By Robert Farago on April 17, 2008

yamaha_majesty_400_abs_1.jpgWhile it seems perfectly natural to assume that clicks on cars reveal trends down at the showroom, I'm not entirely convinced. For example, Autoblog's post on GayWheels top ten researched vehicles would have you believe that a large number of Dodge Caliber buyers are that way inclined. So when the National Automobile Dealers Association (NADA) put out a press release claiming "interest in motorcycles increases as commuters seek two-wheel alternatives" based on their website's traffic, I was interested to see if they mentioned any "real world" impact. To their credit, they did, right from the git-go. "Motorcycle buying interest at NADAguides.com increased 48 percent in March 2008 compared to March 2007, even though sales of motorcycles were down over seven percent at the end of 2007, with NADAguides.com estimating sluggish sales so far this year." And yet, motorcycle ed Lenny Sims is ready to climb out on that limb. "We believe the current state of the economy, coupled with recent summer fuel price predictions, has caused consumer mindset about motorcycles to shift. In our opinion, motorcycles have become attractive options as primary vehicles for daily drivers — due to their fuel efficiency — and are no longer considered just a luxury, 'secondary-vehicle' purchase." Your take?

82 Comments on “Rising Gas Prices: Four Wheels Bad, Two Wheels Good?...”


  • detroit1701
    detroit1701

    High insurance / death rates do not outweigh rising fuel costs, at least for me.

  • thalter
    thalter

    They may be viable in the southwest where it rarely rains and never snows, but up here in the north motorcycles will largely remain recreational vehicles.

  • Edward Niedermeyer

    Mmmm, high death rates.

    My next car will definitely be a motorcycle.

    Sorry Dad!

  • jaje
    jaje

    If large cities pass laws to allow motorcycles to drive between cars at red lights to get ahead of the pack you’ll see a bigger swing.

  • jrlombard
    jrlombard

    You guys are unbelievable.

    High insurance is fixed by buying something smaller than 1000cc’s. If you’re new to riding, you might not want one of those anyway. A nice Kawasaki KLR650 (perfect for commuting!) would run you all of about $10/mo.

    Death rates. Yeah, well. How do you argue that. It’s a vehicle with no protection other than it’s rider’s “sixth sense”.

    Here in CA (yes, I know, I know, but it’s Northern CA) real motorcyclists ride rain or shine. I’ve done many commutes in the rain, have a suit just for that, and often see other motorcyclists. I will grant you that snow is another issue altogether–one that we don’t face here.

    Oh, and yes- lane sharing is legal here in CA. Even at stoplights.

  • dean
    dean

    As a motorcyclist, I’ve seen this debated on cycle-centric forums before. Unless you buy a beater bike for next to nothing, or get rid of/de-insure your car altogether, the economics usually do not support the use of a motorcycle to save money.

    Do it for love, baby!

  • crackers
    crackers

    detroit1701 nailed it. The only thing I would add is that motorcycles are not practical as daily drivers in northern climates. You have to be real hardcore to drive a motorcycle between October and May here in Ontario.

  • AGR
    AGR

    The majority of motorcycle sales in North America are big bore cruisers which are primarily used as recreational “toys” in most instances.

    Scooter sales seem to have peaked, especially that in many areas a 50cc scooter does not have enough speed to stay with the flow of traffic.

    Sport bikes are challenging to insure for many people.

    Will motorcycles cross from recreational to transportation? People that ride bikes are aware that many motorists have little to no respect for the individual on a bike. Which raises the element of danger in a transportation application.

  • eh_political
    eh_political

    I have had a bike since the age of 10. Would never even consider using one on the road. Too many variables (by which I mean idiots) beyond my control. Every incident is a potential catastrophe.

    It’s tempting though. Lane splitting, gliding effortlessly through city traffic, squirting away at stoplights, slashing commute times, and so forth.

    But again, with Mary Clearasil talking on her cell about her evening out, or Joe sixpack living up to his name, it’s only a matter of time before all of the time saved is spent in a hospital bed, or a special line at the airport where all of your metal screws single you out for special attention.

