The Truth About Cars » Between the Lines

Between The Lines: Automotive News’ “The Cost of GM’s Death”

Robert Farago — Fri, 14 Nov 2008 18:29:17 +0000

I can't remember the last time Automotive News [sub] unleashed an email alert for an editorial. Hell, I can't remember the first time they did it. As in this is it: the first time. You see how stunned I am? Well, no prizes for guessing which side of the bailout issue Crain's boys fall. They unleash the argument that's become the de facto Detroit defense: a bailout sucks, but not bailing out Motown sucks even more. They fucked-up but YOU will suffer. So YOU should pay. NOW. BEFORE IT'S TOO LATE! Hysteria and hyperbole? You don't know the half of it. Well, not yet anyway...

Editorial: Between the Lines: David Cole and the Bridge To Nowhere

Robert Farago — Wed, 12 Nov 2008 13:04:10 +0000

David Cole is the man whose industry and union-funded Center for Automotive Research carried-out a study of the economic implications of Detroit's meltdown. The result has become the de facto standard for "this is the serious shit that will happen if we don't bailout Motown's mismanagers with federal tax money" argument. So much so that the mainstream media uses the figures without attribution. TTAC has exposed Cole's blantant self-interest in this matter. Our Best and Brightest have examined CAR's study and exposed its deep methodological flaws. While there is no doubt that a GM, Ford and/or Chrysler bankruptcy filing would create an economic catastrophe for tens of thousands of workers and hundreds of communities, exaggerating the impact for political gain is deeply immoral. And just plain wrong. Giving Cole an uncontested platform to promulgate his propaganda is, if anything, worse. And yet that's exactly what The Detroit News has done...

Editorial: Between The Lines: Barack Obama’s Shot Across Detroit’s Bow

Robert Farago — Sun, 09 Nov 2008 13:34:34 +0000

Senator and president-elect Barack Obama held his first post-election press conference on Friday-- the same day that Ford and GM revealed their respective arterial sprays of red ink and third degree cash burns. Rather than highlight those stats and go for the close, bailoutwise, Obama played his political cards close to his chest. The exact text of his remarks are extremely revealing, in that politicians don't really reveal anything unless they absolutely have to kinda way. "The auto industry is the backbone of American manufacturing and a critical part of our attempt to reduce our dependence on foreign oil." Translation?

Editorial: Between the Lines: How Detroit Drove Into a Ditch

John Horner — Wed, 29 Oct 2008 15:17:40 +0000

Paul Ingrassia's essay in The Wall Street Journal takes a stab at a question which has preoccupied me for years. How the hell did the American automotive industry, which once was the model of industrial might for the world, become a sickly embarrassment? Generally, blame is apportioned amongst these areas: management, labor unions, government, customers and bad luck. Ingrassia comes down pretty hard on management, with a supporting role for the unions.

Editorial: Between the Lines - Wall Street Journal Goes Jenkins Jr. Crazy

Michael Martineck — Wed, 22 Oct 2008 16:47:19 +0000

The Wall Street Journal’s Business World by Holman W. Jenkins Jr. exemplifies the dangers of always looking at the course through the same binoculars. His “Uncle Sam Goes Car Crazy” (WJS Oct. 22, 2008) rant is an attempt to view Detroit’s troubles through Government is Bad glasses, filtering out all other reasons for the slide. He’s wrong, and in a dangerous way.

Editorial: Between the Lines - Throwing Chrysler to the Wolves

Justin Berkowitz — Tue, 21 Oct 2008 12:58:02 +0000

The mainstream media suffers from “opinion inertia.' Once the press corps adopts a certain angle on a story, its superglue city, facts be damned. To wit: TTAC's been slamming Chrysler for horrendous product quality, bizarre model choices, asinine marketing and a bloated, piss-poor dealer network since... ever. Meanwhile, our colleagues have been playing the underdog American automaker meme. Post Cerberus purchase, they’ve been ignoring Chrysler’s failed products and telltale gaffes, such as CEO Bob Nardelli's infamous "operationally bankrupt" admission. But now that rumors of a GM - Chrysler merger have surfaced, the media's woken up. And the fangs are out.

