The Truth About Automotive Electronics Pt. 3: The Ugly

Eric Stepans
by Eric Stepans

Automakers are justifiably proud of the fast, safe, clean and comfortable products they’ve unleashed upon the automotive market. But today’s carmakers have entered into a Faustian bargain with the electronic systems that make these four-wheeled wonders possible, and it’s busy biting them and their customers in their collective keister. Never mind the inherent safety hazards of protecting drivers from their own stupidity. The heavy reliance on technology has fundamentally altered the ownership experience, particularly when these techno-wondercars are repaired and resold.

This problem is particularly acute for high-end, mostly European luxury makes. In the past, upmarket brands justified their price premiums by offering superior performance, handling, comfort and refinement. As less-expensive brands have narrowed the gap, luxury makers have turned to electronic wizardry to create a distinctive distinction. But stuffing more stuff into the cars invites Murphy and his Law to ride shotgun.

Your humble author spent four years battling these issues as a BMW dealership technician and regularly saw Herr Murphy working his mojo. My favorite horror story of that time: a BMW E46 3-Series that was rendered impotent (warning lights aplenty, transmission stuck in second gear) by… wait for it… the radio.

The E46 radio is connected to the engine, transmission and ABS computers (and many others) by a network called the K-bus. When the radio died, it shorted out the K-bus, freaking-out the other computers. Every system that could turn on a warning light did so and the transmission computer went into ‘limp in’ mode: second gear only when in ‘Drive.’

While these sorts of gremlins may be more common in the luxury brands (Mercedes owners unite!), the same systems and problems are now appearing in more mainstream machines. Nissan owners who've put their Intelligent Key fob in the same pocket as their cell phone have discovered that the phone signal scrambles the key programming, rendering it impotent. Honda owners with a persistent ‘check engine’ light may have a major emissions system failure, or they may have slight corrosion on an electrical terminal in the fuse box. No make or model with electronic systems is immune.

Electronic failures differ from mechanical mishaps in important ways. Most mechanical items fail gradually and provide warning signs (noises, visible wear, etc.) indicating that something is amiss. Electronics are usually an either/or situation; they either work or they don’t. They also rarely warn their dependents before they fail. Mechanical systems can often be tweaked or bypassed (e.g. looping heater hoses to bypass a leaking heater core). Electronic systems usually don’t respond to duct tape and WD-40.

This electronic complexity can make for an expensive and time-consuming ownership experience. Increasingly, these systems can only be serviced by dealerships, whose technicians need a lot of (expensive) time and (expensive) training to diagnose the problems. Sometimes, the problems are so subtle that the only recourse is to install part A and see if the problem goes away.

When the owner comes back in a week with the same problem, install part B and repeat until the problem, or the owner, goes away. And make no mistake: these parts are getting mighty expensive. The aforementioned BMW radio lists for $590, and no $79 Pep Boys radio has a K-bus connection. Similarly, the days of cutting a spare key at the hardware store for $5 are long gone.

When the car is under warranty, the customer doesn’t pay the parts and labor costs, and service loaner cars might make frequent dealership visits tolerable. But imagine (or testify) what happens when the warranty ends. Electronic systems are not immune from age-related failures; the owner must bear the full brunt of these costs.

This leaves an owner with a set of tough decisions. Does he fix the problem or try to ignore it? Can he ignore it? If the transmission won’t shift out of second gear, the car isn’t very useful. Are the parts available, new or used? If only used parts are available, how long will they last? Should he just get rid of the car for something newer and/or more reliable?

That last question indicates the area where electronic overkill hurts the car owner the most. Trouble-prone cars have always had low resale values/a shortage of willing buyers. When the troubles are difficult to locate, devilish to rectify and expensive to boot, it only amplifies the situation.

Unfortunately, this is difficult to see in the available data because used car prices are affected by multiple factors. The cachet of MINI and VW, for example, keeps their resale prices high– despite their relatively poor e-reliability records.

Nevertheless, as heavily electronic cars age, the cost of repairs will overwhelm the market values of those cars. This may be the final ironic twist of modern automotive electronics: rendering eight-year-old cars about as valuable as eight-year-old computers.

Eric Stepans
Eric Stepans

More by Eric Stepans

Join the conversation
2 of 59 comments
  • Whatdoiknow1 Whatdoiknow1 on Dec 17, 2007
    I believe that the problem today is not the electronic wizardy within the cars but the fact that there is no redunancy and that they have connected (ala BMW’s k-bus) all of the various subsystems together. This is the type of cheapo engineering I would expect to find hidden underneath a Kia, NOT a BMW! WTF is the point of paying $40,000+ for a car if teh manufacturer is going to dick you around like you purchased a $14,000 bargin basement sub-compact. Like I said when you buy a low priced car fitted with what many would consider to be high-end options like a NAV system you kinda expect to see cut rate engineering as the means of being able to equip a low priced car as such.
  • Driver23 Driver23 on Dec 25, 2007
    I need a GPS, Bluetooth, iPod hookup on the top-end stereo, heated and cooled seats, ABS, stability control, traction control, a built in hard drive to store music, satellite radio, xenon headlights, LEDs in the rear, 300hp, adjustable suspension, hybrid technology, power everything, an automated “manual” transmission, keyless ignition and locking, and so on. I want it for under $30,000. Make it happen! OK, let me see... My PDA has Bluetooth, it can play music, it has GPS and it it rather rugged. It costs $500. One can have rugged notebook with full blown OS and zillion applications for about $1500. Why does can Nav system and upgraded stereo costs $2000? I guess it is about margins. I bet manufacturer cost is $500, not $1950. ABS and traction control are old technologies that typically work reliably and do not need a computer in a sense of iDrive or Audi MM or MB COMAND. Power windows are 30 years old and don't need to be connected to the engine control bus. Automakers do everything they can to prevent you from upgrading stereo yourself for $200 + speakers or adding aftermarket GPS for $300. NOOOOOOO! They'll keep piling gizmos because that's where the margins are and where you don't have any choice except paying the manufacturer outrageous money. iPod integration in E60 BMW for $800??? $300 for iPod and $800 for a small gadget that does not even work reliably? My PC costs that much and happily integrates with iPod for FREE. Alpine aftermarked iPod adapter is $100. And yet BMW happily charges $800.
  • Golden2husky Have to say he did an excellent job on the C7, especially considering the limited budget he was given. I am very happy with my purchase.
  • Marty The problem isn't range; it's lack of electricity in multi-unit building parking. All you need is level 1 - a standard 120v wall socket - and if you're plugged in 10 hours overnight you get 280 miles per week or more. That's enough for most folks but you can use public charging to supplement when needed. Installing conduit circuits and outlets is simple and cheap; no charge stations needed.
  • 2manyvettes Tadge was at the Corvette Corral at the Rolex 24 hour sports car race at the end of January 2023. During the Q&A after his remarks someone stood up and told him "I will never buy an electric Corvette." His response? "I will never sell you an electric Corvette." Take that Fwiw.
  • Socrates77 They're pinching pennies for the investors like always, greed has turned GM into a joke of an old corporate American greed.
  • Analoggrotto looking at this takes me right back to the year when “CD-ROM” first entered public lexicon