Hammer Time: Is Scion The New Geo?
Imagine if you will.
The world’s largest and most consistently successful automaker is in deep trouble. Not because of profits, but because of products.
They build a small car… and a small army of overseas competitors blow it away.
They build a bigger vehicle, and another, and yet another. They build so many models with so many names and variations that they wind up cannibalizing their own products. Every time this happens, they lose sales and more alarmingly, their youngest customers no longer see their products as fashionable.
Every year it gets worse. Then the corporate mothership, which has cost cut their way into the rear view mirror of most of their future customers, comes up with a brilliant marketing idea.
If you can’t beat ‘em, join ‘em — at least for right now.
That was the General Motors of the 1980s. After a mind numbing streak of marketplace losers (Chevette, Sprint, Citation, Omega, T1000, Skyhawk, Cimmaron, Sunbird), GM, under the ever watchful accounting driven gazes of its CEO, Roger Smith, decided that it was time to let imports fight imports. This fight would take place inside Chevy dealerships which were foolishly asked to market a new sub-brand that would compete with higher margin products which already represented the ‘real’ GM metal.
The new brand — Geo — was launched with a mandatory display area (usually in some God forsaken corner of the showroom) for those dealerships that wanted to carry a brand which was all about “Getting to know you.”
First they offered the Geo Prizm. This had been a Toyota in drag which had been marketed as a Chevy Nova during its pre-Geo run. Besides the annual humiliation of having GM’s highest quality plant and product be driven by Toyota know-how, the Nova had also been a sales flop despite the world-class Toyota underpinnings.
Prices were high, dealer margins were minimal, and the commercials? Like an aspiring Yuppie on speed.
The Prizm was followed by the Geo Tracker, which was a Suzuki Sidekick emblazoned with a new Geo logo that, strangely enough, had a bow-tie on the steering wheel — just in case the customers were wondering if it was a real American car, which it wasn’t.
The Geo Metro was next. Although this would turn out to be among the most popular models for gas sippers, tree huggers, rental car companies, and unrepentatnt cheapskates frugal zealots, it didn’t have as strong of a retail presence as many of today’s auto enthusiasts would imagine. The car was flimsy with a new car price to boot, and the acceleration with an automatic was just plain atrocious.
GM needed something, really anything, that would stand out. So what did they do?
They created a joint venture on a sporty coupe — with a company that had zero success in selling sporty coupes.
Sound familiar? It should for those who have followed the recent Scion FR-S. In GM’s case, the Isuzu Impulse, which even came with a Lotus tuned suspension to emphasize handling, was re-homologated into a Geo Storm.
It lasted one generation. The Prizm would last two generations as a Geo, and then would get pulverized into a fine red mist once GM pulled the plug and tried to make it a Chevy. The same with the Metro and the Tracker.
Come to think of it, nobody is quite sure what happened to the Tracker. But rumor has it that the model got eaten by a horde of obese cannibals disguised as Chevy Blazers.
This brings us to the Geo of 2015: Scion.
Like Geo, Scion was initially marketed to the young and youthful in a way that would make middle-aged and older people feel good about their ‘youthful’ purchase. Too bad the advertising was a cacophony of fake special effects and hip-hop fashionistas who apparently were told to display themselves instead of the car.
You think I’m kidding? Well this time, I’m being brutally blunt. On a press launch for the Lexus CT200h back in 2009, the marketing head for that project had also been in charge of launching the Scion brand in the United States. When I asked him why the CT200h didn’t launch as a Scion I was told, “Scion was never marketed as a brand for young people. It was intended to attract people at a specific price range.”
I immediately thought, “Well, okay. I never knew buyers in the $15,000 to $18,000 price hung around college campuses and went to death metal concerts.”
And that to me is the core part of Scion’s failure as a brand — it’s a cannibal. All cannibal sub-brands die in the car business because the core brand is too important to be seriously challenged. As sure as old four-door Geo Metros got recycled into Chinese washing machines, Scion became a poor excuse for Toyota not better supporting their Y2K-era Corolla against the compacts, and last generation Celicas against the sports coupes.
After 10 years of Toyota customers getting to know a slew of Scions, one thing is clear.
More by Steven Lang
Latest Car Reviews
Read moreLatest Product Reviews
Read moreRecent Comments
- ScarecrowRepair I remember when the Gen 2 turbos came out and I was worried my '86 might not last and I should look at the replacements. Not as much fun, and the dealer was an absolute jerk, wouldn't let me do anything but drive around the block. I ended up finally giving it away at 533,000 miles and 29 years when the second engine (first lasted 473,000) blew its head gasket and the connecting rod bearings started knocking. Someone's using it for parts now, and I miss it all the time.
- Tassos https://carsandbids.com/auctions/927xwlgb/2009-mercedes-benz-c63-amg-sedan THIS almost 450 HP and Torque AMG C63 with 79k from 2009, 25 YEARS YOUNGER than Tim's relic, is a much more powerful AND much more practical but above all a FAR FAR FAR SAFER choice than Tim's RELIC of the Day, that even I would at least give a test drive. It just sold for a mere $20k worthless, Cackling Kamala 2024 dollars.
- Tassos https://carsandbids.com/auctions/rj4dOynY/1999-mazda-mx-5-miata I'm not in the market for toys like these, but this Miata with only 37k miles, 15 years YOUNGER than Tim's RELIC, and a PROPER sporty little car, RWD and all, sold for a mere $9k. Given its very low miles, this was a STEAL. It even has the MANUAL.
- 1995 SC I don't know if this is a good price or not, but you'd be hard pressed to get the typical example that shows up of one of these this nice for 20k
- Bd2 4A-GE!
Comments
Join the conversation
Basically... Yes! Scion is a stripped down/decontented car as there's really no options available. I think it's targeted to the Millenials/youngsters. Toyota should save its money/resources and fold Scion back into the Toyota brand and just upgrade the Corollas/Camries with newer technology and designs while lowering the prices. It can then try marketing itself to the younger or newer buyers with an emphasis on newer technology but would have to concentrate on quality control (which it's losing due to its expansion) that's related to its Toyota brand. Heck, make one model from each lineup "sporty" like the Camry SE, but with more emphasis on sport, not just an appearance option package.
What? No mention of the Geo Spectrum ? Great question, Mr. Lang, though I am late to reading this. Wasn't the whole point of Scion to offer basic cars that could be dealer accessorized to an individual's taste and a no haggle pricing scheme, like Saturn? It seems they lost the plot long ago.Keeping it going is just more wasted effort as a Scion would sell much better as a properly badged Toyota.