Did The BlackBerry Outage Save Lives In the UAE And Elsewhere?
The “War On Distracted Driving”, like most of the other wars in which the United States has participated in the past forty years, appears to be a rather muddled way of addressing an improperly defined problem. For the Ray LaHoods of the world, it has to be absolutely maddening that the “epidemic” of distracted driving has yet to lead to any sort of measurable decrease in road safety.
For them, I have some good news. While the plural of “anecdote” is never “data”, it would appear that a BlackBerry outage may have gained a crucial hill in the “War On Distracted Driving”. The problem: as usual, the hill is overseas somewhere.
The Arabian online paper The National reported over the weekend that, during last week’s European and Middle Eastern BlackBerry outage, drivers in Dubai and Abu Dhabi failed to run into each other with their usual vigor:
In Dubai, traffic accidents fell 20 per cent from average rates on the days BlackBerry users were unable to use its messaging service. In Abu Dhabi, the number of accidents this week fell 40 per cent and there were no fatal accidents.
On average there is a traffic accident every three minutes in Dubai, while in Abu Dhabi there is a fatal accident every two days.
Lt Gen Dahi Khalfan Tamim, the chief of Dubai Police, and Brig Gen Hussein Al Harethi, the director of the Abu Dhabi Police traffic department, linked the drop in accidents to the disruption of BlackBerry services between Tuesday and Thursday
Police around the world are notorious for saying whatever stupid, unproveable thing comes into their minds — in one famous case a few decades ago, a policeman estimated that a 4.5-liter US-spec Porsche 928 was doing “about 200mph” at the time of an accident — but in this case there may well be correlation between the service outage and an interruption in on-road fatalities. It’s already illegal to use a BlackBerry on the move in the Emirates, so there won’t be any new legislation as a result of these figures. Nor is it certain that there is any correlation between Arab text-and-crash accidents and conditions in North America. The cultures are very different, as made plain by the top comment on the National’s article:
police say, BlackBerry cuts made roads safer. The Headline Begs for Tough Fines (3000Dhs) for anyone using mobile phones while driving. If god had intended for you to drive and use a mobile communication Device, like a spider he would have given you 8 eyes.
More by Jack Baruth
Latest Car Reviews
Read moreLatest Product Reviews
Read moreRecent Comments
- Rochester I'd rather have a slow-as-mud Plymouth Prowler than this thing. At least the Prowler looked cool.
- Kcflyer Don't understand the appeal of this engine combo at all.
- Dave M. This and the HHR were GM's "retro" failures. Not sure what they were smoking....
- Kcflyer Sorry to see it go. The interior design and color options in particular are rare in the industry
- Wolfwagen Here is my stable. not great not bad I try to do as much as possible. I work for an Aftermarket automotive parts company so I can get most parts at a discount.i try to do as much of my own work as possible. My wife hates that I spend time and money fixing the vehicles but she doesn't want car payments either so...2019 VW Atlas 50K (wife's) Only issues so far were Brakes and normal maintenance.A Bad Cat Converter which was covered and a replacement of the rear bank head gasket which was a manufacturing defect due to improper torquing at the factory. All under warranty2003 Saab 9-5 Arc Wagon (my DD) 116 K picked up used last year. Replaced Struts, brakes, hatch struts, motor mounts, D/S swaybar link, Timing belt, water pump and thermostat Power steering pump Fuel pump, Both Front window regular rollers, Heater core and cabin air filter. Oil and transmission changes. Love the car but Saab/GM packaging is a nightmare.2005 Cadillac Deville (former DD now Son # 1 DD) picked up used 5 years ago with only 47K now 83K Plugs, coils, P/s pump, Water pump, hoses, P/S lines (mechanic job) evap valve, brakes, Front brake calipers and rear brake calipers. Currently has oil pan gasket leak - looking to have a mechanic do that2009 Mini Cooper (Daughters dd)picked up 2 years ago 67K Brakes and thermostat house to clear check engine light2001 Mazda Tribue (Son#2 dd) 106K picked last summer after he severely damaged a 2004 Hyundai accent. Oil changes
Comments
Join the conversation
Always have been and always will be for some type of a car/phone interlock. If your phone is turned on your car wont start
Lucky you people your only concern are texting drivers. In my country it's cheap motorcycles and scooters from China that the dumb masses here can now afford. They weave in and out of traffic without regard for anyone. Even the toddlers and babies and wives i.e. entire families, they carry with them. Most don't have helmets on.