The Renault Twingo: An Explanation Of The Jeep Cherokee's New Look

Marcelo de Vasconcellos
by Marcelo de Vasconcellos

The newly shown Jeep Cherokee has created quite a ruckus. Some like the design, some describe it in language unsuitable to a family-oriented site like TTAC. The fact is Jeep needs this. The mother-ship, Fiat, is taking Jeep international and while Jeep’s design language gets good points at home, it really doesn’t strike a chord among buyers worldwide. What’s more, Jeep doesn’t have that much of a heritage outside US borders. So, the Italians are free to do with it what they like. For starters, Jeep now sponsors one of the most popular football teams in Europe. That is a sure sign that the Jeep you knew and loved is going through profound changes that will either make it relevant, or send it bruised and bleeding to lick it wounds back home.

The Twingo – polarizing, but popular

All you have to do is look at the story of the Renault Twingo to understand. Its designer, Patrick le Quément is known the world over and very influential. The Twingo was the car that made his career. The Renault establishment balked when le Quément presented his vision of the car. Undaunted, le Quément pushed it through. The car is now considered an icon of modern automobile design. If you have a pristine example, hold on to it. It might be worth a pretty penny 20 years from now.

When the 80s became the 90s, Renault was in a tough situation. Its conservative cars were quickly running out of gas in the market place. Newly hired chief designer le Quément proposed a radical new approach to design. He separated it from the engineers and product planners who, of course, were not pleased. So much so that they told le Quément the Twingo would have to be toned down from his radical vision. Le Quément appealed directly to Louis Schweitzer, Renault’s head honcho at the time: “The greatest risk is not to take any risks.”

Le Quément argued his case in a quintessentially French, counter-intuitive fashion, taking the results of the focus groups and turning them on their heads, “fifty percent of the participants hated it and 25 percent were dubious. However, 25 percent said they loved it.”

The French designer radicalizes, “retro is retrograde. It’s driving looking in the rear-view mirror, admitting that you’ve run out of ideas.” In other words, don’t just keep repeating yourself. Retro cars usually create a short bounce of excitement that the good old days are back, then their sales sink into oblivion.

Italians loved the Twingo. They bought it in droves. This story is well known in European design circles. You can bet that it was part of the reasoning for the new Jeep Cherokee. The past is fine and dandy. Nevertheless, Jeep needs to move on. I sincerely hope the lesson is not lost on the great car makers of the even greater United States of America.

Marcelo de Vasconcellos
Marcelo de Vasconcellos

More by Marcelo de Vasconcellos

Comments
Join the conversation
5 of 134 comments
  • GTAm GTAm on Feb 26, 2013

    I think the plan to go radical is a good one. It's just that the execution has gone horribly wrong IMO. The head-on pic above (taken from the top of a truck?) is the most acceptable pose for the Cherokee. But hardly anyone will see it from this angle in the showroom or on the streets. The front three quarter view looks ugly with that bulky front (overhanging) bumper and the double face looks plain silly. Considering the fact they had the very well executed Grand Cherokee as a starting point, this is just ridiculous to me. As mentioned in other comments, this isn't a risk Jeep can afford to take at this point when it's cautiously trying to establish itself as a global brand. The Twingo 1 is a neat, cute well proportioned design and a lot more acceptable. This should be compared with the 90's Fiat Miltipla and maybe the 90's Euro Scorpio. They both flopped. I sincerely hope they do a pre-launch facelift.

    • See 2 previous
    • Marcelo de Vasconcellos Marcelo de Vasconcellos on Feb 27, 2013

      @GTAm So, further reason to take the Jeep even further away from its roots. As the Cherokee is now officially a soft roader, the design has to be "radical" to appeal to this kind of, largely, urbanite buyer. The 500L is being turned into an SUV/CUV. It's called 500X and TTAC even posted a pic of it. I have also seen pics of the Punto based Jeep. For Jeep fans, at least the initial sketched it had round front lights (though due to Cherokee's looks, I bet that won't last). It looks pretty good, but I'm sure the purists will knck it. ANother winner in a merket that's growing like crazy (Duster, EcSport, Honda Urban SUV or something, VW CUV based on up!). People want this kind of car for some reason.

  • Skink Skink on Feb 27, 2013

    Lower grille opening looks like tiki god mouth. On the dark-colored car, the seven slots look like tiki god teeth. The squinty lights look like squinty tiki god eyes. Behold the Jeep Tiki. Available in woodgrain.

  • TheEndlessEnigma Of course they should unionize. US based automotive production component production and auto assembly plants with unionized memberships produce the highest quality products in the automotive sector. Just look at the high quality products produced by GM, Ford and Chrysler!
  • Redapple2 Got cha. No big.
  • Theflyersfan The wheel and tire combo is tragic and the "M Stripe" has to go, but overall, this one is a keeper. Provided the mileage isn't 300,000 and the service records don't read like a horror novel, this could be one of the last (almost) unmodified E34s out there that isn't rotting in a barn. I can see this ad being taken down quickly due to someone taking the chance. Recently had some good finds here. Which means Monday, we'll see a 1999 Honda Civic with falling off body mods from Pep Boys, a rusted fart can, Honda Rot with bad paint, 400,000 miles, and a biohazard interior, all for the unrealistic price of $10,000.
  • Theflyersfan Expect a press report about an expansion of VW's Mexican plant any day now. I'm all for worker's rights to get the best (and fair) wages and benefits possible, but didn't VW, and for that matter many of the Asian and European carmaker plants in the south, already have as good of, if not better wages already? This can drive a wedge in those plants and this might be a case of be careful what you wish for.
  • Jkross22 When I think about products that I buy that are of the highest quality or are of great value, I have no idea if they are made as a whole or in parts by unionized employees. As a customer, that's really all I care about. When I think about services I receive from unionized and non-unionized employees, it varies from C- to F levels of service. Will unionizing make the cars better or worse?
Next