Piston Slap: A Sticky Subie Situation?

Sajeev Mehta
by Sajeev Mehta

TTAC commentator gessvt writes:

Sajeev –

Looking for some advice on a “to sell or not to sell” situation. A little background: I’ve been a fairly faithful Blue Oval guy for most of my driving years, with a few brief forays into cheap, reliable imports for college duty, and a recent contract gig that required me to drive The General’s products (GMC Sierra 4×4, Saab 9-5 Aero and Chevy Cobalt SS). We also own a trouble free Monterey minivan and a perfect ’93 5.0 notchback. My new job has no such requirement, so I made the decision to pay cash for a unique, fun, safe daily driver.

I’m outside of Chicago, and with the exception of this year, am usually subjected to significant snowfall and slow-to-react city


plowing service. A friend left his WRX wagon with me last winter so that a local body shop buddy could do a quick bumper respray in order to sell it. We had a blizzard during this time, and the WRX had Blizzaks, so I drove it around and was *hooked*. This car had too many miles and had been subjected to his car-guy wrath, so I searched for the Holy Grail of Subarus: the 2005 Legacy GT 5-speed wagon.

After a few months, I found one with 60,000 miles, had the dealer replace the clutch (first warning sign), and paid cash for it. Since then, I’ve put 20,000 miles on it, and have really enjoyed the car…when something wasn’t going wrong with it. In 12 months, the following repairs have occurred:

  • replaced a hung up front brake caliper and pads/rotors (did both sides to be safe)
  • chased down an intermittent cylinder misfire and poor idle (replaced intake manifold gaskets, air fuel sensor and a fuel injector)
  • had a wheel bearing replaced under a Subaru TSB.

It sounds like another wheel bearing is getting ready to die, the 3rd gear synchro grinds (something I attributed to the weak clutch before I purchased), and one of the new front calipers got hung up on my drive to work this morning.

I’m at the point where I think I should fix the synchro and other misc issues and unload the car. At 80,000 miles, it’s still worth about what I paid for it. I love the power, the way it looks and drives and the poor weather performance, but I’m thinking that I’ve purchased a sorely neglected or problematic car. It may have turned me away from turbo Subarus for good. My question for the B&B: sell it and head back to Ford, or suck it up and drive it?

Apologies for the wordy rant.

Sajeev answers:

OMG SON! You said “perfect ’93 5.0 notchback” and…now that’s all I can think about.

Mmmmmmmm, Fox Body. (drooling)

Well then! I understand your Subie situation and agree with your assessment. Turbo and manual transmission optioned Subarus are a serious threat to your wallet when purchasing on the used car market: they are too fragile for the abuse that might be thrown at them. And it sounds like you are one of the unlucky ones. Not a big deal, since we all know that true Internet Pistonhead street cred comes from owning a wagon with a diesel and a stick. The Internet does not lie, you aren’t that cool.

I would do the bare minimum to the car for reconditioning, and let your service records do the talking. You obviously loved the car enough to write this well crafted letter to Piston Slap, so I suggest you take all those receipts (that you saved) and put them in a cheapo 3-ring binder. Presentation is everything in selling a niche vehicle like this. If your receipts show you care, the potential buyer will appreciate it…and won’t be so mad when stuff breaks on their clock.

And since you are a Ford guy, the 5.0 and the Mercury van need a Panther or Ranger 4×4 companion. Obviously! Too bad I can’t decide which is better for you!

Send your queries to sajeev@thetruthaboutcars.com. Spare no details and ask for a speedy resolution if you’re in a hurry.

Sajeev Mehta
Sajeev Mehta

More by Sajeev Mehta

Comments
Join the conversation
5 of 40 comments
  • Vvk Vvk on Apr 25, 2012

    I have owned 5 Subarus, have had several in the extended family and several owned by friends. I see nothing unusual in this story. These problems are minor and common. My advise: learn to double clutch. Keep your car.

    • CJinSD CJinSD on Apr 27, 2012

      Is it possible that the all cars are now good and reliable myth exists because most people who buy bad cars never buy good ones to compare them to?

  • Luke42 Luke42 on Apr 26, 2012

    "Looking for some advice on a “to sell or not to sell” situation. A little background: I’ve been a fairly faithful Blue Oval guy for most of my driving years"... I wanted a diesel-powered 2005 Subaru Outback Wagon (which doesn't exist here in the USA), but I ended up purchasing a Ford Escape V6 AWD -- mostly because the Escape is cheaper, and because Ford is the devil I know. To be honest, the Ford Escape clearly solves the same problem as the Outback. Yes, the engine is in the compartment sideways, and it's taller and more-truck-looking than it needs to be. But, when you look past the cosmetics, the Escape really is the American Subaru. It's a pretty good to all-weather all-wheel-drive family transportation that can do light towing. Only downsides are the looks and the MPGs. The same could be said for the Subaru, though, and Ford's been steadily improving the Escape's MPGs over time, and Subaru has been doing the same for their models. An Escape is worth considering as a replacement for the Subie. For all of its faults, the Escape solves the same problem with roughly the same weight/efficiency/capability envelope, and lightly-used ones are fairly cheap. I'm not actually recommending an Escape, but I am pointing out that these vehicles are much more comparable than they appear at first glance.

    • See 1 previous
    • Ubermensch Ubermensch on Apr 26, 2012

      @mnm4ever I was going to say the same thing but you beat me to it. I drive a Leggy 2.5i wagon and a friend has a 2010?(does the year really matter when talking about the Escape) Escape and they are words apart in how they drive. I will take my slow Legacy over the V6 Escape any day of the week. My in-laws have a 2007 Outback and again, I would take that over the Escape any day. Now the new Escape?...looking mighty interesting to me.

Next