Piston Slap: Tribulations of a 4.4-quart Oil Pan?

Sajeev Mehta
by Sajeev Mehta
piston slap tribulations of a 4 4 quart oil pan


William writes:


It is good to have another reason to contact the great and gracious Sajeev with a question that is more vexing than choosing the wrong flavor of Crest toothpaste at Walmart. (Not. Worthy. – SM)

I recently had my 2008 Acura TSX in for a filter and oil change at my local Oregon Honda dealer.

I requested that the oil being put into the car not exceed the maximum mark on the dipstick after the car had sat long enough to get an accurate reading. This occurred during the previous oil and filter change, leading to a most amazing conversation with the Honda Service Deptartment supervisor types.

I was told the oil would get thinner when warmed up, so it was not a problem that the oil level when cold was about 1/2 inch higher than the maximum mark on the dipstick. This would equate to around 1/2 quart of oil, maybe more. I could see the service dept. was up to its tush in cars, so I chose to leave the scene. Several days later I bribed a Jiffy Lube with Hostess cupcakes to drain off the excess oil.

This time around I took the car back to the dealer and discussed the excess oil with no intention of bribing anyone with Hostess cupcakes. The same service supervisor, who explained the thinning oil theory previously, determined that all of the oil would be drained and then refilled, but at a lower volume.

Honda’s service spec calls for 4.4 quarts of oil with a filter change for this 2.4 liter four-cylinder engine. It turns out that putting in 3.9 quarts without a filter change puts the oil level at just below the maximum mark on the dipstick. This led the Service person to conclude that a new filter would not hold 1/2 quart of oil. This leads me to believe Honda is choosing to overfill the engines with oil when doing an oil and filter change.

Please offer your humble opinion about this possibility and allow the best and brightest to bloviate at will concerning this issue.

Sajeev answers:

I consider myself lucky I’ve worked on only one vehicle that eschewed whole numbers when adding engine oil. Plus, it used a full half of a bottle (so to speak), at that.

Regarding the K24’s half-inch too high dipstick reading, I reckon you were charged for a full five quarts and someone ensured you got every penny of it. Who knows why, but it should have been fixed (i.e. drained) upon your initial discussion. I spoke to TTAC commenter psychoboy, a genuine Honda guru, and he agreed. He went further, suggesting it’d take an extra quart (5.4 quarts total) to foam things up via crankshaft aeration to seriously damage your engine. He is not alone in this assumption of you being in the clear.

But he also noted, “might not hurt anything, but still not good.”

I doubt Honda Corporate approves of your experience, and I’m glad the thinning oil malarkey wasn’t thrown at you a second time. So, trust but verify…if you own a vehicle that still has a dipstick.

[Image: Acura]

Send your queries to sajeev@thetruthaboutcars.com. Spare no details and ask for a speedy resolution if you’re in a hurry…but be realistic, and use your make/model specific forums instead of TTAC for more timely advice.

Join the conversation
2 of 63 comments
  • Geozinger Geozinger on Aug 13, 2017

    One thing I used to hate on my folks' 6 cylinder Fords were the 4.5 qt refill capacity (w/filter) on those engines. We always had a half quart can of oil loafing in the garage. I've never understood the every other oil change filter change on modern cars, either. I think since the widespread adoption of cartridge filters, the minimal cost makes up for the additional protection of the motor. I imagine it's like using the bathtub after your sibling, but only emptying it most of the way... Ick. As much as I didn't mind doing my own oil changes (with a few exceptions), with environmental laws being what they are, it makes more sense to have it done. I won't just dump it on my property anywhere. Also, where I live, I have very few places to take waste oil. Or maybe the convenience factor has more to do with it. 20 minutes and I'm done. The local Chevy dealer does it pretty cheap and I've never had a problem with over/under fills, either.

  • Speedlaw Speedlaw on Aug 16, 2017

    My Acura MDX is 4.5 Quarts. I have always done five, with filter every time....no issues. Disposal is easy by me, all the gas stations will take waste oil, that they get paid for.....

  • Kwik_Shift A nice stretch of fairly remote road that would be great for test driving a car's potential, rally style, is Flinton Road off of Highway 41 in Ontario. Twists/turns/dips/rises. Just hope a deer doesn't jump out at you. Also Highway 60 through Algonquin Provincial Park in Ontario. Great scenery with lots of hills.
  • Saeed Hello, I need a series of other accessories from Lincoln. Do you have front window, front and rear lights, etc. from the 1972 and 1976 models
  • Probert Wow - so many digital renders - Ford, Stellantis. - whose next!!! They're really bringing it on....
  • Zerocred So many great drives:Dalton Hwy from Fairbanks to the Arctic Circle.Alaska Marine Highway from Bellingham WA to Skagway AK. it was a multi-day ferry ride so I didn’t actually drive it, but I did take my truck.Icefields Parkway from Jasper AB to Lake Louise AB, CA.I-70 and Hwy 50 from Denver to Sacramento.Hwy 395 on the east side of the Sierras.
  • Aidian Holder I'm not interested in buying anything from a company that deliberately targets all their production in crappy union-busting states. Ford decided to build their EV manufaturing in Tennessee. The company built it there because of an anti-union legal environment. I won't buy another Ford because of that. I've owned four Fords to date -- three of them pickups. I'm shopping for a new one. It won't be a Ford Lightning. If you care about your fellow workers, you won't buy one either.