  • Matthew Danda
    Matthew Danda

    I really tried to convert to a motorcycle. However, it becomes are real pain to don the armored riding suit (an absolute necessity when you commute) every freakin time you need to go somewhere, and there is the nagging paranoia all day long that someone is messing with your bike when it is parked and you’re away. I finally gave up riding when I started saying after every ride, “Thank god I didn’t wreck this time.” No thanks.

  • David Holzman

    Do your average motorcycles do any better than a Prius in MPG?

    I have no desire to ride a donorcycle for the obvious reasons. When I was in my 20s and early 30s, I did almost all of my transportation on a bicycle, right through Wash. DC winters. I could imagine doing some of that again if gas prices got about 50% higher, although nowhere near to the degree I did it before. (Bicycles are far safer than donorcycles, in large part because they just don’t go very fast (I’m a journalist, the first article I ever published was on bicycle safety, and I wrote it because I wanted to know what to do to keep myself safe)).

    Worse than death is the prospect of traumatic brain injury or spinal injury. There are probably lots of those for every death on motorcycles.

  • KixStart
    KixStart

    Most motorcycles don’t get particularly good fuel economy… not better than a Prius, anyway. Some 200’s and scooters do better but nobody I know rides anything like that.

    Factor in the safety and the probable need to keep a car, anyway, extra insurance, registration, etc, buying one for commuting probably doesn’t pay off. If it’s part of your “recreation” budget, anyway, that’s another matter.

    What’s the probable life, in miles, of a motorcyle? I thought it was significantly less than that of a car. And the last I knew motorcycle maintenance was fairly pricey.

    My two-wheeled alternative is a bicycle but I have a commute that makes it a reasonably practical alternative. And I use the car when the weather is bad or circumstances otherwise dictate. Low purchase price, easy to store, no additional insurance or registration, operating costs are low (every few years, it needs new tires, 2 @ $20 each) and it runs on almost any kind of carbohydrate, including E-5 – beer!

  • Martin Schwoerer
    Martin Schwoerer

    I drive my 125cc Vespa on a daily basis in my big-city home. Nothing beats it in terms of speed, ease of parking, low tax and insurance, and for general stimulation of the mind.

    (Of course, I live in a free country where sidewalk parking is OK).

    Generally, I find it safer than bicyling, since I can keep up with traffic. A few years ago I slipped on a wet road when somebody backed out of a parking space without looking and subsequently had a grotesquely enlarged, purple right thigh and buttocks for six weeks. Since then, I’ve have had the words “drive carefully, you idiot!” tatooed on my brain.

  • USAFMech
    USAFMech

    I rode a Suzuki Intruder 700 for 12 months in Illinois. No heated gear, no radio, not even a windscreen. There’s no such thing as bad weather; just wrong attire. And scooters are like chubby girls….

    If I babied it I got 45mpg. If I rode it like I stole it I got 43mpg. If only I could find a nice diesel bike and talk my wife into owning two.

  • AKM
    AKM

    Riding a bike just scares the hell out of me. I commute 20 miles, so a bicycle is out of the option, esp. since it’s mostly highways, but if I move back to Europe, I’m likely to commute on a bike (and save gym time while doing so!) if the city has good bike lanes (i.e. safe ones).

  • limmin
    limmin

    A motorcycle isn’t inherently dangerous. It’s the cars around a bike that cause the danger. A motorcyclist is massively outnumbered by cell-phone chattering dimwits in SUVs.

    I don’t know any motorcycle accident stats. I do know that any motorcycle accident is FAR more likely to cause brain/spinal trauma or death than a typical car crash. Even a minor wipeout can cause maiming if the biker lacks his leather Batman gear.

    An SUV can hit a Yaris at congested urban speeds (25mph) and chances are, the Yaris guy will walk away–fuming but unhurt. That SUV hits a motorcyclist and they’ll be scooping that guy off the pavement.

  • schempe
    schempe

    Most bikes get excellent gas mileage. I ride a Harley softail with a evolution motor and get around 42 mpg with city commutes and nearly 60 mpg in some instances on the highway. Now a evolution motor is not small motor by any means 1340 ccs. It’s not the bike you have or the motor it’s how you ride it. I don’t ride my motorcycle for good gas mileage but I think more people are looking at them as an alternative. Yes, if you ride it like you stole it then don’t expect great gas mileage.

