Jaguar Design Director: Hydrogen Power is a 'Disaster'

Matt Posky
by Matt Posky
jaguar design director hydrogen power is a 8216 disaster

Jaguar Land Rover’s technical design director Wolfgang Ziebart is decidedly not a proponent of hydrogen-fueled vehicles.

Due to the amount of energy required to produce, cool, and then compress hydrogen for transportation and subsequent usage within a fuel cell vehicle, Ziebart is highly critical of its role as a practical automotive energy source.

Still, a minority of automakers disagree.

In an interview with Autocar, Ziebart affirmed that “The well to wheel relationship from the energy source to the vehicle is a disaster.”

“You end up with a well to wheel efficiency of roughly 30% for hydrogen, as opposed to more or less well to wheel 70% efficiency for a battery electric vehicle. So the efficiency of putting the electric energy directly into a battery is about twice as high as the efficiency of producing and using hydrogen. “If there was a strong reason to have a hydrogen infrastructure, then I think it would be set up, but with this disastrous well-to-wheel relationship, it doesn’t just make sense.”

As things stand currently, there are only thirty-one public hydrogen fueling stations in the United States and 28 of those reside in California. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, that total number jumps to 56 if you include private filling locations. Meanwhile, there are over 14,800 public charging stations dedicated to electric vehicles with more cropping up every year. There’s also thousands of additional 240 volt outlets provided by workplaces and local governments, and most EV owners have the option of simply plugging in at home.

Battery powered cars are also less wasteful in a macro sense, as they draw their electricity from a pre-existing grid — one that transports energy more efficiently and at a lower cost.

Jaguar certainly didn’t see a reason to wait around for a hydrogen infrastructure to develop and the company’s new I-Pace Concept, which Ziebart oversaw the development of, is proof that.

Perhaps it is time for Toyota, Hyundai, and Honda to reassess what little effort they’ve already put behind fuel cell technology.

[Image: Jaguar Land Rover]

Join the conversation
2 of 29 comments
  • Makuribu Makuribu on Nov 24, 2016

    The fuel cell is a technology that turns millions of government research dollars into a small amount of electricity and water.

  • Redmondjp Redmondjp on Nov 28, 2016

    Let's not forget another reason why this idea won't die - because existing energy companies (who will sell the natural gas that will be reformed into H2) will still get a piece of the action. And can claim to be "green" while doing it.

  • ToolGuy 404 error on the product link. Which probably isn't terrific marketing on TTAC's part.
  • ToolGuy Second picture: Do you like pegboard storage? (I don't.)
  • ToolGuy "WHAT???"(old 'I was in the artillery' joke)
  • ToolGuy Oh and this.
  • ToolGuy "The boroughs of Bexley, Bromley, Hillingdon, and Harrow have likewise announced plans to take legal action to force a possible judicial review..."But: "In Hartford, Hereford, and Hampshire... Hurricanes hardly happen."