Federal Agency Pushes States to Toll Existing Roads

federal agency pushes states to toll existing roads

The Federal Highway Administration recently held out $10.5 million to bribe states into turning freeways into toll roads through fiscal 2011. As part of the so-called Value Pricing Program, which Congress introduced in 1991, the agency will take taxes paid by drivers at the pump and underwrite projects designed to charge motorists more for driving on existing roads or increase other fees imposed on drivers.

“These projects show that states are developing new ways of thinking about how to manage congestion,” Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood said in a statement on projects selected in August.

Under the program, FHWA will select fifteen project proposals submitted by state departments of transportation and underwrite up to 80 percent of the cost of feasibility studies and implementation reporting. In August’s funding round, for example, the Virginia Department of Transportation and Washington Council of Governments received $320,000 in taxpayer funds for a study of the “advancement of regional pricing in DC including pricing existing facilities.” The Texas Department of Transportation received $2 million to promote a pay-per-mile insurance pilot programs designed to ease the public into acceptance of the concept of pay-per-mile road pricing. Of the total amount of money allocated, $2.6 million is set aside for “non-tolling” projects such as the use of congestion pricing at parking meters, a system that allows local authorities to charge higher rates for car owners during peak times.

Tolling of roads, especially of “existing facilities,” is frequently criticized as creating so-called Lexus Lanes that force poor commuters to drive in traffic while the wealthy can pay for a quicker journey. To address this problem, the FHWA program will support the diversion of even more money from state and federal gas taxes toward complicated rebate systems or mass transit.

“The potential financial effects of value pricing projects on low-income drivers shall be considered,” FHWA’s Federal Register notice explained. “Where such effects are expected to be both negative and significant, possible mitigation measures should be identified, such as providing new or expanded transit service as an integral part of the value pricing project, toll discounts or credits for low-income motorists who do not have viable transit options, or fare or toll credits earned by motorists by use of regular lanes which can be used to pay for tolls on priced lanes. Additional measures include methods to facilitate convenient cash payment by those who do not have bank accounts or credit cards, or who choose not to tie their toll accounts to their bank accounts or credit cards.”

Applications for the federal funding must be received by January 18, 2011.

[Courtesy: Thenewspaper.com]

Join the conversation
2 of 22 comments
  • Glenn Konze Koniszewski Glenn Konze Koniszewski on Oct 24, 2010

    I'm in favor of raising the fuel tax vs tolling roads. On that note, I agree with TCED2...open those books up. I want to see what types of "pet projects" our tax dollars are being used for. Cut out highway "beautification" projects!

  • ClutchCarGo ClutchCarGo on Oct 25, 2010

    I do think that tolling via automated systems (in addition to gas taxes) is a compelling way to pay for road usage in a more equitable manner. The ability to vary tolls according to demand would help shift some travellers to alternatives (mass transit, work from home) and others to off-peak hours (trucking). This also works better than gas taxes when states have disparate rates; motorists can't avoid paying for their travel by buying fuel in a neighboring state. My biggest problem with toll systems is the lack of privacy in the data collected. With no requirement to show cause for accessing records, law enforcement (and anyone well connected) can review the travel habits of any driver they please. This situation invites abuse, and the spread of data collection via tolling would make the problem much worse. Accessing toll records must require a warrant to ensure that casual access is not allowed. Of course, when our courts are holding that law enforcement doesn't need a warrant to attach a GPS unit to your car, I don't expect that we're going to get any real privacy protection for our travel.

  • JMII "Some U.S. automakers have even begun considering bringing back discounts and incentives which were scrapped during the pandemic as supply constraints became a major issue."If sales drop off then this is the cure. Economics 101. Its about time people realized that paying over MSRP is stupid. I have held off purchasing a new vehicle for almost a full year now due to current conditions.My wife would love to have an EV but at current prices its just not happening. However the same is true for ICE vehicles. Vehicle prices are just too high overall right now and our current fleet continues to function perfectly so we see no reason to upgrade. I could careless what the Jone's down the street do or think.
  • TheEndlessEnigma More Ferrari "quality".
  • EBFlex This is not news. People don’t want autonomous vehicles just like they don’t want EVs. Both are unnecessary and dangerous.
  • Redapple2 I hope i fit in the new version.Wanted one since 1990
  • Redapple2 BeautySoulClass/eleganceRarityExpense.Very interesting series