A U.S. Appeals Court in Louisiana Recently Reversed the Dismissal of Tesla's Dealer Franchise Lawsuit Against the State

by Chris Teague

Published: August 27th, 2024

a u s appeals court in louisiana recently reversed the dismissal of tesla s dealer

In some states, car dealer franchise laws help protect businesses by preventing automakers from selling directly to consumers. That policy has caused headaches for some companies, including Tesla and Rivian, which allow customers to purchase a car online for delivery. Tesla sued the state of Louisiana over its franchise laws in 2022, but the courts threw it out. Recently, however, an appeals court reversed that decision, opening the door for the automaker to proceed with its suit.

The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 to reverse the dismissal. Tesla’s lawsuit targeted the Louisiana Motor Vehicle Commission and the Louisiana Automobile Dealers Association, saying that the groups aimed to drive it out of the state. The automaker does not have a network of dealers but does operate regional service centers, one of which is located in New Orleans.

The lone dissenting judge, Dana Douglas, said, “The issue is whether a company can change the composition of a state’s regulatory commission because it merely disagrees with the state law which the commission is required to enforce. But Tesla cannot use this court as an end-run around the legislative process.”

Louisiana isn’t the only state causing headaches for Tesla. Alabama, South Carolina, New Mexico, and others have direct sales bans, and many also prohibit the automaker’s service model. Tesla got around those rules in New Mexico by building a service center on tribal land. Other states have banned Tesla’s gallery model, which lets prospective buyers explore vehicles prior to purchase without making a purchase.

[Images: Tesla]

Become a TTAC insider. Get the latest news, features, TTAC takes, and everything else that gets to the truth about cars first by subscribing to our newsletter.

#Tesla #Louisiana #dealerfranchiselaws

Chris Teague

Chris grew up in, under, and around cars, but took the long way around to becoming an automotive writer. After a career in technology consulting and a trip through business school, Chris began writing about the automotive industry as a way to reconnect with his passion and get behind the wheel of a new car every week. He focuses on taking complex industry stories and making them digestible by any reader. Just don’t expect him to stay away from high-mileage Porsches.

More by Chris Teague

Comments

Join the conversation

2 of 17 comments

El scotto on Aug 28, 2024
You had to get a Ford franchise to sell those hot Model T's. Things have changed a bit.

Like Reply
MaintenanceCosts on Aug 28, 2024
Even a blind appeals court finds a nut once in a while.

1 Reply

Recent Comments

TheEndlessEnigma I'm sure the rise in driving infractions in Minnesota has nothing to do with all the learing centers.
Plaincraig 06 PT Cruiser 214k miles. 24MPG with a 50/50 highway city driving. One new radiator was the only thing replaced from failure at 80k.Regular maintenance and new radiator hoses and struts at 100k. Head gasket failed blew out the camshaft seals and the rear seal failed too. Being able to remove the backseats was wonderful. The ride was fine. Took an exit ramp and twice the rated speed and some kid in a Mazda 3Speed rolled down his window and asked what I done to make it handle like that. I said "Its all stock and Walmart tires. I know how to drive not just go fast."
Flashindapan Corey, I increasingly find your installments to be the only reason I check back here from time to time.
SCE to AUX The first couple generations of Prius were maligned by association with a certain stereotype owner. But you can't deny their economy and reliability is the envy of the automobile world. It's rare for an EV to match the TCO of a Prius. From personal experience, the first-gen Nissan Leaf. Yes, they looked like a frog and their batteries degraded, but the car was ultra-reliable, well-built, and smooth driving, and was a good introduction to electric motoring for its time.
DungBeetle62 Mercury Capri. It was never conceived to be an updated Lotus Elan/Brit RWD Roadster with Japanese reliability as the Miata was. If you just treated it as a more fun and airy commute than the Tracer/323 its bones came from - it was pretty quick with the turbo (for the era) and enjoyable. And you still had some Mazda reliability under the skin. Yes, I owned one. But let's just say I'm not perusing Bring a Trailer looking for used examples in decent shape.