By on July 8, 2017

2014 audi a6 tdi engine

American investigators, hot on the trail of Volkswagen Group executives and managers with dirty hands, haven’t had the easiest time bringing suspected emissions scandal conspirators to trial. Germany doesn’t extradite citizens facing charges in other countries, making justice a tricky pursuit for U.S. authorities.

So far, only two players in the diesel deception find themselves in the arms of U.S. law enforcement— James Liang, a former executive who worked in California (and has pleaded guilty to conspiracy charges), and Oliver Schmidt, a former U.S. environmental liaison who previously worked out of VW’s Michigan emissions office. Federal agents nabbed him during a Miami layover as the German national returned home from a tropical vacation in January. Six others remain safely in Germany after a U.S. indictment.

Well, expect another trial now. Earlier this week, Munich police arrested an Italian national, Zaccheo Giovanni Pamio, the former head of thermodynamics at Audi’s engine development division. It’s the first diesel-related arrest in Germany and Pamio’s citizenship means he’s a candidate for extradition to the United States.

Now charged in connection to the scandal, American authorities hope Pamio squeals on his bosses at Audi. As for his involvement, the federal government alleges Pamio and others decided a premium sound system was a better use of vehicle space than a proper emission control system.

On Thursday, the U.S. District Court in Detroit levelled several charges: conspiracy to defraud the U.S., wire fraud, and violation of the Clean Air Act. At his request, U.S. lawyers claim, Pamio directed his engineers to devise a way to fool American regulators into thinking a new crop of diesel engines were in compliance with pollution laws.

While the team answered to Pamio, the engine manager answered to his own higher-ups. It’s believed Pamio’s arrest is part of a plan to have lower-level execs dish dirt on top brass.

“They want names, and they want top managers,” Annette Voges, a German lawyer for one of the indicted VW execs, told The New York Times. The case against Pamio seems to bear this out. In its documentation, the U.S. implies a superior at Audi pressured him to fool American regulators, and that Pamio once spoke out about it to a senior manager. A presentation created by Pamio in 2013, in which the executive shows how special software — a defeat device — could trick regulators, was allegedly shown to a member of Audi’s management board.

Pamio became involved in the emissions cheating, the U.S. claims, after engineers complained the AdBlue exhaust additive tank in 3.0-liter diesel vehicles would take away space needed for a premium sound system. In its place, engineers fitted a smaller AdBlue tank, with specialized software metering out the fluid in smaller-than-required doses. This lead to greater on-road emissions. However, the same software would also meter out the required amount of AdBlue if the vehicle suspected an emissions test was underway, thus keeping the deception a secret.

The intention was to make the fluid last until the vehicle’s regularly scheduled oil change, thus preventing would-be diesel buyers from being turned off by a finicky vehicle.

Get the latest TTAC e-Newsletter!

10 Comments on “Audi Manager Nabbed in Germany for Role in Diesel Conspiracy; U.S. Authorities Press Charges...”


  • avatar
    zip89123

    The witch hunt continues. How many did VW kill & how many are arrested?

    How many did GM ignition switches kill and why was no one prosecuted?

    I read Ford 1.6 motors, especially those in Kuga’s & Escape’s, are catching fire, causing at least one death worldwide. Has anyone been arrested?

    • 0 avatar
      nels0300

      As far as I’m aware, GM didn’t intentionally design the ignition switches to be faulty. They were just idiots, fixed it, and hoped it would go away.

      As far as the Fords, I seriously doubt the engineers designed the 1.6L engine to catch fire and kill people. Just another engineering oversight like the GM example above.

      As for VW?

      Typical Germans, thought they were smarter than everyone else and WILLFULLY and INTENTIONALLY DESIGNED FAULTY ENGINES that they KNEW didn’t pass emissions. The arguments about which pollutants are more harmful, CO2 or NOX is irrelevant. VW doesn’t get to decide that, the US Government does because it makes the rules here. Period.

      I’ve read the comparison a million times online but there is a BIG DIFFERENCE between VW and your GM and Ford examples.

      As far as deaths VW caused, the estimates vary, but one thing is certain, it’s more than zero.

      F VW.

      • 0 avatar
        Hydromatic

        You’ve gone a bit jingoistic on us, there.

