Contradiction at Cobo - Reflections on the 2018 Detroit Auto Show

Tim Healey
by Tim Healey

When I left the media center at the 2018 North American International Auto Show in Detroit, I turned to Steph to say I might write a roundup piece this week, but I wasn’t sure what angle to take. It’s true this year’s show was truck-focused, and I wanted to go beyond the obvious theme (which Jack eventually took on here) and see if there was more to the show that was getting lost in the truck madness.

“Maybe I will find inspiration on the open road,” I joked.

Instead, the “open road” greeted me with snarled traffic near Detroit and whiteout conditions a couple hours later in Southwest Michigan/Northwest Indiana. So, as I tried to keep a Camry pointed forward and not sideways while surrounded by insane open-road truckers whose response to the weather was to drive even faster, I realized I wasn’t going to come up with some grand, sweeping theme for this year’s show.

Instead, I have a few random musings compiled below.

Side note: If you’re curious, the Camry acquitted itself well in the white stuff, with the exception of the driver-aid systems – the snow clogged sensors so badly that the dashboard was aflame with all sorts of dire warnings about how these aids were temporarily disabled. More on that below.

Without further ado:

  • Outside of trucks trucks trucks, the main theme of the Detroit show was contradiction, especially with Ford. Jim Hackett talked about his GT350 and its loud exhaust at the same presentation in which the company continued to drone on about the future of mobility and the cities of tomorrow. Not only that, but Ford launched a new Bullitt trim for the Mustang shortly before pissing off almost everyone by hinting that a future “performance” crossover with a battery electric powertrain could use the Mach 1 name, of Mustang fame.
  • Shortly afterward, Ford teased the upcoming Shelby GT500, a car that’s far from a BEV crossover with performance intent. I get that automakers are looking to please both performance enthusiasts as well as future-looking consumers who welcome more electrification (and perhaps more autonomy), but Ford’s mixed messaging gave off the impression that the company does not have a coherent vision for the future. And yes, a coherent vision could include both old-school performance vehicles and electric and/or autonomous vehicles – if articulated correctly. Ford, however, looks like it doesn’t know what it wants to do.
  • Speaking of autonomous vehicles, as mentioned above, I experienced some system failures on my drive home thanks to inclement weather. This isn’t to pick on Toyota, since these issues could have happened in any car, but it’s a reminder that there’s a way to go before this tech is ready for prime time, no matter what PR spin you may hear out of NAIAS.
  • I might be insane or have bad eyes, but I detect a hint of current-gen Toyota Tacoma in the new Ford Ranger. That’s not a bad thing, and regardless if I am seeing things or not, the new Ranger does look good to my eye.
  • Based on everything I’ve read about it, both in the media proper and on social media, the new Silverado has the most divisive styling of the new crop of pickups. There seems to be no middle ground. For the record, I like it.
  • Circling back to the Blue Oval: What the hell is Ford doing with the EcoSport? One model on the show floor had such poorly assembled trim pieces that one of our writers was able to move a piece of trim that should be stationary up and down with ease. It looked and felt cheap, as if Ford was so desperate for a subcompact crossover that it didn’t care to put an effort into improving build quality as it brought the model to the U.S. for the first time. I’m not someone who subscribes to the (arguably xenophobic) belief that a car built in India can’t be well made, but at first glance, the EcoSport feels so shoddily put together that I’m already mentally prepping for the first stories about consumer complaints. Regardless of where this thing is built, Ford needs to step up its game.
  • On the other hand, I like the limited-edition Mustang Bullitt, but I can bet that unlike the car used in the movie, it’s not something that can be afforded on a “detective’s salary.” The last time I got bored and built a Mustang GT on Ford’s consumer site it came close to $40K. A quick Google search shows that the average salary for detectives varies from $52K to $75K, depending on the source. Sure, a detective making $75K might have enough cash for a Bullitt depending on his other bills, but the gumshoe making $52K is gonna have to stretch a bit – and that’s assuming dealers don’t mark this car up, which they will.
  • The other car that intrigues me is the Veloster N. Unlike with many performance trims, the performance doo-dads actually make this car look better than the “base” models. Not to mention that the numbers sound good. If Hyundai prices this right and gets the tuning right, the GTI has a real challenger on its hands – one that’s not named WRX or Civic Si (neither of which are available as hatchbacks, of course).
  • Some things never change: Truck wars are as active as ever. Between Chevrolet taking shots at Ford over diesel power specs, and Ford claiming its four-cylinder Ranger will lose nothing compared to V6 models, the usual, um, “contests of ego” remain. The average car buyer doesn’t care, of course, but truck guys now have new fodder for Internet flame wars.
  • The Detroit auto show is always interesting, and this year was no exception, even if it was a little strange. Chicago follows less than a month from now, and New York not quite two months after that – we shall see what weirdness may follow.

