California: Costa Mesa Red Light Cameras Increased Accidents

The Newspaper
by The Newspaper

According to a recently released Costa Mesa (CA) city council report, the total number of accidents at intersections equipped with red light cameras has increased. The city report did not provide a complete analysis of results at every monitored intersection throughout the past six years. Instead, it cherry-picked data from just two intersections, Harbor Boulevard and Bristol Street and Bristol Street and Anton Boulevard. It then chose four intersections without cameras and compared their performance between 2001 to 2003 (before cameras) and 2006 to 2008 (after cameras). Even with cherry-picked locations, the total number of accidents increased 13 percent while the camera-free intersections experienced a five percent decrease. Rear end collisions also jumped 20 percent with cameras, and dropped 10 percent without; a finding consistent with a number of independent studies of the effects of red light camera use ( view studies).

“Rear end collisions usually increase due to some motorists braking quickly in anticipation of the red light camera activation, while the motorist directly behind does not react in time,” Police Sergeant Rob Sharpnack wrote in a memo to the council. “The increase in rear end collisions accounts for the increase in total collisions.”

The camera intersections reported a 15 percent reduction in the number of times police recorded an “injury collision,” although the British Medical Journal has suggested that police officers in the UK underreport injuries so that camera programs would appear more effective in government reports.

Regardless of the city’s assertions regarding the cameras’ effectiveness, the city has received a large bounty from local residents. Since its inception in July 2003, the automated ticketing program has rewarded the city, county and state governments with millions in revenue. Nestor Traffic Systems (NTS), the bankrupt company in charge of the program, mailed $2,486,944 worth of $436 traffic tickets. Even so, it’s not convinced about the effectiveness of Nestor in running the program in light of the company’s recent financial troubles.

“Over the last six months, the Costa Mesa red light camera program administrator has called NTS on average two to three times per week to address problems with the system including performance issues, billing errors, inaccurate record keeping, yellow phasing problems and computer network issues,” Sharpnack wrote. “It has been increasingly more difficult to speak to a live person at NTS as the company has decreased the size of its staff.”

The problems are especially acute since Costa Mesa, like most cities across the country, exercises no oversight over the ticketing process. At Newport Boulevard last year, for example, the police believed the camera was not functioning properly. The agency had no means of independently verifying proper operation, so it placed a phone call to Nestor. The private company assured the police department that the camera was working just fine. Only after seeing no tickets in the monthly billing statements did the police know for sure that the camera in fact had not been working at all. The department was then able to solve its primary concern, assuring it would receive a refund for Nestor’s monthly operational charge at that intersection.

Costa Mesa has also faced significant legal difficulty over the past several years. In 2005, the city lost a major court battle when the California Supreme Court declined to overturn a decision slamming the city for ignoring a state law regarding red light camera warning periods. The city was also caught issuing tickets at an intersection with an illegally short yellow time.

The police department recommended that the city council consider returning to traditional enforcement with live police officers.

“This greatly increases the number of traffic stops with officers enforcing all moving violations, equipment violations and registration violations,” Sharpnack wrote. “Every available traffic officer participates daily not only to enforce against violating motorists, but to provide a high visibility to gain the attention of passing motorists as well to encourage safe driving habits.”

A copy of the memo is available in an 80k PDF file at the source link below.

Nestor Red Light Camera Enforcement Program Review (City of Costa Mesa, California, 9/1/2009)

The Newspaper
The Newspaper

More by The Newspaper

Comments
Join the conversation
 2 comments
  • AJ AJ on Sep 03, 2009

    I'm not surprised. On my way to work each day, along an interstate that is 55 mph, traffic always flows between 65 and 70 mph; sometimes faster. Whenever the cops have well known speed traps setup, everyone brake checks to 55 mph as they pass the cops, and even sometimes when there are no cops at these locations.

  • Rolosrevenge Rolosrevenge on Sep 03, 2009

    If cities actually cared about safety, they would install Smart Sensors instead of red light cameras.

  • Stephen My "mid-level" limited edition Tonino Lambo Ferraccio Junior watch has performed flawlessly with attractive understated style for nearly 20 years. Their cars are not so much to my taste-- my Acura NSX is just fine. Not sure why you have such condescension towards these excellent timepieces. They are attractive without unnecessary flamboyance, keep perfect time and are extremely reliable. They are also very reasonably priced.
  • Dana You don’t need park, you set auto hold (button on the console). Every BMW answers to ‘Hey, BMW’, but you can set your own personal wake word in iDrive. It takes less than 5 minutes to figure that that out, btw. The audio stays on which is handy for Teams meetings. Once your phone is out of range, the audio is stopped on the car. You can always press down on the audio volume wheel which will mute it, if it bothers you. I found all the controls very intuitive.
  • ToolGuy Not sure if I've ever said this, or if you were listening:• Learn to drive, people.Also, learn which vehicles to take home with you and which ones to walk away from. You are an adult now, think for yourself. (Those ads are lying to you. Your friendly neighborhood automotive dealer, also lying to you. Politicians? Lying to you. Oh yeah, learn how to vote lol.)Addendum for the weak-minded who think I am advocating some 'driver training' program: Learning is not something you do in school once for all time. Learning how to drive is not something that someone does for you. It is a continuous process driven by YOU. Learn how to learn how to drive, and learn to drive. Keep on learning how to drive. (You -- over there -- especially you, you kind of suck at driving. LOL.)Example: Do you know where your tires are? When you are 4 hours into a 6 hour interstate journey and change lanes, do you run over the raised center line retroreflective bumpers, or do you steer between them?
  • Mike Bradley Advertising, movies and TV, manufacturing, and car culture have all made speeding and crashing the ultimate tests of manhood. Throw in the political craziness and you've got a perfect soup of destruction and costs.
  • Lou_BC Jay Leno had said that EV's would be good since they could allow the continued existence of ICE cars for enthusiasts. That sentiment makes sense. Many buyers see vehicles as a necessary appliance.
Next