Piston Slap: Misfiring on Mazda 3 Skyactiv's Diagnosis?

Sajeev Mehta
by Sajeev Mehta

Brian writes:

Hi Sajeev,

You are my go-to guy for in-depth automotive knowledge. (Wow! Honored. – SM)

My brother has been having a heck of a time with his 2012 Mazda3 Skyactiv. It’s got about 70k miles on it, and in the past 2 years it’s been in and out of the shop. It started with high engine oil consumption (more than a quart per 3k miles, and going up to this day). Then the ignition coils needed to be replaced. Then the MAF and oxygen sensors needed to be replaced. Right after those were fixed, he had to take it back to the shop because there is now a misfire in one of the cylinders.

What’s going on here? My only guesses are worn piston rings causing engine oil to run into the combustion chamber (then down the exhaust and ruining the O2 sensor), or malfunctioning PCV, a broken EGR system, intake valves with a lot of carbon deposits, or simply “bad luck” with this car.

Hope you are able to shed some light on this mystery. Thanks!

Sajeev answers:

As we all know, Skyactiv engines improve fuel economy without the usual side effect of a wheezy, wimpy powerband. But you can’t have your cake and eat it too: low tension piston rings ensure this truth. But is this really a problem?

I’ve postulated that oil burning is likely a net positive in modern engines and — unless a Dieselgate-worthy scandal comes upon us — this will continue. So tell your brother to not fear the oil consumption issue, unless the rate doubles in a fraction of the current time/mileage interval.

The other issues are worrisome, but less about the car and more about the diagnoses. What engine codes were generated to merit replacing all those bits? Armchair quarterbacking is a dangerous profession, but it seems like this direct-injected motor got a lot of parts thrown at the problem. Parts that either went bad because the motor wasn’t de-carboned, or they weren’t bad to start.

I’ve been spilling digital ink about de-carbonizing Direct-Injected engines for years ( at least 2012) and that’s likely what your brother’s Mazda needs. Perhaps the traditional chemicals/walnut shell/whatever Mazda recommends as a treatment won’t cut it now, and perhaps the intake/EGR system needs a good physical cleaning on the workbench?

What say you, Best and Brightest?

[Image: Mazda]

Send your queries to sajeev@thetruthaboutcars.com. Spare no details and ask for a speedy resolution if you’re in a hurry…but be realistic, and use your make/model specific forums instead of TTAC for more timely advice.

Sajeev Mehta
Sajeev Mehta

More by Sajeev Mehta

Comments
Join the conversation
5 of 81 comments
  • Inside Looking Out Inside Looking Out on Apr 13, 2018

    There is good article with pictures and photos, and yes it is about Mazda engine: https://toolsinmotionauto.ca/blog/?p=218 "The photo above is from a Mazda that we serviced this week, and is the worst example of this build-up that we have seen to date. This engine had less than 150,000 kilometers on it, and a bad misfire that was due in part to the valve issues."

    • See 2 previous
    • Dantes_inferno Dantes_inferno on Apr 16, 2018

      @ToddAtlasF1 >“However, moving the fuel spray from the intake manifold to inside the cylinders had an unexpected conseqeuence: bad deposit build-up on the intake valves.” >Unexpected? Anyone that didn’t expect this was stupid enough to vote for higher fuel efficiency instead of shopping for it. And that (DI carbon issue) is the GIANT elephant in the room that the automotive industry doesn't want anyone to notice.

  • Stuart Stuart on Apr 17, 2018

    I researched this before I bought my '17 Mazda. Mazda claimed that the coking was minimized by keeping the intake valves above 400F: http://www.motoiq.com/MagazineArticles/id/2105/pageid/3529/131-compression-and-40-mpg-on-87-octane-fuel-introducing-mazdas-skyactiv-technology.aspx There seem to be dozens of pictures of badly-coked German DI engines on the web, but pictures of coked Mazda DI (Skyactiv) valves are rare. @InsideLookingOut posted one such link, but the article is mostly about useless cleaning products; the article omits any mention of the year or whether it has a turbocharger. Here's a link to a non-turbo Mazda DI engine with some valve build-up: https://www.miataspeed.com/blogs/news/walnut-blasting-intake-valves-our-2016-skyactiv-g-nd-miata While the owners of the above engine had it cleaned with walnut blasting, it's actually not very bad. When this subject comes up on the web, it's usually about an engine with a severe issue, like this: http://tyspeed.com/bmw-n54-n55-s55-intake-valve-carbon-blasting This forum posting has links to several videos about valve cleaning (none are Mazda): https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums/c7-tech-performance/3717271-lt1-gdi-owners.html Bottom Line: this is a real problem for many makes, especially German. It seems pretty rare on Mazdas.

  • 28-Cars-Later Why RHO? Were Gamma and Epsilon already taken?
  • 28-Cars-Later "The VF 8 has struggled to break ground in the increasingly crowded EV market, as spotty reviews have highlighted deficiencies with its tech, ride quality, and driver assistance features. That said, the price isn’t terrible by current EV standards, starting at $47,200 with leases at $429 monthly." In a not so surprising turn of events, VinFast US has already gone bankrupt.
  • 28-Cars-Later "Farley expressed his belief that Ford would figure things out in the next few years."Ford death watch starts now.
  • JMII My wife's next car will be an EV. As long as it costs under $42k that is totally within our budget. The average cost of a new ICE car is... (checks interwebs) = $47k. So EVs are already in the "affordable" range for today's new car buyers.We already have two other ICE vehicles one of which has a 6.2l V8 with a manual. This way we can have our cake and eat it too. If your a one vehicle household I can see why an EV, no matter the cost, may not work in that situation. But if you have two vehicles one can easily be an EV.My brother has an EV (Tesla Model Y) along with two ICE Porsche's (one is a dedicated track car) and his high school age daughters share an EV (Bolt). I fully assume his daughters will never drive an ICE vehicle. Just like they have never watched anything but HiDef TV, never used a land-line, nor been without an iPad. To them the concept of an ICE power vehicle is complete ridiculous - you mean you have to STOP driving to put some gas in and then PAY for it!!! Why? the car should already charged and the cost is covered by just paying the monthly electric bill.So the way I see it the EV problem will solve itself, once all the boomers die off. Myself as part of Gen X / MTV Generation will have drive a mix of EV and ICE.
  • 28-Cars-Later [Model year is 2010] "and mileage is 144,000"Why not ask $25,000? Oh too cheap, how about $50,000?Wait... the circus is missing one clown, please report to wardrobe. 2010 AUDI A3 AWD 4D HATCHBACK PREMIUM PLUS
Next