    [Images © 2018 Bozi Tatarevic/TTAC, Ford, TTAC staff]

    Tim Healey
    Tim Healey

    Tim Healey grew up around the auto-parts business and has always had a love for cars — his parents joke his first word was “‘Vette”. Despite this, he wanted to pursue a career in sports writing but he ended up falling semi-accidentally into the automotive-journalism industry, first at Consumer Guide Automotive and later at Web2Carz.com. He also worked as an industry analyst at Mintel Group and freelanced for About.com, CarFax, Vehix.com, High Gear Media, Torque News, FutureCar.com, Cars.com, among others, and of course Vertical Scope sites such as AutoGuide.com, Off-Road.com, and HybridCars.com. He’s an urbanite and as such, doesn’t need a daily driver, but if he had one, it would be compact, sporty, and have a manual transmission.

    More by Tim Healey

    Comments
    Join the conversation
    3 of 29 comments
    • NN NN on Jan 19, 2018

      I dumped my Ford stock this week after the 7% drop, which pissed me off, but I don't like what I see other than a few short term profitable hits like finally wrapping up the entire F-Series rollout and the new Lincoln Navigator I sat in this past weekend at my local auto show. There's nothing else that looks good for them. Ranger to me looks mediocre, same product they've been selling overseas, many years late to the party. No more Ford cars, 50 new Zotye low margin Chinese electric autonomous appliances. I guess they'll be abandoning Europe as well if they're not really investing in Focus/Fiesta and instead just a light rehash and move production to China. It all smells like weakness, following, and little to no future. I've had the stock since it was under $2 and Mulally brought them back. Too bad in a strong economy with lots of other growth opportunities now they look so weak.

    • Mojeimeje Mojeimeje on Jan 19, 2018

      Is it me or did the NAIAS have a lot less media days this year as compared to previous years? Everything seemed to be revealed on Monday and Tuesday and that was it.

      • Tim Healey Tim Healey on Mar 05, 2018

        Yup. I drove home on Tuesday. First time I've done that in a while -- usually, Wednesday is departure day.

    • Ltcmgm78 Just what we need to do: add more EVs that require a charging station! We own a Volt. We charge at home. We bought the Volt off-lease. We're retired and can do all our daily errands without burning any gasoline. For us this works, but we no longer have a work commute.
    • Michael S6 Given the choice between the Hornet R/T and the Alfa, I'd pick an Uber.
    • Michael S6 Nissan seems to be doing well at the low end of the market with their small cars and cuv. Competitiveness evaporates as you move up to larger size cars and suvs.
    • Cprescott As long as they infest their products with CVT's, there is no reason to buy their products. Nissan's execution of CVT's is lackluster on a good day - not dependable and bad in experience of use. The brand has become like Mitsubishi - will sell to anyone with a pulse to get financed.
    • Lorenzo I'd like to believe, I want to believe, having had good FoMoCo vehicles - my aunt's old 1956 Fairlane, 1963 Falcon, 1968 Montego - but if Jim Farley is saying it, I can't believe it. It's been said that he goes with whatever the last person he talked to suggested. That's not the kind of guy you want running a $180 billion dollar company.
    Next