Review: 2010 Ford Fusion SE 6MT

Jack Baruth
by Jack Baruth

There ain’t nothing stock about a stock car. Nowadays, there ain’t nothing standard about a “standard” transmission. How long has it been since you’ve heard that quaint sobriquet for a clutch-and-stick setup? More than ninety percent of new cars sold in the United States are self-shifters. Our oh-so-superior friends in Europe and Japan aren’t as far behind in the trend towards PRNDL hegemony as they would have us believe. Combine the weight of marketplace preference with the increasing difficulty involved in making a stick-shift meet emissions regulations, and it becomes easy to understand why manufacturers are making automatic transmissions the only choice for everything besides specialty cars. A clutch pedal is perilously close to becoming an actual luxury item in today’s market. Does that turn this twenty-two-grand base-ish Fusion into a luxury car? Hell no.

Nor is the Fusion a sports car, or even a sporting one. The two-and-a-half-liter Duratec four makes 175 horsepower. That’s not nearly enough to propel the relatively porky Fusion with anything approaching vigor. (Although it would certainly keep up with an old five-cylinder Acura Vigor, if you can find one that hasn’t rusted into irrelevance.) Some of the Fusion’s class-inappropriate weight must consist of heavy Dynamat, because the engine note is virtually inaudible inside the cabin. Shift by the tach or you will meet the rev limiter. Trust me. The suspension tuning has been chosen for peace and quiet, not sturm und drang. It’s a remarkable freeway cruiser, particularly at the price, but it’s no Autobahn terror.

The Fusion SE is supplied with an interior of somewhat less tactile delight than that provided in the Sport model, but this is also way Honda and Toyota do things nowadays. Compared to a base Camry or Accord, this Fusion is more than acceptable. If there’s an occasional obvious cost-clipping in the plastics, there’s also a full SYNC system to balance the books.

This particular type of automobile—a relatively bland, low-equipment, manual-transmission four-cylinder sedan—has been a Honda, Toyota, and Nissan staple for a long time. In fact, the Ford is priced and equipped right on top of the Camry LE six-speed 2.5L, although I’d be surprised if there are more than ten new six-speed Camrys for sale in the entire country at the moment. Could it possibly make sense to buy the Fusion?

The Ford’s actual transaction price is certain to be a bit lower, although Toyota’s no longer slacking with the rebates. The Camry confers more respectability in the average suburban neighborhood nowadays, and it’s likely to be worth a bit more in five or ten years. Most Camrys are built in Kentucky, if you’re one of the folks who would prefer to buy an American-made automobile. There’s more room to be had in the Camry, and the famous Toyota reliability comes standard.

In this case, however, the not-so-famous Ford reliability is likely to carry the day in the long term. Consumer Reports is giving the Fusion the nod over the Camry, and it’s become apparent that recent Toyotas aren’t built as well as they used to be. Toyota doesn’t offer anything to match SYNC’s feature set. The Ford’s a more stirring drive, although this is a relative proposition. I personally find the Camry to be an utterly unforgiveable offense against aesthetics, proportion, and design, but it’s possible that somebody, somewhere, finds Toyota’s deformed-humpback styling compelling. That person is probably legally blind, but legally blind people buy plenty of cars. For proof of this assertion, Google “first-generation Santa Fe.”

The more time I spent behind the wheel of this humble four-cylinder Ford, the more I liked it. As a way to get four people somewhere at relatively low cost and with reasonable comfort, the Fusion SE takes some beating. This is the car that the Contour should have been back in 1995, but the Euro-fanboys and the handling fanatics were running Ford at the time. As a result, the so-called “American Mondeo” was exactly that: a cramped, featureless sedan that happened to suck-up the road like a front-wheel-drive 3-Series. No Accord or Camry could match the Contour for driving dynamics, and precisely nobody cared.

My insiders at Ford say that there’s a sported-up four-cylinder Fusion on the way, perhaps combining this drivetrain with the taut, big-wheeled setup found on the Sport. I cannot imagine that car selling in anything other than curiosity numbers. In fact, I cannot imagine this car selling in anything other than curiosity numbers. It doesn’t matter. Ford’s decision to provide this model is a statement of confidence. For the first time in a long time, there’s a domestic manufacturer willing to face the Camcords on an equal footing.

Some time ago, I asked TTAC’s B&B how this car should be rated: according to my preferences as a reviewer, or according to the Fusion’s position in the marketplace. The response was overwhelmingly in favor of the latter. So, while I feel compelled to note that I would rather have a lime-green Porsche GT2 than this anonymous silver sedan, when I put it heads-up against the competition, it’s four stars, no sweat.

Jack Baruth
Jack Baruth

More by Jack Baruth

Join the conversation
2 of 100 comments
  • Stevenb Stevenb on Sep 29, 2009

    I am seriously considering a new Fusion SE with the 6-speed MT. I am waiting for my local dealer to get one on the lot so I can test drive the MT and see if it feels good. If I like it, I'll probably factory order to get the color and options I want. To those who own or have test driven one - how much headroom do you lose with the sunroof? The Sun and Sync combo pack on the SE (option pack 202) is a really good price for what you get. I don't know why the MT units have trouble meeting emissions testing, but I think I DO know why the reported mileage for the MT is now worse than the Auto: the manufacturer has to use the EPA method to determine mileage - this is a blended test of low speed, high speed, stops, starts, etc. Those of us who like MTs usually do a lot of high-speed, highway/interstate driving in top gear and this is where the mileage differential vs. the EPA estimate will really show up. I'm driving an '06 Accord LX/SE with the 2.4 liter 4 and the 5-spd manual. I've got over 134K miles on it, and I still regularly get over 31 mpg on the highway -about the current EPA HWY estimate for this model. When it was newer and tighter I could get closer to 33 mpg. But I drive long distances in 5th gear - and the Honda 5th gear lets me cruise at 70 mph at around 2500 rpm. If 6th gear in the Ford is comparable, I'll probably buy it. But if they have it geared too low so that I'll be running anywhere close to 3000 at highway speed, then nevermind.... Honda is finally slipping behind though - the new Accord does not impress me and they have gotten way too expensive for what you get. And you still can't get satellite radio unless you pay for a top-line model; something the Ford includes standard on all models except base. Honda should have made satellite radio a dealer-installed option on ALL models and standard on the LX and above.

  • Suzane Suzane on Aug 14, 2010

    2010 Ford Fusion Hybrid is truly the magic and wonder of Ford Motors. The technical features and the specialties of this vehicle are amazing and quite aggressive. Delivering 191 horsepower is one of the best thing one can ever have in their own. Also the other factors are quite impressive. Launching this vehicle has again proved the technical supremacy of Fprd Motors and has created a new dimension and era for the company.

  • Kwik_Shift_Pro4X Union fees and corruption. What can go wrong?
  • Lou_BC How about one of those 2 foot wide horizontal speedometers out of the late 60's Ford Galaxie?
  • Lou_BC Was he at GM for 47 years or an engineer for 47 years?
  • Ajla The VW vote that was held today heavily favored unionization (75/25). That's a very large victory for the UAW considering such a vote has failed two other times this decade at that plant.
  • The Oracle Just advertise ICE vehicles by range instead of MPG and let the market decide.