Group Finds Toll Roads Not in Public Interest

The Newspaper
by The Newspaper

The left-leaning US Public Interest Research Group (US PIRG) has issued a report entitled “ Private Roads, Public Costs” that questions the benefits of using private tolls to construct or maintain roads. The report examined all fifteen completed road privatization projects in the US along with 79 known proposals nationwide. “Though these privatization deals seem to offer state officials a ‘quick fix,’ they often pose long-term threats to the public interest,” the report found. “The economics of these deals are such that the upfront concession payments are unlikely to match the long-term value of the higher tolls that will be paid by future generations and not collected for public uses.”

The report cited the specific example of how Cintra-Macquarie, a private Spanish-Australian consortium, paid Indiana officials $3.8 billion to take control of the Indiana Toll Road. Officials used this windfall to finance a ten-year transportation plan. Although Macquarie told private investors that it would recoup the $3.8 billion in just fifteen years, the public will be paying the tolls for a full 75 years. This illustrates that the short-term benefits of the tolling route can be irresistible to politicians who are not likely to be in office a decade after the deal is struck.

“Whatever structural budget shortfalls Indiana faced before the deal will return in the 11th year, but the state will need to face these shortfalls without revenue from its toll road,” the report explained. “Potential investors claim that by outsourcing toll collection to a private company, drivers’ anger will not be directed at the politicians who authorized the toll hikes.”

The report found that the tolling concept necessarily dilutes public control over transportation policy because the decision to impose tolls on certain roads leads to spill-over traffic on neighborhood side streets as drivers seek free alternatives. Non-compete clauses in tolling contracts further bind the ability of local officials to take action to meet the needs of the public. That need is impossible to foresee over the course of deals that have the force of law for up to 99 years.

US PIRG does not oppose all privatization with respect to transportation.

“When it comes to the question of public versus private provision of government services, it is a matter of where best to draw the line,” the report stated.

To that end, the report offered a number of recommendations to address the major problems in privatization agreements concerning newly constructed roads. It found that all deals should be limited to no more than thirty years, that the public should receive the fair value from all future toll collections, the full details of all contracts should be made open to public comment before approval, and an elected legislature must approve and be held accountable for all tolling decisions.

The Newspaper
The Newspaper

More by The Newspaper

Comments
Join the conversation
2 of 23 comments
  • John B John B on Apr 17, 2009

    As much as I curse the bandits who own and run Highway 407 around Toronto, I must admit the ever increasing tolls (about 20 cents/km) keep traffic at reasonable levels. I routinely travel the 30 km commute across Toronto in less than 20 minutes in rush hour, winter included. Still, when I get that $200 monthly bill ..

  • Tedward Tedward on Apr 17, 2009

    IC Turbo Good point...I don't know of one between Buffalo and Albany (and I did a year at SUNY Buffalo with a home base near Albany). They have been spending good money on the parkways further south though, as an alternative to widening the toll roads further. The secret to getting a toll free parkway in your area is apparently to run it through your most affluent suburb. In NY's case that'd be westchester county. All the movers live right on the saw mill or taconic pkwy's and boy are they never going to have a toll booth installed. The trade off used to be local financing of repairs, but of course that's no longer the case. So there's an obvious solution; forcibly emigrate affluent suburbanites into prepared communities at least 20 miles off of the existing toll road infrastructure (you may want to scatter them in little clumps). It's too far for convenient access and besides, waiting for toll booths is for other people. Before you know it the local windy road will ditch it's lights and become a driving paradise. If you don't have such a road don't worry, one will be built in short order. No need to thank me.

  • MaintenanceCosts It's not a Benz or a Jag / it's a 5-0 with a rag /And I don't wanna brag / but I could never be stag
  • 3-On-The-Tree Son has a 2016 Mustang GT 5.0 and I have a 2009 C6 Corvette LS3 6spd. And on paper they are pretty close.
  • 3-On-The-Tree Same as the Land Cruiser, emissions. I have a 1985 FJ60 Land Cruiser and it’s a beast off-roading.
  • CanadaCraig I would like for this anniversary special to be a bare-bones Plain-Jane model offered in Dynasty Green and Vintage Burgundy.
  • ToolGuy Ford is good at drifting all right... 😉
Next