  • menno
    menno

    Not only would I never climb over a donorcycle again, I actually sold my collector car and bought a pop-up camper new, instead.

    I got tired of absolute moron cell phone users and other sub-moronic imbeciles who happened to be behind the wheel of a deadly projectile (aka automobile, pickumup truck or stupid utility vehicle) paying absolutely no attention while I was trying to stay safe in my 1962 Corvair convertible (I know, I know, it’s supposedly an oxymoron to try to stay safe in a Corvair convertible).

    After seeing typical (and I use that word in the most sarcastic manner you can imagine) driving habits deteriorate over the last 10 years especially, I finally decided I valued my life much more than having a classic car.

    Too many damn fools don’t understand the actual concept of what stop signs mean here in Michigan and simply blow through them, turning in front of you.

    You haven’t lived (deep sarcasm) until you’ve either been on a motorcycle riding around here, or been in a Corvair Convertible with swing-axles, no roll bar, 9″ drum brakes, no collapsable steering column (except your sternum, of course) to find that imbecile #947 has just pulled right in front of you from a side road while you’re cruising at 50.

  • Robert Schwartz
    Robert Schwartz

    “If I babied it I got 45mpg. If I rode it like I stole it I got 43mpg.”

    “I ride a Harley softail with a evolution motor and get around 42 mpg with city commutes and nearly 60 mpg in some instances on the highway.”

    Not good enough. Everything considered, especially here in the mid-west where the climate is seldom salubrious, a B class car like the Fit or Yaris will be cheaper than a 2 wheeler.

  • JuniperBug
    JuniperBug

    Regarding fuel economy: my ‘89 Ninja 600 could pull off low to mid 50 MPG in mixed riding with a passenger and some spirited bursts. That’s 20 year old tech in a package that could outrun a Corvette in the quarter mile. Smaller bikes get better mileage; guys with Ninja 250’s claim mid-60’s or better and still have a top end north of 100 MPH.

    The problem is that a lot of the money saved in gas gets spent on tires. Even a “sport-touring” compound will often wear out in 10k miles. And don’t think that because there’s only two of them that they’re cheaper than car tires to replace.

    Also, the vast majority of motorcycles don’t have nearly the fuel and emissions controls that cars do (no cat and either carburated or open loop FI)- they’re freaking dirty. If I warmed up my bike in the garage (doors open), it used to set off the fire alarm.

    Financially and environmentally, I don’t think there’s much in riding a bike. Then again, life’s not only about money and saving the world.

  • jerseydevil
    jerseydevil

    I wish we had a culture that allowed two wheeled vehicles such as motorbikes and bicycles to be ridden safely. We do not. I will not ride my bicycle on a public raod, even tho I’d love to. I commute at an average speed of about 20 mph to work each day, i can ride my bike comfortably ar about 15 mph. I’d get a good work out, probably not need the gym membershp any more either.

    Not to mention motor driven two wheelers. I suppose we in the states do not live in that world. dammit

  • afuller
    afuller

    I’m sorry but I see a lot of uninformed opinions in these responses. On the large motor engine of the spectrum I had a Yamaha Road Star Warrior, 1700cc, that I averaged 55mpg on. I now have a DL1000 Suzuki that gets a little worse mileage but I’m still around 45mpg average. I also have a Honda Reflex 250cc scooter that will keep up with highway traffic on my commute that gets an average of 70mpg with my large self on it, I imagine if I were a normal size person I could do a lot better.

    From the forums I look at the large, expensive bikes are taking a hit in sales but the smaller, more fuel efficient bikes are getting a lot more interest. The new for 2008 Kawasaki Ninja 250 is getting a lot of interest for $3499 and riders are claiming 80mpg by dropping a tooth on the rear sprocket. In addition perhaps if more people would get out and ride motorcyclists would have a better chance of not getting punted into a roadside ditch by inattentive cagers as there would be more educated folks on the road.

    So yes, there are many choices out there that get better mileage than a Prius for much less money and they’re not as ugly and uninspiring as a Yaris.

