By on October 16, 2012

Criticism is what we do around here. We critique cars, car companies, politicians, consumers and, of course, other automotive writers and publications. Of course if you’re negative about everything, you’re a curmudgeon, not a critic. Criticism, if it is to have any value, must be fair, willing to praise as well as to demerit. TTAC has taken its share of shots against automotive websites, traditional buff books and the Detroit daily newspapers. So much so, in fact, that some of our readers have offered their own criticism that we unduly snipe at others. I don’t agree with that criticism, but it is easy and tempting to dwell on the negative and there are indeed many worthy publications and writers that deserve to be praised as much as the hacks deserve to be exposed. When I read that Aaron Severson’s masterful automotive history site, Ate Up With Motor, has won the E.P. Ingersoll Award, given by the Society of Automotive Historians, it was not really a surprise. Ate Up With Motor is the gold standard for online automotive history.

E.P. Ingersoll was the original American autojourno. He founded The Horseless Age, the first car magazine, in 1895. Back in the day it served as both an enthusiast’s publication and a trade journal for the automotive industry. By 1909 motorcars were competing with other motorcars, not horses, so the name was changed to The Automobile. It continues to be the oldest automotive publication still in operation, currently publishing under the Automotive Industries title.

The SAH gives out the E. P. Ingersoll Award “for the best presentation of automotive history in other than print media” and in the past the Ingersoll award has been given to films, television shows and other websites. The award committee’s criteria are based on historical accuracy and educational value of the nominees. Severson’s work easily surpasses those standards – I read a lot of automotive history and Aaron’s work is on a high academic level. Sources are cited in detail and there are sidebars on related topics as needed. He’s also pretty religious about making sure he has permission to use the photographs that illustrate his histories. I’m honored that he’s chosen some of my own photographs – as a matter of fact I respect his work so much that I’ve gone out of my way to shoot specific cars for AUWM’s use. Severson has graciously responded whenever I’ve asked for a source citation for a fact or a quote. Again, these are serious histories, for people with an attention span, they are decidedly not for the TL;DR crowd. Many website editors don’t want you to go much above 1,000 words on any topic because a lot of “readers” won’t read it all. In comparison, a typical model history at AUWM runs ~5,000 words.

Unlike some of those academic automotive historians, Aaron actually likes cars. Academic histories can be dry reads, focusing more on business than on cars and personalities. AUWM is targeted at the historian and auto enthusiast alike, putting cars and the auto industry in a broader societal context, while informing enthusiasts about the cars and marques they appreciate. Each article focuses on a specific car model, but in doing so the history of the marque making that car is also detailed. Unlike a lot of online automotive histories, you can rely on what he writes. One of the things that I’ve discovered when dabbling in automotive history myself is that you often see the same account repeated in a lot of secondary and tertiary sources that turns out to be based on a single publication. Sometimes that original publication is accurate, like Michael Lamm’s work, sometimes it’s an urban legend, sometimes it’s just one person’s account. If you want to get things correctly, you have to be willing to do more than just checking Wikipedia or doing a cursory internet search. Sometimes it means using these things called books and libraries, like the Detroit Public Library’s National Automotive History Collection. We’ve all had the experience of following a link, looking for information and ending up at a dodgy (as opposed to Dodgey) site. Ate Up With Motor uses no dodgy sources.

One of the SAH’s criteria is that the nominee should use the most recent information available. Aaron’s dedication to getting the historical record straight includes substantially revising stuff he’d previously published when further research merits a revision. When he makes a mistake, he corrects it. AUWM isn’t perfect. It’s a one man operation, and at the level of Severson’s work you can’t expect fresh content at the site every day. Still, it’s literally the first place that I look when I’m looking into the automotive past and it’s nice to see good work get due credit.

Ronnie Schreiber edits Cars In Depth, a realistic perspective on cars & car culture and the original 3D car site. If you found this post worthwhile, you can dig deeper at Cars In Depth. If the 3D thing freaks you out, don’t worry, all the photo and video players in use at the site have mono options. Thanks – RJS

 

Get the latest TTAC e-Newsletter!

