By on March 7, 2010

In the TTAC Pedal Series “Toyota Gas Pedal Fix Simulated: Friction Reduced, But By Too Much”, I anticipated that the crude shim fix for the recalled CTS “sticky pedals” would result in an uncomfortable pedal feel at the least and  quite possibly unsafe characteristics at worst. A quick refresher: a carefully controlled degree of friction (hysteresis) is essential in an e-pedal, otherwise smooth changes and maintaining steady states in throttle position become difficult if not impossible. I wrote: “Undoubtedly, Toyota’s intended degree of friction will be compromised by this fix, to one degree or another. And drivers may find the fix unpleasant or uncomfortable, also to some degree or another. Clearly, this fix is a band aid to fix the intrinsic limitations of this design.”

I’ve been counting the days until someone complained about the results of the pedal fix. Yesterday it came, from TTAC reader JAQUEBAUER:

My daughter took her 2009 Camry in to the dealer today for the Gas Pedal recall, and were very surprised and disjointedness with the “fix” that Toyota has chosen for this problem. We picked the car up, getting the keys and a copy of the repair order from the cashier. We were not told about any precautions to take or be aware of changes in the operation of the car. The Repair order indicated that the cars computer was reprogrammed, and some work was done on the gas pedal. I asked her to test drive the car in the dealers parking lot before she went home, to check for any problems.

There were 2 issues she found unacceptable, that I want to talk about here. (Read More…)

Recent Comments

  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    brn - Yes! Toyota really was (or should have been anyway) trying to do with the FR-S what they did with the Celica. Take advantage of the established name recognition.
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    frozenman - If its not as quick as your Mom’s Accord v6 your man-card takes a hit, not really fair but there you go. No roadster version to compete with MX-5...
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    brn - I wonder if the hype actually hurt long term sales. Automotive enthusiasts (especially journalists) have a tendency to overhype something that they thought the...
  • Re: Chart Of The Day: Auto Brand Market Share In The United Kingdom In 2014

    Pch101 - Who needs light bulbs when we have beer? Or something like that.
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    krhodes1 - A sale is a sale. This is not the 90s when the Detroit Big 3 owned the rental big 3 and they truly were a dumping ground. Camaros, Mustangs, and...
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    Pch101 - This car was not particularly designed with the US in mind. It was made primarily for Japan, which has costly fuel and displacement taxes that rise above the...
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    Turbo Is Black Magic - I came close to buying a BRZ but after extended test drives and driving a friends FR-S a lot, I realized the weak engine would drive me crazy....
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    kovakp - “The U.S. market, long in need of an affordable, compact, rear-wheel-drive sports car…” Joking, yes?
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    krhodes1 - There is very little wrong with this car that a turbo and a Toyota badge won’t fix. It doesn’t need more hp per se, because it is NOT a slow...
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    Hummer - This is like comparing apples to oranges, but I already did the math and it can’t be undone. The Ram 1500, 2 door, 5.7l has a better HP to weight ratio...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Staff

  • Contributing Writers

  • Jack Baruth, United States
  • Brendan McAleer, Canada
  • Marcelo De Vasconcellos, Brazil
  • Vojta Dobes, Czech Republic
  • Matthias Gasnier, Australia
  • W. Christian 'Mental' Ward, Abu Dhabi
  • Mark Stevenson, Canada
  • Cameron Aubernon, United States
  • J Emerson, United States