Georgia HOT Lanes Create Congestion, Disappointment

by The Newspaper

Published: October 19th, 2011

georgia hot lanes create congestion disappointment

Georgia’s introduction of high occupancy toll (HOT) lanes on Interstate 85 at the beginning of the month has already turned into a public relations disaster. During rush hour, motorists found themselves stranded in the general purpose lanes as the adjacent HOT lane — constructed and maintained with their tax dollars — were essentially unused. Drivers balked at paying the stiff $5.40 entrance tax for permission to enter, leaving the existing lane space to go to waste. Governor Nathan Deal (R) intervened swiftly on October 6 to order the State Road and Tollway Authority (SRTA) to lower the cost of using the toll lane.

“Looking at what we’ve learned from our first four work days with the HOT lanes, I’ve asked SRTA to improve utilization of the express lanes,” Deal said in a statement. “In the short term, the toll rate will lower — starting with Thursday afternoon’s commute — but the effective rate will continue to change to regulate speed and volume.”

The HOT lanes idea was hailed from the start as an important advance in the region’s transportation network. Using $110 million in federal gas tax dollars, a system of gantries was set up requiring drivers to install an electronic transponder, called the Peach Pass, if they wished to pay to use a 15-mile stretch of the freeway that previously had been set aside as a high-occupancy vehicle (HOV), free for the use of anyone carrying an extra passenger in his vehicle. The change to the HOT format was hailed as a proven concept.

“The opening of the I-85 Express Lanes will represent a new era in transportation innovation,” SRTA Executive Director Gena L. Evans, said on September 16.

After the project actually opened for business, motorist Howard Rodgers quickly racked up more than 1500 electronic and hardcopy signatures on a petition calling for a halt to the HOT lanes.

“By removing the existing HOV lane for use as a toll lane the state has created daily traffic jams and backlogs causing greater pollution, increased travel times, and an extra tax on the citizens of Gwinnett County and points north during times of economic decline,” the petition states. “The adjustable toll system amounts to a monopoly on the travel lane requiring customer to pay a higher surcharge (price gouging) for the ability to arrive to or from work in a timely manner.”

Deal forced state officials to ask the Federal Highway Administration for permission to allow vehicles with two, as opposed to three, people on board to use the express lanes for free. I-85 is not the only HOT lane to fail. In Washington State, the State Route 167 HOT lanes are on their third year in operation. According to the third-quarter financial results, it cost $173,939 more in toll collection expenses to operate the lanes than was generated in revenue in fiscal 2011.

[Courtesy: Thenewspaper.com]

#Government #Taxes #Traffic

The Newspaper

More by The Newspaper

Comments

Join the conversation

5 of 27 comments

Mtunofun on Oct 19, 2011

EZPass: lame Fastrak: booorrring Peach Pass: ADORABLE!!!!!

Like Reply
Krhodes1 on Oct 20, 2011

Call me a communist, but I have NO problem at all with toll roads. Users should pay directly for thier road use. Works out great for a state like Maine where a HUGE percentage of the traffic is from out of state. If you are a local you can get a commuter pass and pay a flat rate for three months between any two exits. I pay ~$30 every three months for unlimited use in the area that covers 95% of my turnpike use. Saves me a small fortune vs. the individual toll, but all those out-of-staters pay, pay, pay. Don't want to pay? Rt1 is free but I hope you have plenty of time to kill. Of course I am in favor of mileage-based road tax too.