      • 0 avatar
        threeer

        “Typical Germans?” Thank you very much for the stereotype. Just because a company (even one as large as VW) made a corporate-level decision to be stupid, does NOT indicate that Germans are “typically” of this mindset. So, thank you for that. My German mother and all of my family on that side of the ocean appreciate it.

    • 0 avatar
      brn

      Zip, get over it.

      The ignition switch is designed to rotate. When idiots placed weights on their keys and applied too much torque, the switch rotated. Darwin was doing his job.

      VW designed deception into their product. When caught, they wouldn’t stop lying about it.

  • avatar
    pacificpom2

    What are the results of the emission cheating debacle? (1) the makers sought to get their vehicles passed in restrictive legislative environments, they lost, big time. (2) The environmentally aware buyer (all XXXX of them) now feels bad that they are polluting the environment more than normal and demand soothing compensation. (3) The average buyer got a less powerful vehicle when retuned, or got a cash back or some other soothing compensation whether they care or not. (4) The American legal system grinds into gear and starts asserting their authority over they rest of the world, (a new world order anybody?).

    A good job that the rest of the world can’t indicate American companies and prosecute and extradite their executives say, for tax avoidance (Amazon, Google, Apple we are looking at you)

    • 0 avatar
      nels0300

      What are you talking about?

      Let’s do that over.

      1. VW could not get their Diesel engines to pass emissions with acceptable performance, so they cheated.

      2. Tree huggers were screwed.

      3. Average buyer also screwed.

      4. United States legal system is enforcing United States laws that VW broke in the United States.

      The ability of VW apologists to spin this story every which way but the truth is truly amazing.

      • 0 avatar
        zip89123

        Me too, I want a do over.

        1) VW accommodated the rules in place & developed software to pass the tests. Cheating to some, innovative to others.

        2) Screw the tree hugger hypocrites. The ones I know won’t sell their Suburban’s & live in the biggest homes with the most square feet. The do as I say, not as I do crowd I call them.

        3) Average buyer is compensated very well. The only thing they’ll miss is 50mpg.

        4) US legal system is a joke, as is the EPA. Arresting exec’s with no bail warrants is wrong too. The punishment doesn’t fit the accusation. One of these days your innocent butt will get a taste of the bogus US legal system like I did and you’ll change your tune.

        5) how many people did VW kill = 0, zilch, nada, ZERO.

        6) The only folks spinning the story is VW haters. I’m no apologist, and welcome innovation. This has been, and continues to be, a total witch hunt. VW paid the price and yet the witch hunt continues while other brands get a pass.

        7) I had a GM with a defective ignition switch, which was replaced with another soon to be defective ignition switch, and my vehicle wasn’t even on the list. I traded it for another brand and swore off GM, for life.

        • 0 avatar
          hotdog453

          What should the punishment to Volkswagen be, in your opinion? Anything?

          If you cannot hold some executives responsible for the decisions, the punishment will be strictly financial and no one held accountable. There has to be someone responsible for the decisions.

  • avatar
    pacificpom2

    Simple, you do what the French did to hold back the Japanese manufacturers in the early days, insist or legislate that all VW cars must undergo an emissions test prior to delivery to dealers or buyer. Don’t accept a blanket test result like the manufacturers can do today. Also, this testing can only be done at one certified government testing station and they only have one qualified tech :). This will result in loss of sales/increased cost and set a time limit to for the next two years. It is a punishment that affects the whole group. Now as for executives that broke American laws on American soil, no problems. To request extradition is also fair, whether the sovereign country has treaties or the judiciary allows the extradition, that’s another problem. Or you could just rendition them to a compliant nation and take it from there.

Read all comments

Recent Comments

  • Urlik: Actually all they care about is that the union and their paychecks survive. They would throw both the members...
  • ttiguy: Cmon man, he’s (Posky) never had to try over and over again to solve a math/science/whatever problem in...
  • ttiguy: @ LouBC the author is just as much of an uneducated medical hack as he is an uneducated automotive...
  • taxman100: I love full sized sedans, but the latest Avalon is UGLY. I’m not a fan of modern styling, so...
  • Matt Posky: At no point does the above article do entertain ludicrous Q theories about chip implants or how Trump is...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber