Tesla Lost $243 Million Suit that Could Have Been Settled for $60 Million

by Chris Teague

Published: August 26th, 2025

tesla lost 243 million suit that could have been settled for 60 million

Tesla rejected a $60 million settlement offer in a lawsuit over a 2019 fatal accident involving a Model S, but the outcome of the trial wasn’t favorable for the automaker. It has been ordered to pay $243 million in damages over the accident.

The plaintiffs allege that the autopilot system in the Model S sedan failed to prevent a fatal collision, which happened in 2019 when the Tesla collided with people standing near a parked SUV in Florida. Tesla was found liable for a third of the total $129 million in compensatory damages and $200 million in punitive damages.

While denying wrongdoing in the case, Tesla said the outcome “only works to set back automotive safety and jeopardize Tesla’s and the entire industry’s efforts to develop and implement life-saving technology.” The automaker also said it would appeal the outcome.

The system’s failure to operate as intended is certainly at issue here, but a challenge pointed out in other lawsuits is the marketing around features like Autopilot and Full Self Driving. The names suggest that the systems make vehicles autonomous, leading some to abuse the technologies. That said, the other lawsuits have been dismissed or resolved before trial, so there’s no telling how the appeal will go in this case.

[Images: Tesla]

Become a TTAC insider. Get the latest news, features, TTAC takes, and everything else that gets to the truth about cars first by subscribing to our newsletter.

#Tesla #teslafsdlawsuit #TeslaModelS

Chris Teague

Chris grew up in, under, and around cars, but took the long way around to becoming an automotive writer. After a career in technology consulting and a trip through business school, Chris began writing about the automotive industry as a way to reconnect with his passion and get behind the wheel of a new car every week. He focuses on taking complex industry stories and making them digestible by any reader. Just don’t expect him to stay away from high-mileage Porsches.

More by Chris Teague

Comments

Join the conversation

3 of 32 comments

El scotto on Aug 26, 2025

It's Florida, Tesla will have to pay.

Like Reply
HooDingle on Aug 27, 2025

Sounds financially smart to have the same leadership in charge of government funds, amirite?

1 Reply
- EBFlexing on ur mom on Aug 27, 2025
  
  What?
  
  Like

Recent Comments

Lou_BC I've had my collision alert come on 2 times in 8 months. Once was when a pickup turned onto a side road with minimal notice. Another with a bus turning left and I was well clear in the outside lane but turn off was in a corner. I suspect the collision alert thought I was traveling in a straight line.I have the "emergency braking" part of the system turned off. I've had "lane keep assist" not recognize vehicles parked on the shoulder.That's the extent of my experience with "assists". I don't trust any of it.
SCE to AUX A lot has changed since I got my license in 1979, about 2 weeks after I turned 16 (on my second attempt). I would have benefited from formal driver training, and waiting another year to get my license. I was a road terror for several years - lots of accidents, near misses, speeding, showing off - the epitome of youthful indiscretion.
Lou_BC Jellybean F150 (1997-2004). People tend to prefer the more square body and blunt grill style.
SCE to AUX My first car was a 71 Pinto, 1.6 Kent engine, 4 spd. It was the original Base model with a trunk, #4332 ever built. I paid $125 for it in 1980, and had it a year. It remains the quietest idling engine I've ever had. 75HP, and I think the compression ratio was 8:1. It was riddled with rust, and I sold it to a classmate who took it to North Carolina.After a year with a 74 Fiat, I got a 76 Pinto, 2.3 engine, 4-spd. The engine was tractor rough, but I had the car 5 years with lots of rebuilding. It's the only car I parted with by driving into a junkyard.Finally, we got an 80 Bobcat for $1 from a friend in 1987. What a piece of junk. Besides the rust, it never ran right despite tons of work, fuel economy was terrible, the automatic killed the power. The hatch always leaked, and the vinyl seats were brutal in winter and summer.These cars were terrible by today's standards, but they never left me stranded. All were fitted with the poly blast shield, and I never worried about blowing up.The miserable Bobcat was traded for an 82 LTD, which was my last Ford when it was traded in 1996. Seeing how Ford is doing today, I won't be going back.
Jeff S I rented a PT Cruiser for a week and although I would not have bought one it was not as bad as I thought it would be. Pontiac Aztek was a good vehicle but ugly. Pinto for its time was not as good as the Japanese cars but it was not the worst that honor would go to the Vega. If one bought a Pinto new it was much better with a 4 speed manual with no air it didn't have the power for those. Add air and an automatic to a Pinto and you could beat it on a bicycle. The few small cars available today or in the recent past are so much better than the Pinto, Vega, and Gremlin. A Mitsubishi Mirage, Nissan Versa, and the former Chevy Spark are light years ahead of those small cars of the 70s.