Like Reply
- See 2 previous
- ElSnuggles on Oct 20, 2011
  
  That sounds like a great system you have up in Maine, but no toll road I've been near has ever worked like that. I spent 5 years in Orlando using their toll roads, and the discount for heavy usage they provided was about 5%. As a resident of the I85 corridor impacted by this, I want to clarify some things for my fellow TTAC'ers. First, it can be used as a 3 person HOV, but they make it very difficult. You have to log into the Peach Pass System no less than 15 minutes before your "arrival" and notify them that you have high occupancy. Talk about a system designed to screw people. Second - this isn't a toll added on new roads built under the system, as in Orlando, Houston, Dallas, etc. They took an existing lane that was in use, and converted it to charge people up to $8 for 15 miles (the governor claims that they have lowered the price now but I haven't seen any firm results). I85 was already a mess before the lane, and now they made it significantly worse. The concept is simple - removing a lane from general use, increase traffic. Duh. I know people whose commutes are 45 minutes longer each way as a result of the change. I had already avoided I85 because of the traffic and I've seen my commute lengthen because many other drivers are hunting alternate routes. I personally have no issue with new roads built and supported by tolls. I fully support it. Where I get pissed is taking existing roads and turning them into tolls (here, or what the Governor of Penn. has been trying to do for years) or create a toll road and making it inconvenient to use alternate routes so that people are forced to use the toll road (Austin in the early 2000's).
  
  Like
- Valkraider on Oct 20, 2011
  
  @ElSnuggles "I know people whose commutes are 45 minutes longer each way as a result of the change. " 45 minutes *longer*? Jebus man, they should move closer to work, or work closer to home. Or - if that makes too much sense - buy the pass and use the empty lane, then their commute might be *faster*. Anything longer than 30 minutes and I would just take transit - even if transit takes even longer. That way I could sleep, read, play games on my phone, or crack open the laptop and get work done. When driving a car you are held hostage to the steering wheel and brake pedal. (Not that needing to steer or brake stops anyone from doing that stuff while driving... People are crazy!) I would like to see *all* freeways turned into toll roads. In the USA we do not come anywhere near paying the full cost of building, maintaining, and using roads. People think they are "free" and "a right". If we had to pay the full costs of our driving, people would do much less of it. But that is just my *opinion* - people are free to disagree. :)
  
  Like
- Geozinger on Oct 20, 2011
  
  @valkraider: "they should move closer to work, or work closer to home..." Easier said than done. When I lived in metro Atlanta, the wave of population moving out into the surrounding suburbs and counties was impressive, I'm sure it remains the same today. One day, I have one of the first houses in a subdivision, (seemingly) the next day the whole subdivision is completed and the requisite shopping mall is being built, too. It's not like you can just pick up and leave the area your home is in, particularly if you own. It's one thing when you're a renter, but it's a different story if you're putting down roots. Or what happened to me. I went from a nice 20 min ride on the MARTA train to get to work to a 1.25 hr commute because the company moved locations. I didn't want to go from Henry County to Gwinnett county every day, but that's where my job was. It was a good paying job, with lots of benefits, too. Really hard to let that go when you have responsibilities beyond yourself. I eventually did leave for an even better job (ask me why I miss the 1990's), and through good luck it was on my side of town. Not everyone has that kind of choice...
  
  Like

Recent Comments

ToolGuy 9 miles a day for 20 years. You didn't drive it, why should I? 😉
Brian Uchida Laguna Seca, corkscrew, (drying track off in rental car prior to Superbike test session), at speed - turn 9 big Willow Springs racing a motorcycle,- at greater speed (but riding shotgun) - The Carrousel at Sears Point in a 1981 PA9 Osella 2 litre FIA racer with Eddie Lawson at the wheel! (apologies for not being brief!)
Mister It wasn't helped any by the horrible fuel economy for what it was... something like 22mpg city, iirc.
Lorenzo I shop for all-season tires that have good wet and dry pavement grip and use them year-round. Nothing works on black ice, and I stopped driving in snow long ago - I'll wait until the streets and highways are plowed, when all-seasons are good enough. After all, I don't live in Canada or deep in the snow zone.
FormerFF I’m in Atlanta. The summers go on in April and come off in October. I have a Cayman that stays on summer tires year round and gets driven on winter days when the temperature gets above 45 F and it’s dry, which is usually at least once a week.