TTAC Family Feud: Technical Descriptions May Vary

Jeff Puthuff
by Jeff Puthuff

I present to you the results of the little brouhaha that I started way back on 3 February. Despite assertions that I was “making a mountain out of a molehill,” I feel it is important. I like standardization because it makes life easier but I also recognize that on a site like this, with its mixture of news and opinion, standards may have to give way to flexible guidelines. Spike_in_Irvine commented, “There is always tension between saying what is right and saying what is commonly used,” and I agree. I personally like the use of “torques,” “ponies,” and Farago’s occasional many flourishes of French because it adds personality. But, I won’t let it get out of hand; and, I will ensure that a review or news item contains the proper terminology.

One hundred people answered the survey. Survey says . . .

Thirty-eight percent (the majority plurality) of respondents want us to use “lb/ft” and “hp” and several asked that we include the rpm at which peak torque and horsepower are generated. We will if that information is easily obtainable (and free of charge). To make it easier for our writers, I will handle converting “lb/ft” to “lb·ft”. Whether to include metric equivalents was divided at 56% yes and 44% no, though more than half of all respondents want that information displayed on mouse-over only. Several people want info boxes. I’d love to have them, too, but if you saw the code for this site or knew what it takes to get a widget approved and installed by the mothership, you’ll understand why this probably won’t happen.

Fuel economy raised a few heckles from the peanut gallery: more than a few want gallons per n miles. That’s not common usage in the States, but to make it easier for our foreign visitors, I will include a link to the official Department of Energy/Environmental Protection Agency fuel economy site (if available for reviewed vehicle) which helpfully provides that information along with other metrics, e.g., “Carbon Footprint,” “Air Pollution Score,” and “Annual Petroleum Consumption.” Strangely, the DOE/EPA site doesn’t include vehicle weight. If we can easily get that figure, we’ll include it so that power-to-weight ratios can be calculated.

Wrapping up, I thank all most of the people who commented. In fact, Robert and I were so surprised by the passionate/scathing/hyperbolic comments made in the original post that we created The Truth About Grammar. There aren’t many auto blogs that involve their readers in decisions like these, so feel special because TTAC is special. My mom told me so.

Jeff Puthuff
Jeff Puthuff

Early 30s California guy driving a 97 Infiniti I30. Past cars: 90 Cavalier, 82 Skylark, 78 Courier, 61 Beetle.

More by Jeff Puthuff

Comments
Join the conversation
2 of 28 comments
  • Wheely Wheely on Feb 23, 2009

    I'm with Chuck. Assuming the 800-word limit is still in place, it would be a shame to substitute entertaining seat-of-the-pants commentary with units. Measurements, in whatever standard you wish, are available just about anywhere. Thoughtful impressions are harder to come by, and my guess is that is what drives most readers to this site.

  • B. Filthy B. Filthy on Feb 23, 2009

    I'm not much of a car guy at all, but I love TTAC because you sweat the details like this. It's not simply great car writing, it's great writing (and, generally, great commentary). Viva TTAC and keep it up!!

  • Carson D A friend of mine bought a Cayenne GTS last week. I was amazed how small the back seat is. Did I expect it to offer limousine comfort like a Honda CR-V? I guess not. That it is far more confining and uncomfortable than any 4-door Civic made in the past 18 years was surprising. It reminded me of another friend's Mercedes-Benz CLS550 from a dozen years ago. It seems like a big car, but really it was a 2+2 with the utilitarian appearance of a 4-door sedan. The Cayenne is just an even more utilitarian looking 2+2. I suppose the back seat is bigger than the one in the Porsche my mother drove 30 years ago. The Cayenne's luggage bay is huge, but Porsche's GTs rarely had problems there either.
  • Stanley Steamer Oh well, I liked the Legacy. It didn't help that they ruined it's unique style after 2020. It was a classy looking sedan up to that point.
  • Jalop1991 https://notthebee.com/article/these-people-wore-stop-signs-to-prank-self-driving-cars-and-this-is-a-trend-i-could-totally-get-behindFull self stopping.
  • Lou_BC Summit Racing was wise to pull the parts. It damages their reputation. I've used Summit Racing for Jeep parts that I could not find elsewhere.
  • MaintenanceCosts The crossover is now just "the car," part 261.
Next