Between the Lines: Jalopnik’s Ray Wert on GM - Chrysler Merger

Justin Berkowitz — Sat, 11 Oct 2008 12:58:45 +0000

Last night, the New York Times “broke” the story that General Motors and Chrysler/Cerberus were discussing a merger. The report lacked only one crucial component: facts. As RF reported in his initial blog on the subject, the story unravels by paragraph two. We learn that the entire story is based on “two people close to the process.” While anonymous attribution is common new industry practice, a story without independent corroboration is a nothing more than rumor— especially when it defies common sense. General Motors’ assertion that they routinely talk to other manufacturers about collaborative efforts doesn’t count. But it does reveal the truth of the matter. [Continued]

Between the Lines: Chrysler’s Electric Vehicle Charade

Justin Berkowitz — Tue, 23 Sep 2008 18:44:50 +0000

Chrysler unveiled some primo bailout bait today: three electric vehicles (EVs). Choosing CNBC as point man, ChryCo's CEO showed-off a fully electric Dodge sports car and a Jeep and minivan hybrid. While the press has been suitably impressed, pistonheads who've been following (and following and following) the hoopla surrounding GM's plug-in electric - gas hybrid Chevrolet Volt are settling-in for the long haul. Meanwhile, we must endure Auburn Hill's spin on the whole "future vehicles" thing. Or do we? Here's Chrysler press release...

Between The Lines: Bob Lutz’s “Working Hard on Tomorrow, Today”

Robert Farago — Sat, 19 Jul 2008 14:04:17 +0000

In 2001, Robert A. Lutz jumped on the GM gravy train as the automaker’s vice chairman of product development. Since then, The General has continued its inexorable march to oblivion. Car-wise, Lutz’ regime has been marked by brand-defiling badge engineering and a seemingly endless stream of “nearly there” products. And yet the automaker’s camp followers continue to give Lutz a free pass. There’s only one reason for this blind spot: they don’t pay attention to what he does OR what he says. Perhaps they failed to notice that the guy’s got a blog.

Between the Lines: Motor Trend Disses BMW. Ish.

Robert Farago — Mon, 30 Jun 2008 15:41:50 +0000

Source Interlink Media owns Motor Trend magazine. Both conglomerate and car mag are heading south, quickly, in a big way. Ad revenues and circulation are in free fall. Motor Trend (MT) is fighting for it survival with glossy pimpatorials for equally doomed advertisers. The August issue features a glossy "special advertising section" for Buick ("Drive Beautiful") and a slick "advertisement" for the Dodge Challenger ("Motor Trend drives the new Dodge Challenger Through Europe"). Meanwhile, the chronically undercapitalized columnist arthur st. antoine takes a whack at a premium car brand: BMW. Huh?

Between the Lines: Berkowitz Hits the [Toyota] Open Road

Justin Berkowitz — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:32:26 +0000

As GM’s FastLane and GMNext blogs have demonstrated, the U.S. automobile industry has fully embraced the concept of blogging-- as press release. Toyota, of course, has entered the e-fray. Their Open Road blog may do little (as in nothing) to stretch the boundaries of Web 2.0-itude, but it offers the usual insight into the corporate culture from which it sprang. ToMoCo’s plugging the new Venza crossover, designed to fill the gaping hole in their lineup between the Camry, RAV4, Highlander, FJ Cruiser, 4Runner and Sienna. Into the depths we descend...

Between The Lines: MT’s Angus MacKenzie’s on GM’s Sinking Stock Price

Edward Niedermeyer — Tue, 18 Mar 2008 11:23:48 +0000

Angus MacKenzie did everything but call TTAC by name in his essay GM Shares Tumble. So What? Yes, the Motor Trend scribe can “almost hear the Detroit death-watchers rubbing their hands with glee” at the news of GM's stock hitting two-year lows. It's true. Every time GM's share price dips, we light giant cigars, twirl our collective mustache and laugh maniacally. That Mr. MacKenzie sees critical coverage of the auto industry as journalistic schadenfreude goes some ways towards explaining Motor Trend’s increasingly toothless car reviews. But how can MacKenzie, an experienced car hack, justify pinning Detroit’s woes on anyone other than, well, Detroit? Hey, a man’s gotta eat.

Between The Lines: A Look Into Bob Lutz’ Mind

Frank Williams — Thu, 24 Jan 2008 18:36:50 +0000

GM Car Czar Bob Lutz wants you to know what's on his mind. So, at last night's Automotive News congressional confab, Maximum Bob let rip, revealing the concerns triggering the suit's septuagenarian synapses. But, as usual, there are major gaps between Bob's thoughts and actual reality.

Between The Lines: New York Times Op Ed “Et tu Toyota?”