  • alex_rashev
    alex_rashev

    I used to ride rain or snow. Insurance costs me a bunch ($500 a year, almost as much as my car), but I get 65mpg and the bike cost me $3200 new. Plus, it’s easy to park, cheap to service, and I’m having way more fun.

    Too bad my commute now is a 5-minute walk. That’s your ultimate gas savings solution. I spend less than $30 on gas each month right now.

  • jthorner
    jthorner

    I’ve already seen several Smart cars on the roads around here. Honda Fits are all over the place. The Prius is one of the most common cars on the road.

    People in N. California are definitely buying fuel efficient vehicles, but they are going to continue buying four wheeled ones.

    The great news is that little by little visibility on the roads in improving as more and more of the monster trucks and SUVs get parked during the week and are being used as special occasion vehicles while small cars are the commuters.

  • TexasAg03
    TexasAg03

    My problem is my wife doesn’t want me to tie the kids on to the back of the bike. Something about safety…

    That’s my real problem though; no place for the kiddos. I pick them up and take them to school/daycare occasionally so two wheels is not an option.

  • iNeon
    iNeon

    Tex: Sidecar :)

    That’s all I have to say about that.

  • crc
    crc

    I have a 30 mile roundtrip commute to work that is done on my bicycle once western NY temps become reasonable. There is no better way to become a defensive driver than to get on two wheels.

  • radimus
    radimus

    If you want a better chance of getting noticed on a motorcycle install a headlight oscillator. I read a few comments by riders who likened the differnce between riding without one and with one to be like wondering if anyone sees you to feeling like you’re the lead escort of a nudist parade. I’ve seen bikers with headlight oscillators on the road a few times. It actually takes effort to ignore one of these riders, especially if he is in your rearview.

  • Guzzi
    Guzzi

    Motorcycling: you either get it, or you don’t. And if you don’t get it, you are typically prejudiced/misinformed. It still amazes me how strongly and negatively people in the U.S. react to motorcyling. But it’s my choice, and it has practically no impact on you. Why do you care what I do?

    Casual motorcycling is becoming more of a luxury in this recession. Lots of chrome is for sale on CL these days. But the sub-$3000 bikes go in hours in my experience. Commuting? I have noticed more scooters in urban areas lately, but no more motorcycles than usual. A new uber scooter, with ABS, is not a money-saving move. Factor in gas savings + and extra monthly payment, and you’re probably coming out behind. I do it because I love motorbikes. It’s my overriding passion.

  • cjdumm
    cjdumm

    I was a 3-season rider in Colorado in the days before electrically heated suits were common, and then a year-round motorcycle commuter in San Diego.

    Maybe I lost my youthful delusions of immortality, or maybe I’m just a coward these days, but I have no desire to ride a motorcycle in traffic ever again in my life.

    If they develop a motorcyclist airbag suit that inflates milliseconds before impact, turning me into the Michelin Man, or a human beach ball, I’d probably ride again.

  • Landcrusher
    Landcrusher

    If you enjoy it, go for it.

    There is a reason the lower end bikes are the ones selling though. It takes a LOT of miles to make the math work on an expensive bike. Once you do the math, you figure out the real cost of owning a car is depreciation and insurance. Gas is still cheaper than water.

  • drooartz

    Making a clear financial case for motorcycles as cheap transport is very dependent on your commute. 1970s Honda 90s could get 100 mpg+, but top out at maybe 40 mph. (If I could avoid the freeway on my commute, I’d ride one for 3 seasons here in the Utah mountains). Small bore scooters are similar. Some modern 250s can do in the 60-70 mpg range. Savings in fuel cost over, say, a Honda Fit are present but not as high as you might think. (The increase in mpg from 15 to 20 saves more money than 40 to 45).

    I’ve been a rider for 10+ years, and will continue to ride until I am too old to do so. It is a real passion for me. I understand the inherent risks, and they are acceptable to me. I don’t expect everyone to feel that way. Bikes have lots of intangible benefits as well, but again you have to be the sort of person for whom those work. I’d love to see more riders on the road, as it would increase our visibility to the general motoring public.