15 Comments on “Automotive Historians Name Aaron Severson’s Ate Up With Motor Website Winner of E.P. Ingersoll Award...”


  • avatar
    tmkreutzer

    Congratulations to “Ate Up With Motor.” It truly is one of the best websites on the internet.

  • avatar
    Omnifan

    If you’ve never read it, you need to. Really great in-depth stories about cars and the auto industry that made them.

  • avatar

    If you wanna know John DeLorean’s role – or lack thereof – in developing the Vega…

    Or why the ’65 Fords were so boxy…

    Or why “Chrysler” could be a good name for a cat…(think “nine lives”)

    You’ll come to AUWM. It’s well-researched and very readable while not glossing over important details. MUST read!

    Congratulations Aaron!!

  • avatar
    patman

    When will Ate Up With Motor be available in coffee table book form? I would buy that.

  • avatar
    johnny ringo

    I’m quite pleased to see that Aaron Severson’s “Ate Up With Motor”
    getting the recognition if deserves. It really is a great website; very well-written and researched automotive histories.

  • avatar
    Acd

    If you haven’t been there make sure you’ve got plenty of free time because you’ll quickly find yourself getting drawn into cars that you didn’t care much about before you read about them there. Very well written and researched.

    It is nice to see one of the good guys win. Keep it up Aaron!

  • avatar
    Felis Concolor

    Congratulations to Aaron Severson and AUWM, where you will find histories that are enlightening, uplifting, heartbreaking and always entertaining. Be sure to set aside some time once you select an article; you’ll be there for a while.

  • avatar
    jpcavanaugh

    I would like to add another congratulations to Aaron. Top quality research and writing for a genuinely in-depth analysis of the subject, whatever it may be.

    It is one thing to bang out a 1000-1500 word piece in a week by sifting through multiple sources to try and separate wheat from chaff (and I know a bit about this) but Aaron takes any project to a completely different level. My only complaint is how much time I spend whenever I get onto his site. :)

  • avatar
    86er

    Aaron the Automotive Edifying Extraordinaire!

  • avatar
    Lightspeed

    Congrats to Ate Up With Motor! I love the site, I’ve wasted far too much time learning amazing things at the site. AUWM shows both the visionary successes and the hubristic failures that make cars so fascinating.

  • avatar
    High-brid

    What a great site Ate Up With Motor is. I’m afraid to go there because I know I’ll wind up spending hours reading about Checkers and Nash Metropolitans and other almost-forgotten cars of the past.

  • avatar
    Angus McClure

    Not that anybody would have noticed but he got the Angus award before this. I think I have read everything on his site. Good work and congratulations.

  • avatar
    ...m...

    …an exceptionally well-earned honor in this instance: congratulations to aaron along with a heartfelt thank-you for bringing such a studious and insightful resource to the ‘web…

    ..my only complaints are the weekends lost when i first stumbled upon ate up with motor several years ago and that it’s not humanly possible to add content more frequently than he already does…

  • avatar
    probert

    I concur with other commenters – It’s a great website and I’ve always wondered how he finds the time to write the kind of detailed lucid articles that I read with great pleasure and a sense of discovery. On top of that he seems to always take the time to give a well considered reply to posts.

    I’ve happily donated to support the site and look forward to the next article.

    Congratulations.

Read all comments

Recent Comments

  • Mad Machine: So what are you supposed to when automakers are phasing out ICEs in the next decade or so?
  • eggsalad: My condo’s HOA just enacted a rule which states that it is *forbidden* to charge an EV on the...
  • golden2husky: I’ve used POR15 and was very satisfied with the results…
  • CaddyDaddy: We are getting close, I’ll take a 62′ finished in Silver Lilac please! Everyone says these...
  • thegamper: I kind of like this in white with the black rims. The base model of the prior year was actually the most...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Jo Borras
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber