Yes, It's Ironic That Rota's Being Knocked-Off, But It's Still A Problem
The Internet’s alive with schadenfreude regarding ROTA wheels. The company recently warned consumers that fake ROTA wheels were being manufactured in China and distributed in several of the markets in which ROTA has a presence. This has made a lot of people laugh because ROTA themselves are considered to be “copiers” or “counterfeiters”.
Your humble author has been racing on ROTA wheels since 2008, as seen above in a rather hilarious-in-retrospect incident featuring a spinning open-cockpit racer and my Neon. Naturally, I have an opinion about this.
ROTA makes their wheels in the Philippines, where labor is cheap and the OSHA isn’t there to keep children from handling molten aluminum. That’s a joke. I have no reason to believe that child labor even exists there. But seriously. It’s cheaper to make wheels in the Philippines than it is to make them in Japan, which is almost certainly why the latter country invaded the former in 1942 and forced “Dugout Doug” MacArthur to flee while Jonathan Wainwright stuck around and did two years in a POW camp. The definition of hero isn’t always cut and dried, you know. History picks winners and losers and it’s not always right.
But I digress. While Spoon Sports wheels and many other great racing wheels are forged — by taking a “blank” wheel shape and ramming it into a mold at high speed and/or pressure, preserving the original grain of the metal — the ROTAs are cast, which means they pour hot metal into a mold and let it cool. The result is a wheel that is usually heavier, less durable, but considerably cheaper. The Slipstreams I have for the Neon originally cost about $110 apiece. The real Spoon wheels cost about $450 each. That’s a real difference when you need three sets to race a crappy FWD econobox. I’m sure Christian Horner doesn’t stress the price of forged wheels for his race team but I sure as hell do.
There’s nothing original about the design of most ROTA wheels. They’re copies of better wheels. So who cares if they are knocked-off in China? Well, I do. ROTAs might not be terribly original but they are safe, decent wheels that are perfectly suited for don’t-give-a-f** activities like club racing. I wouldn’t put them on my 911 but then again I don’t drive my 911 into walls at high speeds the way I do my Neon. Everything’s relative.
ROTAs never pretended to be anything but ROTAs; they came with a ROTA cap and the company publicized their products. These fakes, on the other hand, are made to unknown safety standards by unknown people and they are intended to be passed off as “real” ROTAs. There’s a real risk there, particularly in high-speed applications. Freeway use, by the way, is a high-speed application. If you don’t believe me, loosen all your lug nuts and try a run down a six-lane at 70mph.
There is something ironic about a “copy company” being targeted by counterfeiters, but it’s worth remembering that Toyota used to copy the Chevrolet Stovebolt Six. This kind of thing isn’t always cut or dried. Ask ROTA, or Spoon Sports, or that other noted victim of Philippine flattery-by-imitation, Steve Perry.
More by Jack Baruth
Latest Car Reviews
Read moreLatest Product Reviews
Read moreRecent Comments
- Fred I had a 2009 S-line mine was chipped but otherwise stock. I still say it was the best "new" car I ever had. I wanted to get the new A3, but it was too expensive, didn't come with a hatch and no manual.
- 3-On-The-Tree If Your buying a truck like that your not worried about MPG.
- W Conrad I'd gladly get an EV, but I can't even afford anything close to a new car right now. No doubt if EV's get more affordable more people will be buying them. It is a shame so many are stuck in their old ways with ICE vehicles. I realize EV's still have some use cases that don't work, but for many people they would work just fine with a slightly altered mindset.
- Master Baiter There are plenty of affordable EVs--in China where they make all the batteries. Tesla is the only auto maker with a reasonably coherent strategy involving manufacturing their own cells in the United States. Tesla's problem now is I think they've run out of customers willing to put up with their goofy ergonomics to have a nice drive train.
- Cprescott Doesn't any better in red than it did in white. Looks like an even uglier Honduh Civic 2 door with a hideous front end (and that is saying something about a Honduh).
Comments
Join the conversation
Unfortunately, we've outsourced so much manufacturing to china (and since they don't necessarily have the same initial understanding of Quality) we've spent a lot of time, money and effort to make them good at stuff they haven't traditionally been very good at. That said I know nothing of Rota or their Chinese knockoffs but much like discussions of Hermosillo manufacturing capability, it's no longer a given that Chines made automatically equals junk. There are plenty of people walking around with various life sustaining medical implants made in China or Mexico or Costa Rica or the Dominican Republic or all sort of other places you wouldn't be necessarily associate with an appreciation of Quality.
"ROTAs never pretended to be anything but ROTAs; they came with a ROTA cap and the company publicized their products. These fakes, on the other hand, are made to unknown safety standards by unknown people and they are intended to be passed off as “real” ROTAs." I found that statement humorous, because ROTAs themselves are fake and made to unknown safety standards. And you're insane for using ROTAs in a track application. Google search "Rota track wheel failure." I dare you.