study points out that EV customers on TOU rates o􏰁en hit their monthly maximum demand when the system is least taxed— typically between 11:00 p.m. and 2:00 in the morning

Here's where the switch flips (pun intended). Architects of the study say EVs have increased utility revenues more than they have increased utility costs, leading to downward pressure on electric rates for EV owners and non‐EV owners alike. Over a 10-year stretch at a trio of California electric companies, electric car owners have apparently contributed $1.7 billion more than associated costs (in 2021 dollars). The eggheads say a key reason why revenues from EVs outweigh the costs is that EV customers, particularly those on TOU rates, tend to charge during off‐peak hours. By charging when the grid is relatively quiet, it is suggested EVs impose minimal costs on the grid and help to utilize resources more efficiently.

In other words, the study is implying that power companies are raking in far more money from supplying power for EV charging than they are spending on system upgrades and maintenance. If hewing to the profit-sharing decree mentioned at the top of this post, customers as a whole could enjoy bigger rebates. 

Of course, anyone plugging in an EV every night is going to spend more overall on electricity every month than if they weren’t. And there is obviously some tipping point at which too many cars are plugged into the grid and the place makes like planet Melmac on ALF.

Still, it’s an interesting take. The entire report is available here.

[Image: Hyundai]

Become a TTAC insider. Get the latest news, features, TTAC takes, and everything else that gets to the truth about cars first by subscribing to our newsletter.

Join the conversation
2 of 49 comments
  • 2ACL Some of the reported issues sound expensive for all but the most committed wrenchers. Scant documentation on some of the previous work is also a minus. I wouldn't mind something like this, but whereas the seller is trying to make room, I don't have any for something this intensive.
  • Merc190 Any Alfa has a unique character built in, so there's that, once you get it running properly, until it doesn't...
  • Syke Yeah, no sympathy for the dealerships whatsoever. I've gone enough thru training a dealership's salesperson under the guise of trying to buy an EV. I'm pleasantly surprised that Ford's insisting on Level 3 DC Fast Charging rather than the usual Level 2 that most dealerships have now. This is definitely forcing a commitment on the part of the dealer that they're going to be serious about selling EV's.Oh yeah, DC Fast Charging is never free, so you're definitely talking another income stream for the dealership. The big question is are they smart enough to make something real of it?I continue to say that the legacy automakers biggest problem when it comes to selling EV's is their own dealerships. And this article really drives that home.
  • SCE to AUX Yeah, I'm going to spend 5 or 6 figures on a used/abused car from a punk.
  • MrIcky I'm not buying any of Musk's BS until he steps into the ring with Zuckerberg. Musk dropped the challenge, Mark picked it up, Musk pussed out. 2 men enter, 1 man leaves- you know the law.