Piston Slap: A Car So Nice I Wanna Buy It Twice!

Sajeev Mehta
by Sajeev Mehta

TTAC Commentator NotAPreppie writes:

Hey Sajeev … or Sanjeev … I’m not feeling picky,

Am I insane for considering buying the same Mazda RX-8 twice? Alternate title: A car so nice I want to buy it twice. (Thanks for that – SM)

Backstory: Three years ago, I sold my daily driver and autocross car (2005 Mazda RX-8 Sport) to a car club buddy when living and going to school near downtown Chicago meant that it sat in a parking garage for months on end (physical chemistry was intense). I graduated and got a job a year ago and bought a new autocross toy: a 1995 Miata, now with 70k miles.

The Miata has turned out to be something of a mongrel. Anywhere fluids can leak, they have. Not having a garage to wrench on the car myself, it’s nickel-and-diming me to death. Also, I’ve discovered that while it’s a Great Car™ during the 60 seconds of an average autocross run, it’s pretty awful to live with day to day. Maybe if I didn’t live in a major metropolitan area, I’d see the appeal of a soft top. To add insult to injury, I think it aggravates my sciatica.

Fast forward to last weekend: I ran into my old ‘8 and her current owner at an autocross event (I swear I did a triple-take when I walked past her on the grid). The owner was making noises about selling it. He’d tried last November, lowering the price to $6,500 before giving up and deciding to hang onto it. It’s got 48,000 miles and is still on the original engine (which shows none of the usual symptoms of low compression, compression check will be requested) and is in exactly the same condition as when it left my hands (actually in better shape, mechanically speaking).

So… am I insane for wanting to buy my ‘8 back?

Sajeev answers:

Yes you are insane. That said, who cares?

There’s something very touching about getting back the car you once owned. You are a different dude, what with your new life outside of school. And you obviously love it — you’re a Mazda nut, you’ll enjoy having it back. That said…

The second-generation RX-8 is so, so much better from a long-term ownership perspective. The R3 version is a better track car, even if the ride is punishing. Don’t take my word for it, take Jonny Lieberman’s word back when he was a (relative) nobody here at TTAC. Even though I like the front end of the original Mazda RX-8 better, you owe it to yourself to consider a later model.

[Image: Shutterstock user cleanfotos]

Send your queries to sajeev@thetruthaboutcars.com. Spare no details and ask for a speedy resolution if you’re in a hurry…but be realistic, and use your make/model specific forums instead of TTAC for more timely advice.

Sajeev Mehta
Sajeev Mehta

More by Sajeev Mehta

Comments
Join the conversation
2 of 74 comments
  • Krhodes1 Krhodes1 on Oct 08, 2015

    I swapped my '84 Jetta GLI back and forth with my best friend for eons. We would each keep it for a couple years until we got bored and sold it to the other. Usually for a nominal sum. So I can totally see doing this, assuming you have a place to keep it and ideally something else as a daily driver. Though the thought of replacing the engine every 100K doesn't really scare me that much, given that is ~20 years of driving for any one of my cars. :-)

