Fair disclosure: we stole that headline from Engadget. And boy, are we late to this story. electrifyingtimes.com reveals that the conflagration of a single "neighborhood electric vehicle" in Key West– albeit one that immolated model Veronica Webb's dog Hercules and destroyed her house– and it's pig pile on the EV, media-wise. Everyone from the New York Post's Page Six ("Hell-Car burns model's home") to El Rushbo (GM stooge that he is) have covered the story. And the majority are spinning the GEM's fiery end as reflective of inherent danger and/or a possible trend. The reverse spinmeister for the vehicle's maker, Chrysler's GEMCar, claimed that the fire was an isolated incident– as far as they know. "We have gone through our files looking for any other reports of fires relating either to use or charging of GEMs, and haven't found anything," Max Gates revealed. "We don't have anything in our records to indicate there's ever been a previous incident like this." Can you imagine the coverage if a Tesla Roadster or Chevy Volt ever appeared suffered a similar fate? [thanks to starlightmica for the tip]
21 Comments on “And you thought that laptop fire sucked…...”
Back to TopLeave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
You can also login using Facebook Connect.
Let’s tally ‘em up…
EV’s lost to fire: 1
Gas cars lost to fire: (wild guess) 10’s of thousands over the decades
My mom and dad’s Chevy Corvair nearly baked them on the California highway when it caught fire. The car was barely a year old.
I’ve owned many cars and none of them have ever caught fire.
“Burn Baby Burn, Disco Inferno”
How many Fords have started house fires due to their well known wiring harness problem?
This kind of thing is always going to happen – the question is does it happen infrequently enough to be an acceptable risk?
But risk tolerance is something that most people are really bad at evaluating in an impartial, unemotional way. Look at how worried some people are about a terrorist attack. Statistically, they should be much more worried about being hit by a bus. But that’s not as “scary”…
The plural of anecdote is not “data”.
If you squit it looks like an F150.
Crap, I’m gonna be hit by a bus?!?!? Now I’ve got to worry about that AND the TERRORISTS?!?
Gas cars lost to fire: (wild guess) 10’s of thousands over the decades
Pbbfft. There were probably that many lost in France in the past two years.
I agree that this is wildly overcooked.
And that EVs will catch stick without deserving to — unless: it could be that her GEM has been customized with a new battery pack, to extend the range and increase acceleration. There are quite a few shops that will do the honors.
In that case, you have no guarantees. You could be sitting on top of a Li-Ion battery pack just itching to begin deflagration, which is what happens when you run a battery hot to the point where it begins burning uncontrollably.
The dog bought it, which means that this is on a par with the Darfur crisis, I guess, as far as the media are concerned.
Amazing how a random story about some golf cart catching fire garners domestic bashing comments.
How do u spell a-g-e-n-d-a?
“I’ve owned many cars and none of them have ever caught fire.”
The plural of anecdote is not “data”.
I’ll keep that in mind whenever I hear some sob story about somebody’s ‘89 Cougar that suffered from spontaneous destruction.
My neighbor’s Wagoneer burned one day for no particularly good reason. Apparently Wagoneers had a habit of doing that.
He replaced it with a very sweet Mercedes 300S circa 1980. The car was previous generation to the then current pig cars (you know the Ss that looked like mid 70s Cadillacs). It had a 3 liter in-line 6. Very smooth, beautiful car.
One of my neighbors had an unscheduled carbeque with their Jeep Wrangler last summer. I wonder if there is a connection there or even worse, a conspiracy.
The GEM vehicle pictured uses lead acid batteries, same as have been used since the late 1800’s. Sh*t happens.
@Paul Niedermeyer
The GEM vehicle pictured uses lead acid batteries, same as have been used since the late 1800’s. Sh*t happens.
Yes – though I have seen GEMs modded with “custom” battery packs for greater range. Maybe an electrical fault not necessarily attributable to the pack itself?
Can you imagine the coverage if a Tesla Roadster or Chevy Volt ever appeared suffered a similar fate?
Can you imagine the coverage if Britney’s car had suffered a similar fate? … if Anna Nicole had died in the fire? … if aliens had started the fire? … if a new GEM rose from the ashes?
Imagine if we change the fundamental facts of the situation – what then? I’ve never understood the appeal of this sort of argument.
Donal:
AP is ready for Britney, they’ve already written obituary.
Follow-up article from TG Daily: unclear if this was an accidental fire or a test burn (huh?). The article also reports 2 more GEM EV fires in addition to the above two.
Car fires happen. She could have accidently dropped a Marlboro in the floor board and walked inside for all we know.
If you squint it looks like a Fiero
I dunno. Looks more like a Fuego to me.
(Or, if the owner is particularly unfortunate, a Phoenix.)