Robert Farago — Thu, 04 Oct 2007 15:41:40 +0000

The New York Times may be called The Old Gray Lady, but I reckon it’s one of those old gray ladies you find lingering at lunch counters, constantly sticking their nose into everyone’s business. In today’s Op Ed piece, Thomas L Friedman takes Toyota to task. He's miffed that the Japanese automaker's siding with The Big 2.8 against proposed federal regs raising the required corporate average fuel economy (CAFE) figure to 35mpg by 2020. The arguments behind “Et tu Toyota?” may be old news to TTAC readers, but like the Times itself, we can’t resist a bit of nasty gossip.

Between The Lines: James May on American Cars and Food

Glenn Swanson — Mon, 17 Sep 2007 11:40:41 +0000

Top Gear (TG) presenter James May’s nickname is Captain Slow. As you’d expect from a country where sarcasm is a team sport, the moniker disses Mr. May’s driving skills. But the nickname could just as easily refer to May’s intellectual agility. Like automotive alpha Jeremy Clarkson, May is always happy to take an analytical shortcut, especially if it leads to some good old fashioned America bashing. Writing about his recent stateside sojourn in the Telegraph-- "Eat Junk, Drive Junk"-- May once again reveals that the U.S. and the UK are two nations separated by British snobbery.

Between the Lines: Lexus’ F Ad

Robert Farago — Tue, 11 Sep 2007 19:59:13 +0000

During my brief stint in British advertising, I had the distinct pleasure of working with one Paul Harvey Douglas. Paul was the world’s best headline writer. He could distill an entire advertising campaign down to a single sentence, a phrase, a word. I wonder what PHD would have made of Lexus' ad for its new F-Series automobiles. “What is F?” the two-page Autoweek center spread asks. “F is everything you thought we weren’t,” it answers. I could almost hear Paul’s derisive snort. “F means their brand’s in ‘effing trouble,” he would have pronounced. Too right, mate.

Between The Lines: Motor Trend on the 2008 Subaru WRX

Justin Berkowitz — Tue, 04 Sep 2007 16:07:52 +0000

As Motor Trend (MT) and its buff book brethren hemorrhage readers and cash to the Internet, they’ve reacted in the only way they know how: by kow-towing to their advertisers with even greater ardor and even lower journalistic standards (yes, “special advertising section” readers, it is possible). But what really galls is their continued belief that they’re superior to both Internet websites and those who visit them. MT’s first test review of the 2008 Subaru Impreza WRX is a perfect case in point.

Between The Lines: AutoWeek’s Long-Term Jaguar XK-R

Robert Farago — Thu, 30 Aug 2007 14:33:50 +0000

Press cars are specially selected, carefully prepared and meticulously maintained. Why wouldn’t they be? You can hardly expect a manufacturer to pluck a car from the assembly line and trust their model’s reputation to the vagaries of quality control-- even though the car’s less likely to receive a harsh critique than a seventh grade production of The Wizard of Oz. To their credit, the manufacturers eventually “let go;” surrendering specially selected, carefully prepared new vehicles to the buff books’ long-term fleets. When things go wrong, as they do, the result betrays the tension between payola and editorial credibility.

Between the Lines: Former Tesla CEO Martin Eberhard’s Email to Roadster Customers

Robert Farago — Tue, 14 Aug 2007 17:27:36 +0000

This website has been skeptical of Tesla Motors’ claims for their lithium-ion-powered Roadster since day one. While some readers think we’ve “had it in” for the California-based car company, rest assured TTAC is an equal opportunity muckraker. Anyway, yesterday, when Martin Eberhard revealed that he’d relinquished Tesla's top job, we held fire to avoid accusations of smug satisfaction. But Eberhard’s email to Tesla customers piqued our interest. As Tesla has yet to deliver a single customer car, by thy words thy shall be known.

Between the Lines: Car and Driver on the New Cadillac CTS

Robert Farago — Thu, 09 Aug 2007 10:22:39 +0000

Aside from ad revenue, why would a car magazine want to position itself as a cheering section for General Motors? Well exactly. Car and Driver’s September review of the “new” Cadillac CTS is such a blatant example of boosterism it puts the "sub" in "subsidy." This will come as no surprise to regular readers who’ve watched the buff book slowly sink into a glossy ghetto of pistonhead prostitution. Even so, I feel compelled to use C&D’s CTS review as a re-launching pad for Between the Lines, so that TTAC readers understand what this website stands for. Or, more precisely, against.