Piston Slap: A Real Caddy, A Once in a Lifetime Deal…

Sajeev Mehta
by Sajeev Mehta

TTAC commentator Kenzter writes:

Sajeev,

I recently picked up a 1969 Cadillac Sedan Deville. It was one of those once-in-a-lifetime deals you only hear about, like my uncles cousins sister is selling her deceased husbands garage queen for pennies on the dollar deal.

My problem is, the Automatic Climate Control (a $550 option!) does not work. The only settings that trigger any response are FOG and ICE. Even then, I can only hear the blower motor and just barely feel air from the floor vents. Where to begin the troubleshooting?

Thanks,


Kenzter

Sajeev answers:

Damn son, that sounds like a choice cut of Cadillac. I love Caddy’s “fuselage era” not just because I bleed Panther Love, or started watching Mad Men from the beginning on DVD last week…but that never hurts!

First off, you told me absolutely nothing about the car’s condition. Odds are older vehicles have worn out HVAC systems because of use or neglect. I hope you understand the headaches associated with old car ownership: when I removed/replaced the evaporator/heater core/blower motor from my 1988 Mercury Cougar XR-7 with nearly 200,000 miles on the clock, I was horrified at the state of everything! But cleaning and replacing worked so well: even with a conversion to less-efficient R134a, the Cougar now has the strongest A/C in the Mehta fleet. It will freeze the balls off a polar bear on the low-speed setting!


Even low mile garage queens have HVAC problems, because getting old is a bitch no matter who or what you are.

That said, my gut says you have bad vacuum lines under the hood. Especially the one from the vacuum source to the firewall, to (eventually) the HVAC box behind the dashboard. But that’s for starters: I am so confident because you said the only “response” was from the defogger setting. Most, if not all, HVAC systems will default to the top setting when vacuum lines fail: this is a safety feature to keep your windshield from fogging up in interior/exterior climate changes. Well, in theory.

But what else do you do? You probably need a new blower motor, at this age. And maybe the factory service manuals (that you need to own) will help you dig deeper and find more problems. Also get Cadillac specific parts catalogs from various vendors, just so you know what the world has to offer in terms of new parts. Every catalog I get in the mail is like a mini-Christmas present…even if I may buy elsewhere, especially via eBay.

When you have the proper books, get the proper tools. Maybe join a local Cadillac-LaSalle club. Start reading up, learning and slowly tackle the project in your spare time. Eventually you will fix the whole system. And enjoy the ride, because everything can and will eventually fail on an antique car. That’s part of the fun.

Welcome to the sickness, I am happy you joined us!

Send your queries to sajeev@thetruthaboutcars.com. Spare no details and ask for a speedy resolution if you’re in a hurry.

Sajeev Mehta
Sajeev Mehta

More by Sajeev Mehta

Comments
Join the conversation
4 of 37 comments
  • Doug-g Doug-g on May 14, 2012

    Let me begin by apologizing for nit-picking a seemingly minor point, but I must correct the reference to this car as a “fuselage era” Cadillac. The "fuselage era" began with the 1971 full-size models and ran through 1976. This car contains a design element so significant that's its designer (Wayne Kady) is still remembered and credited for the concept. In 1965, Cadillac was shorn of its fins. Kady came up with the precise crease line in the side paneling that swept from the top of the front fender downwards across the body to the upper rear fender. This, combined with the rear fender "kick up", visually gave Cadillac its fins back. These "phantom fins" first appeared on the 1967 full-size models (Eldorado excluded) and were a feature through the 1970 model year. Sorry, I had to give Wayne his props.

    • See 1 previous
    • Roberto Esponja Roberto Esponja on May 18, 2012

      @Sajeev Mehta I thought the "fuselage" term had been coined only for the 69-73 large ChryCo cars...

  • Beefmalone Beefmalone on May 16, 2012

    Just be glad it isn't an Imperial with the Autotemp system.

  • Lorenzo Yes, they can recover from the Ghosn-led corporate types who cheapened vehicles in the worst ways, including quality control. In the early to mid-1990s Nissan had efficient engines, and reliable drivetrains in well-assembled, fairly durable vehicles. They can do it again, but the Japanese government will have to help Nissan extricate itself from the "Alliance". It's too bad Japan didn't have a George Washington to warn about entangling alliances!
  • Slavuta Nissan + profitability = cheap crap
  • ToolGuy Why would they change the grille?
  • Oberkanone Nissan proved it can skillfully put new frosting on an old cake with Frontier and Z. Yet, Nissan dealers are so broken they are not good at selling the Frontier. Z production is so minimal I've yet to see one. Could Nissan boost sales? Sure. I've heard Nissan plans to regain share at the low end of the market. Kicks, Versa and lower priced trims of their mainstream SUV's. I just don't see dealerships being motivated to support this effort. Nissan is just about as exciting and compelling as a CVT.
  • ToolGuy Anyone who knows, is this the (preliminary) work of the Ford Skunk Works?
Next