  • VolandoBajo VolandoBajo on Oct 09, 2015

    If I could find another 88 Thunderbird with the 302 V8 and the AOD transmission, in metallic silver, moonroof, dark blue leather interior, and the aluminum billet wheels I had to lean on the dealer to swap in, I would buy it in a heartbeat. I got over a quarter of a million miles of fun out of that car in under a decade, before I had to sell it. Had to choose between supporting it, or supporting my then new wife and child. I made the right decision, but would love to have one back. Sometimes I fantasize that FoMoCo would have a giant 3D printer, where, for the price of the original, one could order up an exact replica of an earlier offering. I would buy another one of those Birds, just as it was the day I drove it off the dealer's lot (minus the Eagle GT's and plus the Sumitomos for half the price and twice the traction). That car even trumped the Mk II Jaguar I once owned. In fact, if I hadn't been so in love with my then and now wife, I wouldn't even have been in a position to have had to choose between her and the car. But she is one in a hundred million. When we had been dating for about six weeks, I found out that she had driven it when her hooptie died for the nth time, without telling me while I was on the road for a project I was doing. Any other woman, I would have figured I couldn't trust her, and would have x'd her off...her, I just told her that if she had asked, I would have told her yes, but made sure she knew how to care for it. I realized I was already all in at that point. It had snuck up on me, but there was no turning back. I had been enjoying my new freedom for several years after my divorce, but I knew then that those days were behind me. Still, I loved that car then, and would love to have it back again. Even if it had a 100K +/- on it. But not enough to have remained a so-called "free born man of the USA" (a Wire reference for those who don't know it.) But that was a tough day, when I had to let the most enjoyable car I had ever owned go. Especially since the early years of our marriage were good overall, but had their downs as well as their ups. But today, my only regret is that I didn't make even more money than I did, so I could have swung both deals back in the mid-90's. That configuration of the 88 Thunderbird deserves to be on a list of all time great Fords, along with the Model A (only for historical reasons), the T bucket (only because it made a good hotrod), the 32 Ford three window coupe, the 40 Ford, something from the 50's and from the 60's (you pick 'em), a few more modern ones, and I'm sure, the new GT350. If I had the kind of money Jay Leno has, I'd have all of them in my collection. But if not, I would still have that 88 Bird again, if, and it is a big IF, if you could "go home again". And while I respect some of the authors who rave about the Miata being the answer to any question, in my mind, it is even the answer to "what is an under-powered, over-rated money pit?", especially the first incarnations. But damn, no you have me jonesing for another Thunderbird...not a prudent use of my retirement time and money, but I would love to have it anyway. Unfortunately for me, my son's auto taste runs more towards the high performance version of the Tesla. But if I was his age, mine probably would also. Still, that was one sweet matchup of comfort and roadworthiness in the Bird.

  • Bkojote Allright, actual person who knows trucks here, the article gets it a bit wrong.First off, the Maverick is not at all comparable to a Tacoma just because they're both Hybrids. Or lemme be blunt, the butch-est non-hybrid Maverick Tremor is suitable for 2/10 difficulty trails, a Trailhunter is for about 5/10 or maybe 6/10, just about the upper end of any stock vehicle you're buying from the factory. Aside from a Sasquatch Bronco or Rubicon Jeep Wrangler you're looking at something you're towing back if you want more capability (or perhaps something you /wish/ you were towing back.)Now, where the real world difference should play out is on the trail, where a lot of low speed crawling usually saps efficiency, especially when loaded to the gills. Real world MPG from a 4Runner is about 12-13mpg, So if this loaded-with-overlander-catalog Trailhunter is still pulling in the 20's - or even 18-19, that's a massive improvement.
  • Lou_BC "That’s expensive for a midsize pickup" All of the "offroad" midsize trucks fall in that 65k USD range. The ZR2 is probably the cheapest ( without Bison option).
  • Lou_BC There are a few in my town. They come out on sunny days. I'd rather spend $29k on a square body Chevy
  • Lou_BC I had a 2010 Ford F150 and 2010 Toyota Sienna. The F150 went through 3 sets of brakes and Sienna 2 sets. Similar mileage and 10 year span.4 sets tires on F150. Truck needed a set of rear shocks and front axle seals. The solenoid in the T-case was replaced under warranty. I replaced a "blend door motor" on heater. Sienna needed a water pump and heater blower both on warranty. One TSB then recall on spare tire cable. Has a limp mode due to an engine sensor failure. At 11 years old I had to replace clutch pack in rear diff F150. My ZR2 diesel at 55,000 km. Needs new tires. Duratrac's worn and chewed up. Needed front end alignment (1st time ever on any truck I've owned).Rear brakes worn out. Left pads were to metal. Chevy rear brakes don't like offroad. Weird "inside out" dents in a few spots rear fenders. Typically GM can't really build an offroad truck issue. They won't warranty. Has fender-well liners. Tore off one rear shock protector. Was cheaper to order from GM warehouse through parts supplier than through Chevy dealer. Lots of squeaks and rattles. Infotainment has crashed a few times. Seat heater modual was on recall. One of those post sale retrofit.Local dealer is horrific. If my son can't service or repair it, I'll drive 120 km to the next town. 1st and last Chevy. Love the drivetrain and suspension. Fit and finish mediocre. Dealer sucks.
  • MaintenanceCosts You expect everything on Amazon and eBay to be fake, but it's a shame to see fake stuff on Summit Racing. Glad they pulled it.
Next