    Having ridden both bicycles and motorcycles on the road, I feel far safer on a motorcycle — being able to keep up with traffic is a real benefit.

  • Facebook User

    Recreational second vehicle, the real numbers (sales) bear it out.

  • schempe
    schempe

    @ Robert Schwartz

    Total cost of ownership is hard to argue. While the initial cost of a Harley may be more than other bikes I would rate its dependability right up with any vehicle mfg. Insurance is cheaper, parts are easy to get especially with a dealer network that’s always open on Saturdays in most also on Sunday’s as well. Maintenence is easy and repairs are far less complex than any car built in the last decade. To top it off my Harley won’t depreciate like that Yaris.

  • KixStart
    KixStart

    Yesterday, on the way home, Suzie Sellfoan blew through a red light as I watched. Yep, she was yakking on the phone. For someone on the cross-street, her approach would have been masked by a line of cars. Had anyone else been traveling through the intersection from the cross street, their first clue could have been when they were struck from the side at 40-45mph.

    I “get” motorcycling. I’ve owned two and I really enjoyed it but they’re long gone, I have other sources of fun, instead. Some choose to keep riding… that’s OK for them.

    But I don’t think it matters how good your defensive driving skills are, there’s always the risk of some unhappy situation that you didn’t see or anticipate. In a car, you’ve got a much better chance of surviving the resulting accident. On foot or on a bicycle, at least your own speed is low, which takes some of the potential force out of any collision (and a foot/bike path is an option).

    Motorcycle to save a few bucks on gas? Not worth it.

  • Sanman111
    Sanman111

    I have to say that Vespas and other scooters seem to be becoming more popular in the Southeast. A friend of mine bought one to go to work everyday and got rid of her car (they share her husband’s car if they need to). It seems to work well in the local downtown area where we live. Personally, I stick to my bike or my two feet most of the time (I live two blocks from work).

  • kph
    kph

    Motorcycles work well in certain places. Unfortunately none of them are in America. These places are more like urban areas of India or Taiwan.

    If everybody rode a motorcycle, safety wouldn’t be as much of an issue. Not only is there less mass involved in the accident, but everyone is more careful because a) everyone is exposed / unprotected and b) no one can talk on a cell phone, drink a coffee, or smoke a cigarette while riding. Restrict riding to the cities and vehicles are generally moving slower as well.

    The benefits are cheaper costs for the bike as well as for fuel consumption. Disadvantage is everyone ends up riding without any regard to traffic rules.

  • hwyhobo
    hwyhobo

    @jpc0067: Motorcycling: you either get it, or you don’t. And if you don’t get it, you are typically prejudiced/misinformed. It still amazes me how strongly and negatively people in the U.S. react to motorcyling. But it’s my choice, and it has practically no impact on you. Why do you care what I do?

    I noticed many people saying it is not for them, but no one criticizing others for riding a bike, so I am not sure what you are talking about? Are you building a strawman for some further argument?

    And for why not many folks in my area commute on bikes, here are my reasons:

    1. Have you tried to wear that leather batman outfit over a suit when going to work?

    2. No economic justification (additional insurance – no one will REPLACE their car, just add to it), additional wear, tear, maintenance, and funny outfits

    3. Little fuel efficiency gain over available four-wheeled solutions (like Prius, Civic Hybrid, etc)

    4. Weather

    5. Accident impact on your health and life

    6. Likely worse than an automobile environmental impact

    In fact, the only reason for riding a bike would be the use of carpool lanes, stolen from taxpayers in the first place and arbitrarily given away to moms and their babies riding in an Expedition, and to the very politicians in limos (2 people in a vehicle, right?), while Joe the working Stiff in his car is stuck in traffic jams caused by effectively closing down a lane in the most needed areas on the freeway.

    As much as I would like the last privilege, I cannot justify the first 6 factors.

  • jolo
    jolo

    You want to make motorcycles more acceptable in this country? Mandate that those who get their driver’s license HAVE to only ride a motorcycle for the first two years before they are allowed to drive a car. People will be more alert to bikes once they are in a car because the average MC rider pays better attention to their surroundings than those in a car who have never ridden on a bike.

