By on August 30, 2016

Winterkorn, Piech, Piech - Picture courtesy Volkswagen

Former Volkswagen chairman Ferdinand Piëch resigned his position a month after questioning and failing to get answers from ex-CEO Martin Winterkorn about the company’s defeat devices, an internal probe revealed.

The finding from the investigation by U.S. law firm Jones Day was published in the German newspaper Bild am Sonntag, Bloomberg reports, shedding light on the power struggle that preceded the diesel emissions scandal.

In March of 2015, Volkswagen was already being investigated by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. According a report in Bild, when Piëch cornered Winterkorn after the Geneva Motor Show, the CEO responded to his questions about the investigation by saying he had it all under control.

That interaction caused a widening rift between the two executives, who had once been very close. A feud broke out, with Piëch publicly questioning Winterkorn’s authority and scraping any plans to appoint him as his successor. Ultimately, Piëch resigned as chairman of Volkswagen AG’s supervisory board in April, 2015.

Winterkorn stepped down almost immediately after the scandal went public in September. The ex-CEO is now under investigation by German investigators, along with brand chief Herbert Diess. The probe aims to find out what knowledge either man had of the emissions deception, and when.

Evidence suggests that Winterkorn may have known of the looming scandal in May of 2014, a year before his falling out with Piëch. A memo detailing the International Council on Clean Transportation study, which blew the lid off of the deception, landed on his desk on May 23 of that year. He also attended a meeting during the summer of 2015 where the issue was mentioned.

Piëch never revealed the reason for his split with Winterkorn, only saying that he didn’t approve of the executive’s U.S. product strategy.

[Image: Volkswagen]

Get the latest TTAC e-Newsletter!

8 Comments on “Piëch v. Winterkorn Row Triggered By VW Dieselgate Scandal: Report...”


  • avatar
    JimZ

    deeper we go down the rabbit hole.

  • avatar
    tedward

    Now this is interesting, if true. I had been assuming a somewhat opposite order of guilt here. However, with winterkorn’s audi history in mind it makes some sense, he must have been exercising considerable autonomy before his elevation to ceo as well.

    I remember when they split, no one here had any real idea why and everyone was worried that piech wanted to reinstitute the phaeton plan or something in the us. This makes much more sense.

  • avatar
    ToddAtlasF1

    Will Piëch find a way of resuming control of VW AG after letting every other executive in the company fall on their swords? He probably knew as soon as anyone did.

  • avatar
    s_a_p

    this sort of confirms my speculation that this was on the radar long before VW was exposed, and the reason there is no quick “fix” is because they would have released it before the scandal broke if there where. On the cars with urea injection, it makes me wonder exactly how much extra fluid it would require to be compliant and if that is the only hang up(say a 5k mile top off vs 10k miles) then it would have been released along with free service to cover the hassle. If these vehicles can pass under certain conditions, how bad is the drivability under those conditions? These seem like simple questions, that nobody has answered. I dont expect there to be simple solutions, but VW is a case study in how *not* to handle a scandal such as this.

    • 0 avatar
      Luke42

      My guess is that the problems with VW are more management problems than technical problems.

      Given how much denial and foot-dragging has occurred over the course of this scandal, I wouldn’t be surprised if the problems you propose worked in engineering terms — but nobody in a leadership position would sign off on it.

      After all, not listening to their engineers when they said building an emissions-compliabt diesel engine without urea injection was impossible is more or less how they got in to this mess in the first place….

  • avatar
    fincar1

    Scraping…scrapping…two different words.

    • 0 avatar
      Lorenzo

      Given the amazing flexibility of the English language, especially in the hands of Americans, there’s probably an alternate definition of both words that mesh together perfectly.

  • avatar
    hreardon

    A lesson can be learned from the study of the loss of Challenger and Columbia shuttle orbiters. In both cases, what on the surface appeared to be an engineering failure was actually a management / political failure. In both cases you had a vehicle operating to engineered specifications, but exhibiting anomalies that the technical team warned management about.

    In both cases you had management who essentially said, “damn the torpedoes, full steam ahead” and accepted these anomalies as acceptable risks.

    Much like the financial shenanigans leading up to the financial crisis in 2008: it worked….until it didn’t. And then when it failed, it did so catastrophically.

    Richard Feynman said it best: “For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for nature cannot be fooled.”

    Volkswagen, like NASA of the 1980s and again in the early 2000s, has spent years ignoring reality. Management ignored the facts and felt that they could simply ‘will’ things into existence: be it faster and cheaper launch rates without compromising safety at NASA or cleaner burning diesels at Volkswagen.

    At NASA corporate culture was ultimately blamed for the failure, and I suspect that when Jones Day finishes up their analysis at VW, we’ll find the same thing here.

    Piech is extremely crafty. You can be sure that when he got a whiff of what was going on with emissions in the US he knew the gig was up and that the bottom was about to fall out. He got out when the getting was good.

Read all comments

Back to TopLeave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Recent Comments

  • CKNSLS Sierra SLT: theflyersfan Personally I would never finance a vehicle for 84 months, but transaction prices...
  • ajla: Like if the C8 Z06 was a $90K version of this, would it be so bad? youtube.com/watch?v=MWfJIJ213p Q&t
  • ajla: “sports car/muscle car hybrid” I think he means something like “grand touring” car but...
  • dal20402: Looks like the LFX is pretty susceptible, but not too many bad things happen as a result. The LGX is a lot...
  • mcs: “I still think that Corvette is supposed to be a sports car/muscle car hybrid, and that mid engine doesn’t...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber