Weekend Head Scratcher: Which Car Is Overrated?

Cammy Corrigan
by Cammy Corrigan

Michael Jackson is overrated. There! I said it! You’d be surprised how much trouble that statement has got me into. Not that I’m a stranger to saying stuff that gets me into trouble. If were to say “I think the Rolling Stones” are overrated, most people would shrug and say “Fair enough”. If I were to say “The Beatles’ music isn’t seminal”, most people would say “To each their own”. But every time I say “Michael Jackson’s music all sounds the same and is overrated” people look at me, as if I’ve murdered their children. I just don’t understand this reaction. Why is Michael Jackson above criticism? I mean, Michael Jackson? Is it really THAT blasphemous to question the music of the Mr Jackson? Anyway, this isn’t “The Truth About Music”, it’s “The Truth About Cars”. And it’s this, quite frankly, lack of credulity which gave me inspiration for this weekend’s “Weekend Head Scratcher”.

What car, either currently on the market or in history, do you think is vastly overrated?

Do you shake your head in despair when you see people driving a Toyota Camry? Maybe your heart sinks when you see a Cadillac CTS? Or possibly you think people are wasting their money on a Porsche Boxster?

But don’t think that you can just post “Honda Accord” or whatever car you think and that’s the end of it. Put some thought behind it. We want to know what car you think is overrated, reasons why you think that and (if applicable) a suitable alternative. We don’t want to see baseless ranting (this isn’t YouTube); we want to read reasoned arguments. This is “The Truth About Cars”, not “Goobers Rant About Cars”. So come on, then. Vent your spleen. Strip the Emperor of his clothes.

Cammy Corrigan
Cammy Corrigan

More by Cammy Corrigan

Comments
Join the conversation
2 of 165 comments
  • Davey49 Davey49 on Sep 23, 2010

    No car choice here but I say that Michelin tires are hugely overrated and overpriced. Especially by car safety wonks who will tell you if you buy a set of Yokohamas or Kumhos that your life is forfeit.

  • Bufguy Bufguy on Oct 03, 2010

    The new Ford Taurus.....A platform used by the S80, the Five Hundred, the rebadged Taurus and now an uglier bloated Taurus Ford tries to pass off as brand new. A car that looks much worse in person than pictures. Gun slit windows, a "dent" in the rear fender and huge ass.

  • Probert They already have hybrids, but these won't ever be them as they are built on the modular E-GMP skateboard.
  • Justin You guys still looking for that sportbak? I just saw one on the Facebook marketplace in Arizona
  • 28-Cars-Later I cannot remember what happens now, but there are whiteblocks in this period which develop a "tick" like sound which indicates they are toast (maybe head gasket?). Ten or so years ago I looked at an '03 or '04 S60 (I forget why) and I brought my Volvo indy along to tell me if it was worth my time - it ticked and that's when I learned this. This XC90 is probably worth about $300 as it sits, not kidding, and it will cost you conservatively $2500 for an engine swap (all the ones I see on car-part.com have north of 130K miles starting at $1,100 and that's not including freight to a shop, shop labor, other internals to do such as timing belt while engine out etc).
  • 28-Cars-Later Ford reported it lost $132,000 for each of its 10,000 electric vehicles sold in the first quarter of 2024, according to CNN. The sales were down 20 percent from the first quarter of 2023 and would “drag down earnings for the company overall.”The losses include “hundreds of millions being spent on research and development of the next generation of EVs for Ford. Those investments are years away from paying off.” [if they ever are recouped] Ford is the only major carmaker breaking out EV numbers by themselves. But other marques likely suffer similar losses. https://www.zerohedge.com/political/fords-120000-loss-vehicle-shows-california-ev-goals-are-impossible Given these facts, how did Tesla ever produce anything in volume let alone profit?
  • AZFelix Let's forego all of this dilly-dallying with autonomous cars and cut right to the chase and the only real solution.
Next