    Sure, there will be lots of injuries and deaths (the Darwin factor) the first decade or so, but in the grand scheme of things, there would be better car drivers on the road once they have to learn how to properly drive.

  • schempe
    schempe

    @hwyhobo

    I wouldn’t swear to it but, I think you just proved jpc0067’s point. I ride for enjoyment and the experience as most riders will tell you. I don’t ride to save a few $$ on gas. It’s simply another toy in the stable that I enjoy.

  • Landcrusher
    Landcrusher

    hwyhobo,

    If you ever owned a motorcycle, you would know about the attitudes you catch from people who think you are a crazy mad man for riding. It’s gotten a bit better since arley made a comeback.

    I like your bit on the commuter lanes. Amen.

    I was curious about your item number 6. How does a motorcycle have worse impact than a car?

  • dean
    dean

    KixStart makes a great point. People that ride motorcycles are usually people who enjoy riding enough that they can balance the risk with their personal reward. I think it is highly unlikely that someone who has never dreamed of riding will decide to do so simply for the purpose of fuel savings.

    On the other hand, many who have wanted to buy a motorcycle but couldn’t justify it to the significant other may now have some ammunition!

    As for insurance, claiming you can insure a KLR650 for only $10 a month is fine for you, but won’t apply to everyone. My 7 year old 600 sportbike will cost me about $550 to insure for half a year. That is with liability only — no collision, no theft, no fire. For that reason I only insure the bike for the 6-7 months when the weather is good here.

  • Phil Ressler
    Phil Ressler

    Robert,

    Can you take time to research historical data? What happened to motorcycle sales after the Iranian oil embargo in Spring 1979 through the previous real dollars fuel price peak in 1981? I recall then that media reports trumpeted a similar spike in motorcycle interest (though we didn’t have web clicks to gauge it), but that real world increase in motorcycle adoption for routine transportation was merely incidental and any bump failed to persist. Although for other reasons entirely, the recreational bike sector, including trail, grew throughout the 1980s/90s.

    The brief time I’ve spent on motorcycles has been seductive and thrilling. But I’ve had four friends killed on motorcycles, and that doesn’t count mere acquaintances lost. In all those cases, death came in an instant by a blindside assault from a car, truck or bus. No other single cause of death has taken that many people from my personal network so far. Not cancer, heart disease or crime.

    I’ll stick to my continuing series of convertibles.

    Phil

  • bunkie
    bunkie

    I’m a life-long motorcyclist. I’ve commuted on two wheels in Boston, New York City and Columbus Ohio.

    First off, in my opinion, anyone who tosses out the term “donorcycles” has too much bias to be taken seriously. It’s one of those terms that immediately puts me on the defensive. Yes, there are a lot of under-skilled riders who get killed, but I firmly believe that a smart rider can drastically reduce the odds. Blind intersection? Idiot running a red light? ALL of these sorts of situations are not only avoidable, they are reliably predictable. Knowing that, the smart rider adjusts, planning for the worst case in every scenario.

    There is absolutely no doubt that my many miles on two wheels have made me a much safer rider and driver. I approach riding as if I were getting into a fighter plane: the concentration level goes up and I get “on my game” in a hyper-alert (by car standards) state. For me, it’s fun. I really enjoy it.

    Weather? As was said, it just means that you don’t have the right gear.

    The only place where I’ve actually been frightened was on the Garden State Parkway. I don’t ride on that road any more. Way too many people drive like idiots and with five lanes, they can come from anywhere.

    Cars? I love them. But anyone can drive a car these days. It takes dedication and skill to stay alive and unhurt on a bike. Those of us who aspire to this have something that car drivers don’t.

  • JTSParts

    I started riding offroad at the age of 13. When I could ride on the road it seemed like a natural progression to me. I often said that my bike handling skills from all the years of motocross put me way ahead of the average street rider. In the early 90’s I only owned a bike, a Honda CB450t. Great bike by the way. I would bring home the groceries hanging on the bars.

    This article comes at an interesting time for me, i found myself in the local Vespa shop the other day. I was quite surprised to see the prices on most models north of $5k. I have been kicking around the idea of another bike. I have a 50 mile roundtrip commute so bicycles are not really an option. I sold my last bike, a Yamaha Royal Star about 6 years ago when my daughter was 2. Ultimately, as a single parent, I can’t justify the risk.

