Buick Goes Upscale, Bumps Into New Cadillac XTS (In Concept)

by Edward Niedermeyer

Published: November 13th, 2011

buick goes upscale bumps into new cadillac xts in concept

Take Buick’s LaCrosse, load it up with a fancier interior materials, wheels and trim, and what do you get? No, not a Cadillac XTS. The XTS, you see, is a fancier Buick LaCrosse for a different kind of buyer. The XTS is for people who might want a fancier LaCrosse, but with some “red blooded luxury” flair. This LaCrosse “GL” concept is for those who want a fancier LaCrosse which retains Buick’s “inviting luxury” vibe. See the difference? GM’s decision to keep Buick in its brand portfolio has worked out fairly well thus far, bracketing the luxury market with very different brand images and products… thus far. But with Cadillac dipping into Buick territory with its midsized XTS, now does not seem to be the time for Buick to move upwards by showing an ultra-luxury version of its midsized LaCrosse. Luckily this LaCrosse GL is just a concept, but it should remind The General that a two-brand approach to the luxury market has to be especially careful: swallow too much of the “different brands for different buyers” Kool-Aid and overlap becomes unavoidable. Appealing though it may be, this LaCrosse GL sounds a warning…

#3WTP #Branding #Buick #Cadillac #Design #GM #Luxury

Edward Niedermeyer

More by Edward Niedermeyer

Comments

Join the conversation

3 of 52 comments

Ronnie Schreiber on Nov 13, 2011

People say that Cadillac and Lincoln need flagships. Well, part of Buick's place in Alfred Sloan's hierarchy was giving folks who could afford a Cadillac a less outwardly ostentatious alternative. Buick's didn't become known as doctors' cars because doctors couldn't afford Cadillacs, it was just that it wasn't quite so socially acceptable then, when people paid most medical bills, not insurance companies. So I think there's a spot for a very well appointed Buick without necessarily cannibalizing sales from Cadillac. One aspect of Sloan's hierarchy was that the brands indeed competed, but only at the margins. Should you buy a loaded Chevy or a lower end Pontiac? A nicely appointed Olds, or a Buick? A nice Buick, or a cheaper Cadillac, like a Calais.

Like Reply
Daveainchina on Nov 14, 2011

Color me confused, what makes this an ultra-luxury model. 2-tone interior?? I'm sorry I just don't see what makes this special. Two colors of leather on the seats just doesn't impress me regardless of the other electronic doodads they put in it. I don't see how this intrudes on Cadillac. It's still a boring buick, barely anymore personality than a lexus. Which is the point I thought.

Like Reply
- KalapanaBlack on Nov 14, 2011
  
  I'm with you here... I don't understand why this is a 'concept.' It's just a damn LaCrosse with different color leather and some slightly different (possibly larger, possibly not) wheels. Snoooooore. And then it became a post on TTAC. And then it became a hot topic that brought people out of the woodwork to discuss how this "new Buick model" (???) overlaps with the Cadillac. IT'S A LACROSSE WITH NEW WHEELS. It's not a new model. If the LaCrosse sitting at dealers right now doesn't overlap with the XTS, then neither does this thing. Why is this worthy of our attention at an auto show, or wherever they showed this? Does anybody else announce with a special concept when they change the wheel design on a midsize sedan or offer a new leather color on their seats? Hell, I'd say neither option even makes it to the production LaCrosse. Also, what the heck does "GL" mean? It used to be the basic trim level for VWs and some Oldsmobiles... GL doesn't scream upmarket luxury any more than DL does for me. Why couldn't this be the LaCrosse Ultra? Oh, that would make too much sense... Not to mention at least the old Park Ave Ultra had a special engine, unlike this alloys-and-leather option package. /rant
  
  Like

Recent Comments

TheEndlessEnigma I'm sure the rise in driving infractions in Minnesota has nothing to do with all the learing centers.
Plaincraig 06 PT Cruiser 214k miles. 24MPG with a 50/50 highway city driving. One new radiator was the only thing replaced from failure at 80k.Regular maintenance and new radiator hoses and struts at 100k. Head gasket failed blew out the camshaft seals and the rear seal failed too. Being able to remove the backseats was wonderful. The ride was fine. Took an exit ramp and twice the rated speed and some kid in a Mazda 3Speed rolled down his window and asked what I done to make it handle like that. I said "Its all stock and Walmart tires. I know how to drive not just go fast."
Flashindapan Corey, I increasingly find your installments to be the only reason I check back here from time to time.
SCE to AUX The first couple generations of Prius were maligned by association with a certain stereotype owner. But you can't deny their economy and reliability is the envy of the automobile world. It's rare for an EV to match the TCO of a Prius. From personal experience, the first-gen Nissan Leaf. Yes, they looked like a frog and their batteries degraded, but the car was ultra-reliable, well-built, and smooth driving, and was a good introduction to electric motoring for its time.
DungBeetle62 Mercury Capri. It was never conceived to be an updated Lotus Elan/Brit RWD Roadster with Japanese reliability as the Miata was. If you just treated it as a more fun and airy commute than the Tracer/323 its bones came from - it was pretty quick with the turbo (for the era) and enjoyable. And you still had some Mazda reliability under the skin. Yes, I owned one. But let's just say I'm not perusing Bring a Trailer looking for used examples in decent shape.