Pour One Out For Road & Track

Jack Baruth
by Jack Baruth

It’s the end of an era, as perhaps the best of the remaining American color car rags moves from Newport Beach to Ann Arbor. As the slightly snobby California counterpart to Motor Trend‘s unhappy mediocrity and Car and Driver’s wild swings between brilliance and boorishness, Road & Track has always provided pleasant, well-illustrated automotive content with a motorsports focus. No doubt part of that was due to the magazine’s distance from the Detroit manufacturers and its proximity to West Coast racetracks and the car-club culture.

No longer. Hearst Corporation is choosing to geographically merge R&T with C/D, and just in case there’s someone out there who isn’t getting the memo about what’s expected, they’re changing leadership as well.

According to the Hearst press release, former C/D editor Larry Webster will be calling the shots are the newly relocated magazine. Mr. Webster’s resume includes several impressive results in manufacturer-funded race appearances as well as a variety of legitimately interesting columns and features over his career. He is a legitimate “car guy”, not a “lifestyle guy” or a marketroid who endlessly bounces between both sides of the PR/journo buffet table.

Even with Mr. Webster’s legitimate qualifications taken into account, it’s hard to see this as anything other than the same sort of broken thinking that has over-promoted the current leadership at the other American magazines. Combine that with a move back into the sordid orbits of the PR machine, and it’s easy to conclude that Hearst is simply preparing everyone for the inevitable merger of their two automotive properties.

I will miss the old R&T. There was always a quiet dignity to their leafy photography and painstaking specification sheets. Let’s hope Mr. Webster makes this slide into oblivion as painless as possible.

Jack Baruth
Jack Baruth

More by Jack Baruth

Comments
Join the conversation
4 of 101 comments
  • 05lgt 05lgt on Jun 01, 2012

    Someone give Jack a car to drive and write about. This is getting ridiculous. How long has it been? Was the rental Corolla really the last one? Am I forgetting a car?

  • Jeff Snavely Jeff Snavely on Jun 03, 2012

    I think R&T is currently the worst of the mags - all their new car previews & reviews read like press releases with no opinion or commentary to be found. The big comparos are good, but I only skim R&T vs. reading all the other mags.

    • See 1 previous
    • Highdesertcat Highdesertcat on Jun 04, 2012

      @NMGOM "Sometimes I wish they (R&T, C&D) wouldn’t turn everything into a contest of rankings with winners and losers." They're in the business of selling magazines. That's why they chose that format. And they each have their favorites, driven by the amount of ad dollars spent with them. My recommendation is to test drive each of the vehicles you are interested in and then decide for yourself. One example was a friend of ours whose Murano CVT had died for the second time and was no longer covered under warranty. My wife let her drive our 2012 Jeep Grand Cherokee to Albuquerque to buy a new car and the woman fell in love with it. Instead of buying a Pilot, as she had intended to do, she ended up driving another Grand Cherokee home. Mags are good for entertainment value, not much else. The final decision should always be seat-of-the-pants.

  • Scott Who makes the best used cars? I thought they all made new cars. (silly me)
  • Jkross22 It's the one with some warranty left.
  • Big Al from Oz Well, the best manufacturer of a used vehicle? Who makes used cars? If we are asking which manufacturer produced the best vehicle for resale I would think most any (with a few exceptions). Used vehicle condition is dependent upon the maintenance performed over its life cycle. There are good Mitsubishis and Nissans out there, somewhere.
  • Ajla Anything over about 5 years or 50k miles and you're buying the prior owner's maintenance and driving habits as much as you are the brand.
  • Loser I had a spice red 06, only complaint was the stereo sucked. The low end torque was intoxicating. Had an ‘04 Mustang Mach that I really loved but the GTO was a huge upgrade. It was probably the best road trip car I’ve ever had. They were just about giving them away when I got mine. Never understood why they didn’t sell better. People say it was too bland but it was perfect to me.
Next