    Also I have not really ridden too much in this cell phone madness that exists today. I really think that phones and cars do not mix and that these hands free laws are really BS. Most people I see on the road have no business driving at all, let alone driving and talking.

    I would love to have another bike, but here in So California, I think there is too much risk.

  • David Holzman

    KixStart re his bicycle: and it runs on almost any kind of carbohydrate, including E-5 – beer!

    KixStart,

    I did that once, years ago, filled my water bottle with beer on a bicycle trip. Tasted so good, I got another. Then my muscles began to turn to rubber. Finally, facing a long uphill, I conked. Luckily, there was a museum right there, and luckily, I was only 21, so I metabolized the stuff pretty quickly and was able to go on after about 45 minutes.

  • Martin Albright
    Martin Albright

    Been riding for about 26 years now. I’m on bike no. 8, which is actually an old beater 750 I bought off CL last year for $800. Runs great!

    Over on the MC forums where I post, we often get people coming in right after gas prices spike. Sometimes they think they can save a lot of gas money by getting a bike, other times I get the impression that they’ve wanted a bike for years but haven’t been able to get the wife/parents to approve and so they’re trying to use the “but it will save me so much money!” argument as a pretext for getting the two wheeled toy they want.

    Thing is, by the time you crunch the numbers, it usually doesn’t save you a dime. As has already been pointed out, most of this country is not the kind of place where a motorcycle can replace a car, the best it can do is augment it, which means you’re still paying for a car, you just aren’t driving it as much. Then you have to factor in training, equipment and insurance.

    You also have to figure maintenance: My 3cyl Triumph required valve adjustments at 12k mile intervals, at a cost of ~$400. New chain and sprockets at 26k were about $500. Auto drivers used to getting 40,000 miles on a set of tires might be shocked to find that tires for a sportbike can be used up in as little as 4,000 miles – and that’s street miles, take it to the track and you can easily use up a tire less than 1,000 miles. Cost of a decent high performance tire can also top $200 per tire installed. Even on my relatively mild cruisers I’ve never gotten more than 14,000 miles out of a tire.

    As for the accident thing, you can either be obsessed with it or you can be aware and deal with it. In 26 years and roughly half a million miles of riding I’ve been in two accidents. Most motorcycle accidents are avoidable by the rider (even where they are someone else’s fault.) In any case, I’m not going to let fear keep me from doing something I love. At the end of the day, motorcyclists face the same fatality rate as Prius drivers: 1 person, 1 death, sooner or later.

    But the bottom line is that motorcycling is not really an economically viable way to get around high gas prices. A small, used econobox will save you much more money if that’s what you need to do. Motorcycles, like boats, are basically toys.

  • 240d
    240d

    3. Little fuel efficiency gain over available four-wheeled solutions (like Prius, Civic Hybrid, etc)

    I’d be curious as to how many readers of TTAC have traded in one car for a smaller, more economical car. The last I heard, everyone was towing boats to Moab.

  • David Holzman

    jpc0067 :
    Motorcycling: you either get it, or you don’t. And if you don’t get it, you are typically prejudiced/misinformed. It still amazes me how strongly and negatively people in the U.S. react to motorcyling. But it’s my choice, and it has practically no impact on you. Why do you care what I do?

    I suspect most of us on TTAC feel as I do. I like motorcycles, motorcyclists, I always wish them to be safe from cars in my head. It’s just a risk I am not going to take.

  • David Holzman

    bunkie :
    First off, in my opinion, anyone who tosses out the term “donorcycles” has too much bias to be taken seriously.

    This is what transplant surgeons call them.

    I can believe, as you say, that there are people who are alert and careful enough to stay safe most of the time on them. Probably not most of us, however, especially given all the distracted drivers now on the road.


Back to TopLeave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

You can also login using Facebook Connect. Connect with Facebook

Subscribe without commenting

Recent Comments

 


Auto Insurance GPS Navigation
Car Loans Auto Parts
Car Warranty Wheels
Automotive Tires Car Care