How Accurate Are Auto Sales Estimates? TTAC Grades The Analysts

Edward Niedermeyer
by Edward Niedermeyer

Every month, Bloomberg publishes monthly auto sales estimates from the leading analysts… and as this month’s survey proves, they’re all over the place. With SAAR estimates running from 11.4m units to 12.1m units, and with Ford’s growth estimates ranging from 4.2% to 11%, it’s clear that we will have some winners and losers from the bunch. In short, the analyst community needs a little truth injection… which, of course, is where TTAC comes in. This month, and every month in the future, TTAC will be grading analysts on the accuracy of their forecasts. By comparing analyses from month to month, we hope to build a case for which analysts are the most consistently accurate. Industry analysts beware: TTAC has put you on notice!


Edward Niedermeyer
Edward Niedermeyer

More by Edward Niedermeyer

Comments
Join the conversation
 4 comments
  • SPPPP SPPPP on Aug 02, 2011

    The largest deviation from the average is only 4.2%. I consider that close enough.

  • Ron Ron on Aug 02, 2011

    Analysts don't pick their estimates out of their ass -- they receive "guidance" from the manufacturers. It is pointless to call up a handful of dealers when there are thousands. The differences largely reflect when they call (the later the better), whom they speak with, how much the contact likes the analyst (you can count on receiving misinformation if you have a sell rating on the company), etc.

  • Brantta Brantta on Aug 02, 2011

    Manufacturer....Estimate.....July 2011......Retail GM.......................7%...................8%.............6% Ford...................7.8%..................9%..........didn't report Chrysler.............15%.................20%...........33%

  • Mike978 Mike978 on Aug 02, 2011

    Great idea, since it is easy for analysts to make predictions and never get called out if they are consistently wrong. I would like to see the actual figure added to the chart so it is easier to see who is right and wrong (comparing to an average doesn`t help since how close they are to the actual number is what counts, not close to each other).

Next