GM: Our Takata Airbags Are Better Than Those Other Takata Airbags

by Steph Willems

Published: November 22nd, 2016

gm our takata airbags are better than those other takata airbags

A crop of General Motors pickups and SUVs left the factory with potentially deadly Takata airbags, but the automaker has won approval to delay their recall.

According to The Detroit News, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has allowed GM to defer repairs on 2.5 million vehicles so it can test the lifespan of the faulty parts. Naturally, there are conditions attached.

The GM vehicles make up a small part of the massive Takata recall, which so far has seen about 70 million vehicles recalled to fix airbag inflators that could explode, leading to serious injury or death. The ammonium nitrate propellant in the inflators breaks down over time — a problem compounded by heat and humidity. So far, the issue has been linked to 11 deaths and hundreds of injuries.

The NHTSA said today that it would grant GM “a short deferral” of its obligation to fix the airbags. Takata airbags are found in certain 2007 to 2011 GM vehicles, including the Chevrolet Silverado, GMC Sierra, Chevrolet Tahoe, Chevrolet Suburban, Cadillac Escalade and GMC Yukon.

In September, the automaker petitioned the road safety regulator in the hopes of conducting long-term tests with the help of a third-party research firm. The tests aim to nail down the safe service life of the Takata components. GM has claimed the inflators in its vehicles are safer than the others, thanks to a more robust design.

If the agreement sounds dicey, make no mistake — the NHTSA has eyes on GM’s experiment and can pull the plug at any time. The automaker must also deliver monthly updates.

“If at any point there is any evidence of a testing or field rupture, NHTSA can immediately act to reject the petition and compel the recall,” NHTSA spokesman Bryan Thomas told The Detroit News. “GM is continuing its work to design replacement inflators in the interim.”

GM feels that even the highest-risk vehicles are safe until the end of 2019, and wants a chance to prove it. The study should be complete by August of next year.

Earlier this year, a dire-sounding NHTSA bulletin targeted Honda and Acura models from the early 2000s, explaining that those vehicles faced a much higher risk of airbag rupture. Since then, a California woman died as a result of an airbag rupture in one of the flagged vehicles.

[Image: RL GNZLZ/ Flickr ( CC BY-SA 2.0)]

#GeneralMotors #GM #NHTSA #Safety #Takata #TakataAirbagRecall

Steph Willems

More by Steph Willems

Comments

Join the conversation

5 of 22 comments

MatadorX on Nov 22, 2016

Ehhh I don't see the difference between owning a Takata equipped domestic car that HAS been forced to be recalled, and one that hasn't. Keep in mind these guys aren't like Honda/Mazda/Toyota, who are bending backwards to fix the situation, get parts made, contact owners, and install the new part. The domestics couldn't give less of a care. From what I gather, until the wreckage that is Takata is purchased and resumes production, the recalled parts will be on indefinite back-order, with the idea that "well, we notified the consumer, so who cares if the parts take years to show up, we are covered from lawsuits...." Meanwhile my 08 Milan has been waiting for something....anything...communication wise from Ford as to timeline for getting the passenger bag fixed...for over a year. That alone was enough to steer my latest $25k vehicle purchase elsewhere. ...And no if you were wondering this doesn't just affect some odd-ball Mercury. List of cars affected, that Ford has made ZERO effort to begin actually replacing the air bag or even getting the parts made: All Mustangs 05-11 All Rangers 07-11 All Edge/MKX 07-10 And of course all Fusions, Milans, MKZs 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011. That many many millions of cars/affected owners. Likely many times the total volume of all affected Mazdas, however unlike Ford they actually care about their customers and are getting the cars fixed. Why so many love Fords is beyond me. The company clearly cares little about long term retained ownership.

Like Reply
- See 2 previous
- Carguy67 on Nov 22, 2016
  
  Odd. Ford sent the recall notification for my 2008 Mustang GT to me shortly after the issue became well-known, with at least one follow-up before the notification that the 'fix' was available. Had to call 3 dealerships, though, before I found one ready to make the swap, which was done about 6 weeks ago.
  
  Like
- Art Vandelay on Nov 23, 2016
  
  Wasn't Honda trying to get used car buyers to sign waivers of liability prior to purchase? Sounds like the ones bending over are those customers.
  
  Like
- Psychoboy on Nov 23, 2016
  
  @Art Vandelay I've not seen that at any of my local dealers. Any used cars that were on the recall list either got fixed, or parked until parts were available. Existing customers' cars were fixed, parked and given a rental/loaner, or released with a written warning about the open recall. Now that parts supplies are keeping up with demand, all the loaners are home and Honda is back to begging customers to get their cars fixed. Most dealerships are sitting on dozens of airbags that have been ordered for cars and have been waiting a month or more for the customer to come back.
  
  Like
SoCalMikester on Nov 23, 2016

well, my JTKKT VIN toyota scion xA keeps trucking along. no recalls of any sort, whatsoever. JDM baybee. boring and slow, but this could well could be the last car i ever own as a primary car. Im in to scooters (japanese megavespas) as a primary form of transport, so im happy

Like Reply

Recent Comments

Offbeat Oddity The price is definitely too high, but this generation of Accord has still been very reliable- not far off from the Camry. I believe the CVTs in these have held up very well, so while not ideal, it wouldn't deter me- the mileage is just way too high.
VoGhost "compliance EVs" - so typically Posky. Come on, Matt, come clean about what Big Oil is paying you already.
VoGhost Great to see leadership from Washington in supporting American businesses and job creation.
VoGhost Oh, Mattie, I am BEGGING you to take a course in economics. There's probably a community college near you offering courses for free or very cheap. Seriously, people this ignorant of basic economics really should not be writing this drivel. Stick to what you know: pimping for big oil.
2manyvettes I was a computer instructor in a local technical college for some years teaching Windows OS and Micosoft Office. Not long before I retired I purchased a Mac Book Air laptop. It didn't take me long to learn the Apple OS and the first thing I learned was the lousy job Microsoft did ripping off the Apple software. I purchased Microsoft Office for Apple at the time and discovered when Apple upgraded the OS to 64 bit and my 32 bit Office software would no longer run on the laptop, that embedded in the Apple OS was software that could open any Office file and could save any file in Microsoft file format. I have always felt if Apple sold product at PC prices they would put Microsoft out of business. Oh, and I bought my Mac ten years ago and still runs like brand new. Effect on Rivian? Who knows? Based on my experience with their technology, it could be interesting.